For me a RPG is more about role playing game play. This includes meaningful player control character growth comes from and that includes gear, stats and abilities. Respecing does ruins it.

This lead to what your character(s) is good and bad at. The problem with the action elements is that it more about what you the player is good at. It is hard role playing a character when they are actively diminishing the same character.

I didn't like the story but I'm happy you enjoy it. One of the worse part is there a people trying to claim that turn base part of gaming is now out of date.

Not action. That just hurt the RPG. I can not think of a action RPG that I would place as a top RPG.

The problem with Skyrim and Fallout 4 is the action elements they added to the game play.

I find action RPG to be commonly never as good as other RPG. The action elements are what hurts the game.

I would love paid mods by Obsidian. New Vegas show what some paid mods can be like.

I think Bethesda is good at crafting the world itself. IT is a shame they been reducing the role playing in them.

CDprojektred... I think they are bit to praised but I did quite The Witcher 3 because I did not enjoy it. I just do not like the way the game play.

I only played Xenoblade and I did not like it. I find action RPG to be poor as RPG and as action games.

I hate to say this but many of the current RPG are a down grade when you compare them to older RPG

Right now the only hope is paid mods.

It is foolish to think what the very start is what it would be like later. As I said before the indie game market when it first came out was flooded by crappy game and now there are many loved indie games. Paid mods came out and people just beating it before see anything like a settled market. We also know it can be a good thing as the video I link talk about where it been used and is a good thing.

I don't think it working and it does not allow small companies a real chance to work on mods. I just do not think that patreon is good enough.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wsi7DbCd0BU please watch this. He explain about paid mods and where the market been.

Well at best it like a green apple compare to a red apple unless you want to keep dying them pink.

Third party support or paid mods offer everything that the indie game scene offer and I can see them offering more. I find it hard to see a real different between the two.

Who do you think will make these paid mods? It would be the small devs that makes them and those devs work on indie games. I would love to see what can be done with skyrim with a full time dev making a total conversion for it. Just think of what could be when they do not need to reinvent the wheel and instead focus on what they want to do. I know many love the ideal of innovation but this could push gaming to new ideal while keeping the polish of higher tier games. How could I not like that ideal?

As with any market there will people trying to scam others but you can not just pick the most exterem cases and say that is what the market will be after it goes into a more settled state. I remember indie games that were copy of free games being sold. Kickstarted had a man sell dice he claim to need more money to finish but it turn out a company was already making it.

I say let it goes and see what happens before we start screaming how bad it is.

Is it wrong to force people to pay for indie games?

The only thing that is garbage is the way many just whined about it. With no true proof we have people going on a witch hunt. From what I heard and reached about them and how they affect the flight sims, they offer

Do not whine about this if you have ever talk good about indie games!

Nothing really stood out.

Anthem looks dull.