As fun as Halo 4 is, I can't help but shake the "Same old, same old" feeling I get from it everytime I play. The Walking Dead and Journey are miles more interesting.
Aside from Fez & The Walking Dead (2 other downloadable indie games), all the other games you mentioned are shooters. At this point in this console generation, no shooter deserves GOTY.
Your argument makes no sense and shows why most people who support XBL Gold are mindless sheep. You pretty much think XBL Gold is better than PSN because you pay $60/year for it...
ForceofNature9's comments