OMFG Alan Wake >>>>>> Heavy Rain.

[QUOTE="Kandlegoat"]

the games arent comparable whatsoever.

delta3074

id rather take out my garbage and walk my dog and call that a game then watch someone doing menial tasks.

[QUOTE="Kandlegoat"]

the games arent comparable whatsoever.

Cruncha_Munch

yeah...both are story driven...but so are alot of games...I guess Alan Wake is similiar to Planescape Torment now?

if anything i'd say..

Heavy Rain is a Crime Thriller like the Movie Seven.

and Alan Wake is a Psychological Mystery ala Twin Peaks.

[QUOTE="Kandlegoat"]

the games arent comparable whatsoever.

Cruncha_Munch

alright lets compare heavy rain, alan wake to GOW3. Both interacting , story games. :P

[QUOTE="delta3074"][QUOTE="Kandlegoat"]

the games arent comparable whatsoever.

clone01

[QUOTE="Kandlegoat"]

the games arent comparable whatsoever.

delta3074

[QUOTE="Cruncha_Munch"][QUOTE="Kandlegoat"]

the games arent comparable whatsoever.

Ribnarak

alright lets compare heavy rain, alan wake to GOW3. Both interacting , story games. :P

[QUOTE="delta3074"][QUOTE="Kandlegoat"]

the games arent comparable whatsoever.

sherman-tank1

[QUOTE="Cruncha_Munch"][QUOTE="Kandlegoat"]

the games arent comparable whatsoever.

Ribnarak

alright lets compare heavy rain, alan wake to GOW3. Both interacting , story games. :P

it's just my personal opinion dude, i am sure the games are actually very good, they are just not my cup of tea, the lack of total control of my character frustrates me to hell and back, to say alan wake looks better than heavy rain is silly though, it may be QTE, but it looks sweetdelta3074

[QUOTE="Ribnarak"]

[QUOTE="Cruncha_Munch"] Right becuasee Alan Wake has nothing to do with being story drivin or interacting with the enviorment? Ueah right Come on people. Cruncha_Munch

alright lets compare heavy rain, alan wake to GOW3. Both interacting , story games. :P

hack adn slash is upto the player, i could if i wanted to not press so many buttons at once.

I almost puked watching that crap

[QUOTE="sherman-tank1"]

[QUOTE="delta3074"]spot on,ones a survival horror the other is a QTE borefestdelta3074

But the thing is, is heavy rain isn't like any game on any platform. If it's not easy to tell from the trailers, the review talks all about it. An interactive movie, made along a movie script, WITH QTE events but based mainly on the detective story.
I just find it funny that it's supposed to be a pretty unique title, yet you know what it's already all about.

I already know Alan Wake will be bad because any game with spirits as the enemy tend to be pretty bad. "OH NO, THERE'S A SPIRIT! HURRY SHINE YOUR FLASH LIGHT ON IT!"

I like using your format of replies to form my own :]. I should do this more often.

[QUOTE="gamer-adam1"]

i doubht many gamers would play Heavy Rain now adays, maybe in the past but most people want shooters

clone01

guys im gonna go on youtube and im gonna do all these tasks and you can even direct me, you just say do this and I will do it, its great watching me brush my teeth, or brush my hair, and the graphics are welll, photorealistic.

[QUOTE="delta3074"][QUOTE="sherman-tank1"]You've played Heavy Rain? I didn't know it was already out.

Some-Mist

But the thing is, is heavy rain isn't like any game on any platform. If it's not easy to tell from the trailers, the review talks all about it. An interactive movie, made along a TV script, WITH QTE events but based mainly on the detective story.
I just find it funny that it's supposed to be a pretty unique title, yet you know what it's already all about.

I already know Alan Wake will be bad because any game with spirits as the enemy tend to be pretty bad. "OH NO, THERE'S A SPIRIT! HURRY SHINE YOUR FLASH LIGHT ON IT!"

