I have seen talking head after talking head call this everything from the "Apocalypse for Women" to the "The Lord's Joyous Second Coming." The truth is that its neither, break down as follows:
1) Ruling applies to "closely held corporations only" (CHC), this is a legal distinction (and one verified by the IRS) that you own a business in where 50% plus of the shares are owned by less then 5 people (relatives) and not a publically traded company. People who are saying this means that Corporations everywhere are suddenly "going to find Jesus" are overly simplifying it, mainly because the loss of profit for a public corporation to go CHC (from no longer having public shareholders, loss of big corp tax breaks, etc.) would be substantially more than the savings of not covering those contraceptives. The legal paperwork alone would cost a pretty penny while the contraceptives themselves would not be as expensive (and if there is one thing corporations can be counted to do is find the way to maintain profit). Hobby Lobby is religious and so is willing to pay the costs of fighting for their beliefs.
2) The ruling only exempts Hobby Lobby from providing 4 of the 20+ contraceptive options mandated by Obamacare. Specifically the two Morning after pill types and two types of IUD's. The remaining contraceptives (including the Pill) actually make up 80% of the contraceptives used in the US. People who say that millions of women will now be without contraceptives (like I heard someone say this morning) fail to see that most people will continue to have access to the contraceptives they use the most.
3) The vote was along the usual ideological lines, 4 conservatives, 4 liberals, one swing vote (Justice Kennedy). I had someone tell me this was some vast misogynist conspiracy because all the women voted against it. I told her that if you gender reassigned every person on the bench they would still vote according to their entrenched ideology. Now the justices on both sides will say otherwise but the truth is they probably already had their minds made up when they granted the writ of certriari (permission for case to go to Supreme Court). Except Kennedy, that guy votes on whatever side of the bed he wakes on.
4) I've heard some of the supporters of the ruling saying this would finally free them from having to provide for the "abortion" drugs. It wont, President Obama has already said he plans to work around the ruling, maybe requiring that the Fed gov pay for these contraceptives, which means we the tax payer will still be stuck paying for it. (Quite the irony for those Hobby Lobby supporters eh?)
5) The gist of the ruling is basically the government, through Obamacare, did not use the "least restrictive means" to regulate an activity that interferes with the practice of religion. Freedom of Religion is a "Fundamental Right (found in the Constitution) while the right to contraceptives is a "prenumbra right" (a right that was later found by the courts in the "shadow" of the Constitution). Take a guess which has priority.
6) Finally the ideological divide is whether you can use you freedom of religion rights in this case. Liberals say that your religious rights apply only in your home or designated place of worship, conservatives say you can take it anywhere. Doing business in the economy is the big gray area with court rulings for both sides. Please realize this before you start saying this is all some conspiracy or vendetta etc.
7) People are saying this is a big can of worms legally and it is. However a can of worms can go anywhere, including in the opposite direction the can is open in. And all of it is tempered by the speed of our court system, which is about as fast as an actual worm. I would wait and see how this plays out before saying that we have reverted to a third world country (seriously?)
In the end will anyone get everything they want? Nope. Some women will not get every single conceivable birth control they want on demand included in their job perks and some hyper religious people will still have to pay for "abortion" drugs when the Fed gov uses their tax dollars for it. Still the media, politicians, and others will make a scene for their respective teams.
Anyway, its up to you to make up your own mind on the matter.
Log in to comment