1. Mario 64
2. Mario World
3. Mario Bros 3
4. Sunshine
5. New Super Mario Bros
5. Mario Bros
6. Mario Bros 2

Mario 64 is my all time favorite game. Mario World, Bros 3, and Sunshine were all just about eually excellent. New Super Mario Bros was also fantastic. Mario Bros was simple fun back in the day, and Mario Bros 2 was a decent game on it's own right

I don't own a Wii, so I can't play Galaxy. But once I buy one, Galaxy will definitely be the first game I play

Spore. People were expecting this game to be huge since early 05.Then it hits and it is very underwhelming

Everyone knew that Too Human was probably going to be less than stellar ever since the Unreal engine problems popped up a year ago. The hype dwindled, people were expecting a train wreck, and that's just what we got. It was a flop, but it kind of became expected to be a flop. Spore was just flat out dissapointing, and that is so much worse. 

Sony 06 was decent with some hysterically awkward/dumb moments, but at least it was interesting to watch.

Nintendo in 07 and 08 was godawful on the other hand. So friggin boring, dissapointing, and depressing to watch as an old fan. 

Bioshock

With a lack of a PS3 and Wii I am seriously missing out some serious contenders though. I'm sure that LittleBigPlanet and Super Mario Galaxy (ecspecially) would put up exceptional fights for the top spot. 

• Super Mario 64
• Sonic the Hedgehog 3 & Knuckles
• Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2
• Burnout 3
• Banjo-Kazooie
• Crash Bandicoot
• Yoshi's Island
• Super Mario Bros 3 
• Ninja Gaiden (xbox)
• Wipeout Pure