Best RPG ? ( Poll )

Amongst recent quality RPG games , which one you prefer ? You can include any other of your favourite rpg game not included in the list .

I voted Demons Souls :)

Mask of the Betrayer.

Either The Witcher or Mask of the Betrayer for me.

None of the five in your poll would make my top five list for this gen. Some might be in the top ten though, maybe.

Fallout New Vegas > Fallout3 imo

Id say The Witcher, Fallout New Vegas, Mask of the Betrayer, Origins or Risen is my fav rpg so far this gen.

Wierd why The Witcher wasnt on the list in the poll though.

I also liked Alpha Protocol, Drakensang and Lost Odyssey more then Oblivion/Fallout3 personally.

Wierd why The Witcher wasnt on the list in the poll though.

kozzy1234

*looks at the TC*

Nope,not weird at all...

Well first off to be technical you should drop the word game after saying RPG, otherwise you're saying role-playing game game. But anyway, I think we throw around the title RPG too much. A shooter with RPG elements such as stat building is, in my mind, not an RPG.

Demons Souls.

My answer: none of the above.

Demon's Souls

My favorite RPG's this gen are Fallout 3, Mass Effect series, Tales of Vesperia, and Lost Odyssey. So one of those.

Demon's Souls.

Out of that lists... and basing it off of when it came out... not todays views. Def oblivion. Never put so much time into a game.. AMAZING!

Demon's Souls. Mass Effect 2 was better, but I played it like a shooter :D

Out of those, demon souls because mass effect 2 is not a rpg imo.

Mass Effect 2 is more of FPS with RPG elements. Its hardly an RPG, but whatever.

From the list I will go with Fallout 3.

Overall I will go with Gothic 2 or Morrowind.

The Witcher

DA :O

Best RPG of all time comes out this tuesday (TW2 of course.)

Out of those: Demons Souls was the only one that was even good. Granted, Demons souls fantastic.

However I prefer the likes of

Mask of the Betrayer
The Witcher
Mount and Blade Warband
Risen
Age of Decadence

Now I will explain why the rest of the list were bad games.

Dragon Age: Origins: Utterly cliche, dumbed down gameplay from BG, very repetitive, with copy paste encounters. Basicly this is Baldur's Gate without the qualities of Baldur's Gate.
Mass Effect 2: The shooting sucked, the roleplaying sucked even more, the plot horrible as well and outside of Garrus and Tali, I didnt care for any of the cast, especially Miranda and Jack.
Fallout 3: Bland environments, horrid writing, horrid story, quests and solutions that felt so out of place (vampires, really), gunplay was bad too. Completely went against the design and lore of Fallout.
Oblivion: One of the worst games made this gen, awful main story, copy paste environments, level scaling like you wouldnt believe with bandits in daedric, awful minigames, combat that somehow managed to be worse than Morrowind (yes, its worse than morrowind), boring planes of oblivion, broken buggy mess with thousands of bugs, horrible levelling system, awful, linear quests.

Best RPG of all time comes out this tuesday (TW2 of course.)

ChubbyGuy40

From those list I've only played DA:O and Oblivion. I picked Oblivion, I think I've put in 200+ hours into it.

If older games are included Diablo 2 is the best RPG for me.

[QUOTE="ChubbyGuy40"]

Best RPG of all time comes out this tuesday (TW2 of course.)

KalDurenik

Why do you say no to something like that? It sure looks ambitious enough, why could it not pass planescape torment?

Oh you've played it? No, didn't think so.

[QUOTE="ChubbyGuy40"]

Best RPG of all time comes out this tuesday (TW2 of course.)

KalDurenik

I also don't think that Torment will be dethroned any time soon, but if any game stands a chance...it might just be TW2.

[QUOTE="ChubbyGuy40"]

Best RPG of all time comes out this tuesday (TW2 of course.)

KalDurenik

Opinions man!

Plus I've never played Planetscape and have no interest to do so unless they do a remake.

I havent played Demon Souls, maybe Dark Souls will change my opinion. So far:

1 - Oblivion

2 - Mass Effect 1

3 - Mass Effect 2

Fallout 3 and Fallout: New Vegas are the only RPG's I've played and liked.

Demons souls is the only console game ive liked this gen

thats who i voted for

The Witcher

I'd probably go with New Vegas

Fallout: New Vegas, easily.

Risen and Mount&Blade: Warband are my recent favourites. Divinity II was good too (although I have yet to try its enhanced re-release).

From the poll - Fallout 3

Overall - The Witcher or Fallout: New Vegas

From this generation the top 3 RPGs are...

1. Persona 4
2. Valkyria Chronicles
3. Mass Effect

Persona 4 is the best game I've played all gen, not just RPG.