This topic is locked from further discussion.
^ Asking for oppinions
[QUOTE="indzman"]
^ Declaring your oppinion as truth
Provided you link about the fact that P.C gamers are very happy about L.A Noire release on P.C
[QUOTE="indzman"]
HaHaHa
GeneralShowzer
^ Laughing at other peoples oppinions (which you asked for)
The person i quoted said L.A Noire deserved to be outscored by The Witcher 2
No matter how much you gonna ignore L.A Noire , all of you secretly wishes to play L.A Noire as well as its made by Rockstar Games .
indzman
^ Ridicilous misinformed claims
You making ridiculous misinformed claims yourself that pc gamers hate GTA
Provided you link again that PC gamers 'd really love to've L.A Noire on P.C
I think you simply trolling :)
If that is the case, then this should be in General Games Discussion.Rockstar Games - ( Makers of Grand Theft Auto and Red Dead Redemption ) ... i don't think The Witcher 2 stands any competition against a Rockstar Game . Go to P.C forums majority P.C gamers wishing L.A noire to be released on P.C as well . Everyone loves Rockstar Games ( from P.C gamers to Console gamers )
No matter how much The Witcher 2 gonna be good , its no competition against L.A Noire ( coz Rockstar Games Publishing / Developing it along with Team Bondi ) .
Its not about P.C VS console gaming , its about competition against Rockstar Games .
MAY 17 is L.A Noire Day .
indzman
Guys Guys I'm not here to bash P.C gamers anticipation of The Witcher 2 ( I'm going to purchase it day 1 myself ) , neither i'm bashing The Witcher 2 .I'm always saying The Witcher 2 gonna be great no doubt .
I'm only saying L.A Noire will be much better gaming experience than The Witcher 2 as worlds best developer Rockstar Games making it along with Team Bondi , come on guys its Rockstar Games .
I'm a diehard Rockstar Fan , debate with me regarding game vs game .
Yeah LA Noire will get great reviews, as with GTA and RDR but it will still suck. Just like GTA and RDR.Guys Guys I'm not here to bash P.C gamers anticipation of The Witcher 2 ( I'm going to purchase it day 1 myself ) , neither i'm bashing The Witcher 2 .I'm always saying The Witcher 2 gonna be great no doubt .
I'm only saying L.A Noire will be much better gaming experience than The Witcher 2 as worlds best developer Rockstar Games making it along with Team Bondi , come on guys its Rockstar Games .
I'm a diehard Rockstar Fan , debate with me regarding game vs game .
indzman
[QUOTE="indzman"]Yeah LA Noire will get great reviews, as with GTA and RDR but it will still suck. Just like GTA and RDR. Pretty much this. I played GTA4 today on my PC, I was incredibly surprised when I busted out laughing as I stole a chicks car, then as I was driving away she held on to her car, not letting go then I smashed her against another car, but then, I was just driving around liberty city, I got bored then fired up TF2. TL;DR Rockstar games are fun for the first 5 seconds then they get boring as hell.Guys Guys I'm not here to bash P.C gamers anticipation of The Witcher 2 ( I'm going to purchase it day 1 myself ) , neither i'm bashing The Witcher 2 .I'm always saying The Witcher 2 gonna be great no doubt .
I'm only saying L.A Noire will be much better gaming experience than The Witcher 2 as worlds best developer Rockstar Games making it along with Team Bondi , come on guys its Rockstar Games .
I'm a diehard Rockstar Fan , debate with me regarding game vs game .
joel_c17
Guys Guys I'm not here to bash P.C gamers anticipation of The Witcher 2
indzman
No matter how much you gonna ignore L.A Noire , all of you secretly wishes to play L.A Noire as well as its made by Rockstar Games . If L.A Noire was to be released on P.C , all you P.C gamers would've forgotten about hyping The Witcher 2 .
indzman
No, that's what you're here to do.
You're saying that the game we are looking forward to is worthless, and everyone should think as you.
I think you simply trolling :)
indzman
Right I'm trolling...
Think Ill stop trolling now and leave this thread.
