I think to call some thing better for the industry than something else you have to take everything in to account. Doom moved the industry forward in many many ways. Half life moved the industry forward in terms of stroy and theatrical style game play. Halo also moved the industry forward in terms of story, gameplay and truthfully helped launch xbox live. So to say that one is better than the other in terms of impact is quite childish. Rather, one should look at what and how each game impacted the industry and changed the coarse of gaming for years to come...
-HCMF-'s comments