I like using your format of replies to form my own :]. I should do this more often.

lol watch someone comment on what you said and actually argue about what youve said. :P That would be sad, and yet i wouldnt be surprised if the TC went: "Shining flash lights on spirits is more fun than HR"

Whats he going to do next go shake his controller why he is in the shower. LMAOCruncha_Munch

guys im gonna go on youtube and im gonna do all these tasks and you can even direct me, you just say do this and I will do it, its great watching me brush my teeth, or brush my hair, and the graphics are welll, photorealistic.

Idream2010

I think I figured out why these must be big issues for you. I mean if you don't even like brushing your teeth or doing basic stuff like your hair in real life, of course you're not going to like doing it in a videogame.

I have to say that thefirst 9 minuteslooks really boring and lame. but i havent played it so im reserving judgement. i saw allen wake and it looks boring and lame too. we'll know when those games come out though.

maybe it doesnt appeal to us because it was made for japanese gamers. who knows

[QUOTE="delta3074"][QUOTE="sherman-tank1"]You've played Heavy Rain? I didn't know it was already out.

Some-Mist

But the thing is, is heavy rain isn't like any game on any platform. If it's not easy to tell from the trailers, the review talks all about it. An interactive movie, made along a movie script, WITH QTE events but based mainly on the detective story.
I just find it funny that it's supposed to be a pretty unique title, yet you know what it's already all about.

I already know Alan Wake will be bad because any game with spirits as the enemy tend to be pretty bad. "OH NO, THERE'S A SPIRIT! HURRY SHINE YOUR FLASH LIGHT ON IT!"

I like using your format of replies to form my own :]. I should do this more often.

[QUOTE="Idream2010"]

guys im gonna go on youtube and im gonna do all these tasks and you can even direct me, you just say do this and I will do it, its great watching me brush my teeth, or brush my hair, and the graphics are welll, photorealistic.

Some-Mist

I think I figured out why these must be big issues for you. I mean if you don't even like brushing your teeth or doing basic stuff like your hair in real life, of course you're not going to like doing it in a videogame.

You have a furry for an avatar,you shouldnt be making fun of anyone else.

The graphics look photo surreal

The graphics look photo surreal

HermitGTX

I loled.

[QUOTE="Some-Mist"]

[QUOTE="delta3074"]i already know it's a borefest because for me ANY QTE game is a borefest, i don't need to play it to know it will bore me to tearsdelta3074

But the thing is, is heavy rain isn't like any game on any platform. If it's not easy to tell from the trailers, the review talks all about it. An interactive movie, made along a movie script, WITH QTE events but based mainly on the detective story.
I just find it funny that it's supposed to be a pretty unique title, yet you know what it's already all about.

I already know Alan Wake will be bad because any game with spirits as the enemy tend to be pretty bad. "OH NO, THERE'S A SPIRIT! HURRY SHINE YOUR FLASH LIGHT ON IT!"

I like using your format of replies to form my own :]. I should do this more often.

now, does that mean the game is going to be bad. It will build on previous ideas and make them better, thats what devs try to do. ITs like saying Uncharted 2 gameplay has been done before, meaning it will not do well. BUt look how that turned out.

all im saying is, if somethings good, devs should just use the same formula with ssome enhancements to make it even better. I dont want NEW things all time, i would be so happy if U3 was like U2 but with a few more things.

[QUOTE="Some-Mist"]

[QUOTE="delta3074"]i already know it's a borefest because for me ANY QTE game is a borefest, i don't need to play it to know it will bore me to tearsdelta3074

But the thing is, is heavy rain isn't like any game on any platform. If it's not easy to tell from the trailers, the review talks all about it. An interactive movie, made along a movie script, WITH QTE events but based mainly on the detective story.
I just find it funny that it's supposed to be a pretty unique title, yet you know what it's already all about.

I already know Alan Wake will be bad because any game with spirits as the enemy tend to be pretty bad. "OH NO, THERE'S A SPIRIT! HURRY SHINE YOUR FLASH LIGHT ON IT!"