Problem is The Witcher series are not even in the ranks of other great rpg games as Mass Effect , Dragon Age , Final Fantasy or The Elder Scrolls to debate with / against Rockstar Games :(
Its simply so new :(
Correct me if i'm wrong :(
BUT ye , if The Witcher 2 outscores L.A Noire , it might be worthy enough for a discussion :)
Problem is The Witcher series are not even in the ranks of other great rpg games as Mass Effect , Dragon Age , Final Fantasy or The Elder Scrolls to debate with / against Rockstar Games :(
indzman
Personally, I'd say that The Witcher 1 was easily better than both Mass Effect and Dragon Age games, and the most recent FF and Elder Scrolls games.
It's pretty much the best RPG of the gen...so yes, I disagree.
Also, the developer's new-ness works in its favour - if their first game was able to rival the best RPG developers out there, imagine what they can do with better technology, more money, and heaps of player feedback?
[QUOTE="indzman"]
Problem is The Witcher series are not even in the ranks of other great rpg games as Mass Effect , Dragon Age , Final Fantasy or The Elder Scrolls to debate with / against Rockstar Games :(
Planeforger
Personally, I'd say that The Witcher 1 was easily better than both Mass Effect and Dragon Age games, and the most recent FF and Elder Scrolls games.
It's pretty much the best RPG of the gen...so yes, I disagree.
Also, the developer's new-ness works in its favour - if their first game was able to rival the best RPG developers out there, imagine what they can do with better technology, more money, and heaps of player feedback?
Wrong ... Demons Souls was the best rpg of this gen ( Goty 2009 ) :(
[QUOTE="indzman"]
Wrong ... Demons Souls was the best rpg of this gen ( Goty 2009 ) :(
edidili
You have a problem with opinions do you and no, the best rpg for 2009 was DA:O.
Its a fact Demon Souls is declared as the best rpg of 2009 , not The witcher ... never :(
[QUOTE="edidili"]
[QUOTE="indzman"]
Wrong ... Demons Souls was the best rpg of this gen ( Goty 2009 ) :(
indzman
You have a problem with opinions do you and no, the best rpg for 2009 was DA:O.
Its a fact Demon Souls is declared as the best rpg of 2009 , not The witcher ... never :(
It's an opinion. Do you get it? The same as when I say that TW2 will be better than LA noire.
Wrong ... Demons Souls was the best rpg of this gen ( Goty 2009 ) :(
indzman
Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't that an Action-RPG (as in, story-lite, focus on combat/loot/stats rather than actual roleplaying, etc)? If so, it's rather difficult to compare across RPG sub-genres - they both do what they do very well.
In any case, The Witcher 2 is incorporating a few elements of Demons Souls...so that's yet another thing in its favour?
Anyway, many of the impressions I've read about LA Noire haven't had great thing to say about that game's action sequences. I know those aren't the core of the gameplay, but I'm sure that heaps of reviewers will dock it marks for that.
And...hm, what was the last AAA console/PC adventure game (besides Portal)? Those are much more rare than AAA RPGs.
Its a fact Demon Souls is declared as the best rpg of 2009 , not The witcher ... never :(
indzman
2009 was a pretty bleak year for RPGs, so that isn't saying a whole lot.
[QUOTE="indzman"]
Wrong ... Demons Souls was the best rpg of this gen ( Goty 2009 ) :(
Planeforger
Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't that an Action-RPG (as in, story-lite, focus on combat/loot/stats rather than actual roleplaying, etc)? If so, it's rather difficult to compare across RPG sub-genres - they both do what they do very well.
In any case, The Witcher 2 is incorporating a few elements of Demons Souls...so that's yet another thing in its favour?
Anyway, many of the impressions I've read about LA Noire haven't had great thing to say about that game's action sequences. I know those aren't the core of the gameplay, but I'm sure that heaps of reviewers will dock it marks for that.
And...hm, what was the last AAA console/PC adventure game (besides Portal)? Those are much more rare than AAA RPGs.
