a good example of a good game that doesnt need mp is mgs4 the story makes up for it which is why it got the scores it did. and an example of a great game with a not so good story but amazing mp is gears of war and halo 3.desyple
But MGS4 wasnt an FPS, and Im not one of those guys who gets anal when you talk about TPS in the same category of FPS. MGS4 just doesnt belong in this discussion at all.
I bought Gears for the SP, and I acutally enjoyed the story. Sure it was short and lacked some real depth, but it was still enjoyable.
An FPSRPG (Fallout 3, BioShock, SS2, etc.) obviously doesn't need multiplayer.
An FPS like Metroid Prime doesn't need multiplayer.
MetroidPrimePwn
Yet the only game you mentioned that is a true FPSRPG is Fallout 3. SS2 was more of a FPS Survival Horror, and Bioshock was a lame attempt to recreate SS2 in a different setting.
I think it depends on the game, and how fulfilling it is. The Half-life games and Metroid Prime games although lacking MP dont really leave you feeling like you wished you had more. Then you have games like Halo and Gears, and although I admit I do enjoy the SP version of Gears, I know that it was the MP that was its saving grace. It was obvious that those games were designed with MP in mind and it really shows. I think when it comes to games like Bioshock, a game that lacks any content at all, should have MP if theyre not going to give any SP incentive. Bioshock was a game that had no unlockable features, no extra skins, the gameplay was severely linear so there wasnt really any going back and looking for a different approach through different areas. There was no extra modes to play around with. The game had nothing but a SP campaign that can be completed in 6 hours.........8 if you take your time. Once you complete it, then what? Whats there to keep the average player, playing? Theres nothing.
So some games need MP to keep it going, and others can do fine without it. It all comes down to the game. Unfortunately with the direction the gaming industry is headed, all games are going to have MP forced into it in one way or another.
Log in to comment