Thanks very much for your feedback :)
Thats what I enjoy - and why I upgraded my account in the first place - to access your huge library of HD videos that shows games in all their glorious details. Whenever I download a HD, I always keep them because I always end up looking back at them to show friends & family when they pop over, because they are keen gamers as well.
You do have a good point about the resources HD Quicktime uses; I tried it out on my quad core CPU,using real-time monitoring & my video I edited as seen in 1st post as the example. I was skipping forward to a point in QuickTime & it uses 22% of the CPU... playing it normally uses 7%. Bear in mind I only encoded it using a bitrate of 1.38Mbps - but thats the typical resource demand of HD these days. Your huge 941Mb video that was encoded @14Mbps, used 30% skipping forward to a point & 28% playing it normally, which rules out a lot of single core CPU thats people maybe using to view it. If you use anything under 10Mb then it uses up only 17% CPU whilst playing, meaning more single core users can view it without any stuttering or other issues.
I also compared that to a WMVHD video (C&C - Kane's Wrath On the Spot HD Demo @7Mbps) and the CPU usuage is alot lower when playing the video, it used just 6% CPU using Windows Media Player. So theres a case there for a HD download to offer for MAC in the H264 codec & a separate HD download for PC using the better WMVHD codec that I love. By the way, I ran the H264 on my PC in full screen & its plays perfectly...lucky me. But it used a big 36% of my CPU to do it which is why many might have issues.
As I said above, when I download HD movie trailers, I prefer the highest quality possible to be at 6-7Mbps with 2-pass VBR. I use this setting for my own family DVDs in Adobe Premiere 2. I know its always trial & error, deciding the time it takes to encode them speed vs quality & getting them uploaded to everyone without it taking ages. Do you think your servers are struggling with demand? Because if they were fast enough or you had more of them, you would negate this issue completely & keep the highest quality.
Anyway, I am really pleased to here of big changes coming to GS to help improve the video quality & service to everyone. And I wish you luck for these exciting changes & hope it really works out for everyone involved. Could you provide this thread with news on the changes in video quality to come - I don't like waiting too long for great news like this or mind you 'going overboard' at all :)
Log in to comment