The Witcher 2 incorporating few elements from Demons Souls ? WOW ! thats great news as i loved DS . They specified which elements they incorporating ? :)
[QUOTE="DragonfireXZ95"]I hope The Witcher 2 outscores L.A. Noire, they deserve it.indzman
L.A Noire will outscore The witcher 2 easily ,
The Witcher 8.5
Grand Theft Auto 4 10
Grand Theft Auto The Episodes from Liberty City 9.0
Red Dead Redemption 9.5
HaHaHa
errr... yes.but rockstar were a big company with tons of money whereas the witcher was the first game from small company, they did great with what they had.
The witcher 2 incorporating few elements from Demons Souls ? WOW ! thats great news as i loved DS . They specified which elements they incorporating ? :)
indzman
Not specifically, but they have said:
"We get inspired by many games, obviously, like any game developer. I can't say specifically whether it's Heavy Rain, Demon's Souls or Arkham Asylum that has inspired us most over the past few years – it's probably a mix of all of them. I think everyone will find elements of Demon's Souls, though, definitely. We don't auto-scale opponents, for example. If you want to compare it to anything, Demon's Souls is definitely good. I'd like that, for sure."
[QUOTE="indzman"]
[QUOTE="DragonfireXZ95"]I hope The Witcher 2 outscores L.A. Noire, they deserve it.PcGamingRig
L.A Noire will outscore The witcher 2 easily ,
The Witcher 8.5
Grand Theft Auto 4 10
Grand Theft Auto The Episodes from Liberty City 9.0
Red Dead Redemption 9.5
HaHaHa
errr... yes.but rockstar were a big company with tons of money whereas the witcher was the first game from small company, they did great with what they had.
This i completely agree :) Hats off to CD Projekt :)
1. Rockstar are overrated
2. The Witcher 1 was better than both GTA4 and RDR
3. The Witcher 2 looks better than the Witcher 1 in every possible way.
Yes.
[QUOTE="indzman"]
The witcher 2 incorporating few elements from Demons Souls ? WOW ! thats great news as i loved DS . They specified which elements they incorporating ? :)
Planeforger
Not specifically, but they have said:
"We get inspired by many games, obviously, like any game developer. I can't say specifically whether it's Heavy Rain, Demon's Souls or Arkham Asylum that has inspired us most over the past few years – it's probably a mix of all of them. I think everyone will find elements of Demon's Souls, though, definitely. We don't auto-scale opponents, for example. If you want to compare it to anything, Demon's Souls is definitely good. I'd like that, for sure."
Thats great . Thanks a lot for the info , much appreciated . I also hope The Witcher 2 lives upto its expectations so we all can enjoy it :)
i think The Witcher 2 will be the better game but L.A noire will sell way more because of rockstars reputation & hype.
doesn't mean L.A Noire is the better game though.
What a load of crap. 1) I dont care for the cheesey mafia theme. 2) GTA IV and Read Dead Redemption were 2 above average games to me nothing more, both flat and uninspired fueled by the sandbox effect that hasnt evolved much beyond graphics.... I expect this to be the same but with bloody adventure elements thrown in. 3) I prefer RPG's to semi acceptable shooters that double up as sandbox games, E.G most rockstar games, so why would I want this over The Witcher? 4) PC Version is possible, and i own an xbox and im still not getting L.A NOIRE even if it rates 9.5 like RDR or 10 like GTA IV I just know its the same thing again and again.No matter how much you gonna ignore L.A Noire , all of you secretly wishes to play L.A Noire as well as its made by Rockstar Games . If L.A Noire was to be released on P.C , all you P.C gamers would've forgotten about hyping The Witcher 2 .
Truth is Truth , just saying ;) :)
indzman
i think The Witcher 2 will be the better game but L.A noire will sell way more because of rockstars reputation & hype.
doesn't mean L.A Noire is the better game though.
PcGamingRig
You see L.A Noir is having a detective mode story which is very interesting , not a completely gangster game again as Mafia or GTA i hope you understand what i mean :) It 'll involves crime solving plus investigating crimes just like a detective in real life plus gun action and car chases are there in this sandbox game. Plus the player can progress in ranks of his police department as the story progresses .
