Hmm. I guess I am bit privileged to have a nice PC, because from my perspective the Wii U has always seemed to be the better choice - at least out of the PS4 and XBone. 90% of releases for those consoles are also available on the PC, so no problems there. And the Wii U lets me play all the excellent Nintendo exclusives. I guess what I'm saying is the PC is the far superior choice, but the Wii U is a good supplementary console.

@Dannystaples14: I would have perhaps worded it less harshly, but I agree. I loved Shadow of the Colossus when I was younger and still have a lot of respect for what it did to the gaming industry, but the gameplay has not aged well. I found myself much more frustrated when I replayed it recently than I remember being originally.

@Bowser05 They played the European version. The US version has been announced, but no release date yet ("December 31, 2014" is Gamespot's way of saying "sometime in 2014").

@Fireheart89 How many games has Nintendo released recently that have gotten under an 8? Not many, but they release one dud and suddenly everything they've ever produced is bad and they're failures. Can you people give them a break?

@helbertpina Came down here to post the exact same thing haha

The only category where I could see every single nominee as a potential winner. Though it'll probably be Zelda or Animal Crossing.

Any of those three indie titles deserve to win. It's about time they got the recognition they deserve.

I haven't been able to put a finger on my dissatisfaction with the 360 as of late, but this about sums it up. Not a single exclusive!

It's got to be The Last of Us or Ni no Kuni. The other games are great and all, but those two are great AND exclusive.

Heck, if you released a game on the XBone it has like a 50% chance of making this list regardless of its content!