I like using your format of replies to form my own :]. I should do this more often.

but my point being, how do you know it's not unique? how do you know the game doesn't present different gameplay elements not found in any other game? because you watched gameplay videos?
I'm just trying to show you that sure, you can form your opinion about the game without having already played it. Your opinion just isn't credible. I mean that may not be a big deal to you, but I don't really like when people look at my replies as a joke, when they aren't meant to be humorous.

IMO, I'm excited for both games. Possibly Alan Wake a little more so than HR (since I've been following Alan Wake since my TFC days). However, I see what heavy rain 'could be' and the potential geniusness behind it. I also never played a game made along-side a movie script :D so I'm wondering if the story telling is going to be even better than that of MGS.

The graphics look photo surreal

HermitGTX

[QUOTE="delta3074"][QUOTE="Some-Mist"]

But the thing is, is heavy rain isn't like any game on any platform. If it's not easy to tell from the trailers, the review talks all about it. An interactive movie, made along a movie script, WITH QTE events but based mainly on the detective story.
I just find it funny that it's supposed to be a pretty unique title, yet you know what it's already all about.

I already know Alan Wake will be bad because any game with spirits as the enemy tend to be pretty bad. "OH NO, THERE'S A SPIRIT! HURRY SHINE YOUR FLASH LIGHT ON IT!"

I like using your format of replies to form my own :]. I should do this more often.

Ribnarak

now, does that mean the game is going to be bad. It will build on previous ideas and make them better, thats what devs try to do. ITs like saying Uncharted 2 gameplay has been done before, meaning it will not do well. BUt look how that turned out.

all im saying is, if somethings good, devs should just use the same formula with ssome enhancements to make it even better. I dont want NEW things all time, i would be so happy if U3 was like U2 but with a few more things.

[QUOTE="HermitGTX"]

The graphics look photo surreal

mrmusicman247

I think it's great! I can't wait to play this mega exciting game!

I can not see how anyone can try and claim they are 2 different games. that is BS. And nothing more then trying to use a fake defense to cover that how lame HR is looking now. They are both interative thriller type games. Yes they both have a different story. But they are both clearly interactive thriller games. So tell me again how they are not in the same game type? Yeah really you can't so stop making such BS claims. Again do they both have a different story yes agreed. But do they both fall into the same game type of interactive stroy games. yes they do FACT.Cruncha_Munch

lolwut?

I guess Mass Effect and Uncharted 2 are the exact same type of games because you can use guns in both. :o

[QUOTE="Ribnarak"]

[QUOTE="delta3074"]because it's not unique, it will be the same as farhenhiet (indigo prophecy) and its the same concept and principle to games like myst,it's nothing new, it's been done before delta3074

now, does that mean the game is going to be bad. It will build on previous ideas and make them better, thats what devs try to do. ITs like saying Uncharted 2 gameplay has been done before, meaning it will not do well. BUt look how that turned out.

all im saying is, if somethings good, devs should just use the same formula with ssome enhancements to make it even better. I dont want NEW things all time, i would be so happy if U3 was like U2 but with a few more things.

your 'personal opinion' is just very generic and uninformed.

I remember when I used to be stubborn.

[QUOTE="mrmusicman247"]

[QUOTE="HermitGTX"]

The graphics look photo surreal

HermitGTX

I think it's great! I can't wait to play this mega exciting game!

Just when i thought you couldn't get any cooler

[QUOTE="delta3074"][QUOTE="Some-Mist"]

But the thing is, is heavy rain isn't like any game on any platform. If it's not easy to tell from the trailers, the review talks all about it. An interactive movie, made along a movie script, WITH QTE events but based mainly on the detective story.
I just find it funny that it's supposed to be a pretty unique title, yet you know what it's already all about.