I mean L.A Noire can also be enjoyed by everyone very much for its gameplay :)
And true , kinda early to predict if L.A Noir will be a better game or not , but thats the charm of discussions in system wars ... nothing personal against anyone :)
Rockstar games are overated their good games no doubt but not the gods of the gaming world as people make them out to be same with the call of duty games.
Ah TC, That train of thought does only work if you Like Rockstar games, right?
I have not liked a gta game since Gta 2 (yeah so far back) and the last good Rockstar game I playied was Max Payne 2. (atleast I think that was rockstar and not remedy).
I like what I see from L.A Noire, It is not the typical halfdone sandbox with lack of... well everything honestly, so it kind of IS the first Rockstar game Ive been interrested in in nearly a Decade, Rockstar does good first impressions, good voice acting, average characters, and a handful of fairly solid game mechanics. Problem being that those are way too few mechanics for an open world game, and Unlike Both SMG 1,2 and MGS 4 Alot of people on the forums, and even Jurnalists when they talk about GTA4 Think it scored more then it should, as soon as the wow factor vanished the game was not worth much.
RDR should be better, Im not into western games, but people generally seem that like that one, I have hopes, but here is the thing.
I know what TW2 will be like (pretty much the last hope of the year for something that resembles a true RPG) LA Noire has a really good and different premise, I like to hope that what LA Noire tryies to do, they suceed in, if they can, then I should outscore TW2.
Problem is The Witcher series are not even in the ranks of other great rpg games as Mass Effect , Dragon Age , Final Fantasy or The Elder Scrolls to debate with / against Rockstar Games :(
Its simply so new :(
Correct me if i'm wrong :(
BUT ye , if The Witcher 2 outscores L.A Noire , it might be worthy enough for a discussion :)
indzman
Umm, Witcher 1 was released in October of 2007.
I think The withcer 2 will be a very special game and will be well praised. I find Rockstar games to be the same old stuff over and over again. Suer they have been revolutionary but they need to innovate more now
I played Witcher1 WAY more than GTAVI, so yes one company will get full cash for their game and the other will wait for sales.
That and I really dont like the theme of LA Noir, never was a fan of old school detective/mob movies.
[QUOTE="indzman"]
Problem is The Witcher series are not even in the ranks of other great rpg games as Mass Effect , Dragon Age , Final Fantasy or The Elder Scrolls to debate with / against Rockstar Games :(
Planeforger
Personally, I'd say that The Witcher 1 was easily better than both Mass Effect and Dragon Age games, and the most recent FF and Elder Scrolls games.
It's pretty much the best RPG of the gen...so yes, I disagree.
Also, the developer's new-ness works in its favour - if their first game was able to rival the best RPG developers out there, imagine what they can do with better technology, more money, and heaps of player feedback?
Boy, this thread really backfired on you indzman, didn't it? :lol:[QUOTE="DragonfireXZ95"]I hope The Witcher 2 outscores L.A. Noire, they deserve it.indzman
L.A Noire will outscore The witcher 2 easily ,
The Witcher 8.5
Grand Theft Auto 4 10
Grand Theft Auto The Episodes from Liberty City 9.0
Red Dead Redemption 9.5
HaHaHa
Witcher receiving a 8.5 was a great feat considering that the first title was built on a Bioware engine. Witcher 2 can easily score a 9.0 or higher CD Project REd has really outdone themselves building a new engine and improving the core mechanics.[QUOTE="indzman"]
[QUOTE="DragonfireXZ95"]I hope The Witcher 2 outscores L.A. Noire, they deserve it.jasonharris48
L.A Noire will outscore The witcher 2 easily ,
The Witcher 8.5
Grand Theft Auto 4 10
Grand Theft Auto The Episodes from Liberty City 9.0
Red Dead Redemption 9.5
HaHaHa
Witcher receiving a 8.5 was a great feat considering that the first title was built on a Bioware engine. Witcher 2 can easily score a 9.0 or higher CD Project REd has really outdone themselves building a new engine and improving the core mechanics. Built on an ANCIENT bioware engine, long-ass load times and plenty of bugs, still got 8.5 Also it was their first game, neither the RDR nor GTA developer were on their first game in any of those scores. In fact, RDR1 got 7.3, far less then The Witcher. :wink:Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment