Well I guess I'm a retard for saying Tom Brady is better oh wait thats right Colts fans will say Manning is better because there Colts fans just like I think Brady is better because I'm a Patriots fan. This discussion is getting so old now everyone has different opinions on it most people say ones better because they hate the other one. Ok since the defense wins for him lets rewind to 2005 the defense stunk for the most part of the season and Tom Brady had his best season and they still went to the playoffs. This past season if that Colts defense didn't step up we wouldn't be talking about how Manning won his ring because they would've been shut out at Baltimore luckily they have the best kicker in all of football and the defense played great.