I already know Alan Wake will be bad because any game with spirits as the enemy tend to be pretty bad. "OH NO, THERE'S A SPIRIT! HURRY SHINE YOUR FLASH LIGHT ON IT!"

I like using your format of replies to form my own :]. I should do this more often.

Some-Mist

but my point being, how do you know it's not unique? how do you know the game doesn't present different gameplay elements not found in any other game? because you watched gameplay videos?
I'm just trying to show you that sure, you can form your opinion about the game without having already played it. Your opinion just isn't credible. I mean that may not be a big deal to you, but I don't really like when people look at my replies as a joke, when they aren't meant to be humorous.

IMO, I'm excited for both games. Possibly Alan Wake a little more so than HR (since I've been following Alan Wake since my TFC days). However, I see what heavy rain 'could be' and the potential geniusness behind it. I also never played a game made along-side a movie script :D so I'm wondering if the story telling is going to be even better than that of MGS.

[QUOTE="delta3074"][QUOTE="Ribnarak"]

now, does that mean the game is going to be bad. It will build on previous ideas and make them better, thats what devs try to do. ITs like saying Uncharted 2 gameplay has been done before, meaning it will not do well. BUt look how that turned out.

all im saying is, if somethings good, devs should just use the same formula with ssome enhancements to make it even better. I dont want NEW things all time, i would be so happy if U3 was like U2 but with a few more things.

Some-Mist

your 'personal opinion' is just very generic and uninformed.

I remember when I used to be stubborn.

[QUOTE="Ribnarak"]

[QUOTE="delta3074"]because it's not unique, it will be the same as farhenhiet (indigo prophecy) and its the same concept and principle to games like myst,it's nothing new, it's been done before delta3074

now, does that mean the game is going to be bad. It will build on previous ideas and make them better, thats what devs try to do. ITs like saying Uncharted 2 gameplay has been done before, meaning it will not do well. BUt look how that turned out.

all im saying is, if somethings good, devs should just use the same formula with ssome enhancements to make it even better. I dont want NEW things all time, i would be so happy if U3 was like U2 but with a few more things.

re-read what you wrote again.

1. it did sound like you were sayign ure opinion, but u were treating it as a fact.
2. by you saying that somethings done before, doesnt make the game bad.
3. how have you played and experienced all the game mechanics of HR. < you realy cant judge.
4. i understand that you dont like it, but your post earlier was trying to say that old game mecahnics implemented in a game cant make the game good. IT will just be exaclty like the old game.

[QUOTE="delta3074"][QUOTE="Ribnarak"]

now, does that mean the game is going to be bad. It will build on previous ideas and make them better, thats what devs try to do. ITs like saying Uncharted 2 gameplay has been done before, meaning it will not do well. BUt look how that turned out.

all im saying is, if somethings good, devs should just use the same formula with ssome enhancements to make it even better. I dont want NEW things all time, i would be so happy if U3 was like U2 but with a few more things.

Ribnarak

re-read what you wrote again.

1. it did sound like you were sayign ure opinion, but u were treating it as a fact.
2. by you saying that somethings done before, doesnt make the game bad.
3. how have you played and experienced all the game mechanics of HR. < you realy cant judge.
4. i understand that you dont like it, but your post earlier was trying to say that old game mecahnics implemented in a game cant make the game good. IT will just be exaclty like the old game.

[QUOTE="Ribnarak"]

[QUOTE="delta3074"]i can't stand QTE games, so from my point of view, this game will be bad,IMO, can't you get it,it's my personal opinion,it's not my kind of gamedelta3074

re-read what you wrote again.

1. it did sound like you were sayign ure opinion, but u were treating it as a fact.
2. by you saying that somethings done before, doesnt make the game bad.
3. how have you played and experienced all the game mechanics of HR. < you realy cant judge.
4. i understand that you dont like it, but your post earlier was trying to say that old game mecahnics implemented in a game cant make the game good. IT will just be exaclty like the old game.

stop being stubborn.

all im sayign is that good you posted your opinion, but stop acting as if your opinion is a fact. Opinions can be proved as facts with factual information, but not urs.

Why dont we wait for them to be released to see how they look, play and score? Honestly i think both will be equally amazing.

[QUOTE="Some-Mist"]

[QUOTE="delta3074"]because it's not unique, it will be the same as farhenhiet (indigo prophecy) and its the same concept and principle to games like myst,it's nothing new, it's been done before delta3074

but my point being, how do you know it's not unique? how do you know the game doesn't present different gameplay elements not found in any other game? because you watched gameplay videos?
I'm just trying to show you that sure, you can form your opinion about the game without having already played it. Your opinion just isn't credible. I mean that may not be a big deal to you, but I don't really like when people look at my replies as a joke, when they aren't meant to be humorous.

IMO, I'm excited for both games. Possibly Alan Wake a little more so than HR (since I've been following Alan Wake since my TFC days). However, I see what heavy rain 'could be' and the potential geniusness behind it. I also never played a game made along-side a movie script :D so I'm wondering if the story telling is going to be even better than that of MGS.

hence why I said 'I remember when I was stubborn'. I used to hate rpgs, especially turn basd ones because I had a bad experience with a few different ones (final fantasy 3 in particular). However, I ended up finding an RPG I liked (chrono trigger) which helped me realize that I do like RPGs including some that are turn based, but not every rpg. Now, xenogears is my favorite game of all time.

I tend to forget that not everyone can change their opinion.

[QUOTE="delta3074"][QUOTE="Ribnarak"]

re-read what you wrote again.

1. it did sound like you were sayign ure opinion, but u were treating it as a fact.
2. by you saying that somethings done before, doesnt make the game bad.
3. how have you played and experienced all the game mechanics of HR. < you realy cant judge.
4. i understand that you dont like it, but your post earlier was trying to say that old game mecahnics implemented in a game cant make the game good. IT will just be exaclty like the old game.

Ribnarak

stop being stubborn.

all im sayign is that good you posted your opinion, but stop acting as if your opinion is a fact. Opinions can be proved as facts with factual information, but not urs.

[QUOTE="delta3074"][QUOTE="Some-Mist"]

but my point being, how do you know it's not unique? how do you know the game doesn't present different gameplay elements not found in any other game? because you watched gameplay videos?
I'm just trying to show you that sure, you can form your opinion about the game without having already played it. Your opinion just isn't credible. I mean that may not be a big deal to you, but I don't really like when people look at my replies as a joke, when they aren't meant to be humorous.

IMO, I'm excited for both games. Possibly Alan Wake a little more so than HR (since I've been following Alan Wake since my TFC days). However, I see what heavy rain 'could be' and the potential geniusness behind it. I also never played a game made along-side a movie script :D so I'm wondering if the story telling is going to be even better than that of MGS.

Some-Mist

hence why I said 'I remember when I was stubborn'. I used to hate rpgs, especially turn basd ones because I had a bad experience with a few different ones (final fantasy 3 in particular). However, I ended up finding an RPG I liked (chrono trigger) which helped me realize that I do like RPGs, but not every rpg. Now, xenogears is my favorite game of all time.

I tend to forget that not everyone can change their opinion.

OMFG Alan Wake is going to destroy Heavy Rain. It's not even going to be close. Were do I begin. First off this guy in Heavy Rain walks like he has a pole jammed right up his ass. Second lets be honest the graphics in Heavy Rain do not look all that great. They are good but Alan Wake cleary looks much better. I mean come on guys Heavy Rain looks to be 7.5 at best. This game looks like total lameness. http://www.gametrailers.com/user-movie/heavy-rain-first-9-minutes/338509 I LMFAO when I saw him shake the controller to shake the OJ. That is SO WEAK. Whats he going to do next go shake his controller why he is in the shower. LMAOCruncha_Munch

thanks for your incite level 1 post 13

i will take your word for it

/sarcasm