Depending on who you are.

User Rating: 5.3 | The History Channel: Civil War - A Nation Divided X360
I played it, and i didn't mind it, it is a nice set back, something different finally..

The graphics, while detailed, framerate drops occasionally, you can't say you never saw it, because that would be a lie, but from an artistic perpective, it looks good, who ever designed the art obviously is a pro

Sound, oh my god the sound is somewhat terrible, or is it just me, i dunno, but i didn't like the sound at all, the sounds sometimes overpowered and sometimes extremely weak.

Gameplay is extremely awful, i was set back a whole level just because i didn't save before i died. The AI is no walk in the park either, it is smart sometimes, but it gets tedious to watch you men get shot because they never took cover.

Guns are awfully designed, none of them are forgiving enough to let you reload in a couple seconds, sure it is realistic but I don't care, it takes forever, i was probably able to go out to dinner, and comeback to a loaded gun, thats how long it takes to reload.

The last paragraph. It would have been worth the purchase, figuring it had multiplayer, but no, it doesn't, for a game of this type, you wouldv'e expected multiplayer...