If I had to choose between a game that was 1080p or one that was 900p with more detail, I'd go for option 2 every time.
Every multiplat so far has had the same textures, despite lemming shitposting.
If you need to emulate the Xbone's shitty sharpener, you can do so using your TV settings.
I didn't say anything about Xbox One or PS4... I'm just saying, in general, I'd prefer 900p with more detail over 1080p. The point being that 1080p isn't everything.
@BattleSpectre: It's the Xbox color output. It crushes blacks but at the same time there is a significant drop in detail in dark areas. It does make the image appear to have more "pop" though. Just a trick of the eye.
Why is this troll bait thread still open? This one just got LOCKED (linky), figured all troll baits are getting closed, especially when they cherry pick and use youtube low res screens. Hopefully we aren't seeing cherry picked threads being locked...
those screenshot comparisons are terrible, they are about 10x less resolution then 1080p which makes them hard to compare, plus they are posted by an xbox employee or some fanboy. You can blur an image with photoshop and then say its from this console or that, sorry i don't trust anything i'm seeing here. Its just too easy to enhance or degrade an image with photoshop.
Why do you want it closed? Because it's just one of several threads to point out a glaring weakness in the PS4 hardware.
All of a sudden 1080p isn't so cool any more is it?
I never mentioned resolution. You are talking to a straw-man. You aren't reading my post which is probably why you didn't quote it. I will make sure to quote my words below. I enjoyed 1080p many years ago if you must know, but now onto what it is I was talking about, which is apparently a double standard in locking of threads.
It has nothing to do with whatever fantasy it is you conjured up. I got all the machines and I laugh at the youtube low res screens presented for any machine (PC, Wii U, Wii, 360, PS4, Vita, 3DS, PS3, Xbone) as it's comedy to take any of this seriously. These are even more funny as they are pictures of youtube screens, quite hilarious if one is supposed to use as evidence when I can go just turn on my machines in the livingroom.
I already answered your question before you asked however, it's a clearly troll-bait thread and apparently depending on the moderator, those now get locked. That's also why I never commented in this comedy thread. It was the double standard that got my attention.
I don't care if the thread gets locked, I care about standards. In fact, better to unlock the other thread and let discussion continue. If other threads based on the same hokey premises are going to get locked, do it equally to all fanboys, not select fanboys. Again, my post:
----
"Why is this troll bait thread still open? This one just got LOCKED (linky), figured all troll baits are getting closed, especially when they cherry pick and use youtube low res screens. Hopefully we aren't seeing cherry picked threads being locked..."
The real question, which I already know the answer too as I remember you, is why you care to quote me if you aren't going to read my words before quoting? I already know the answer, but I suggest to you that you don't formulate opinions on any hardware based on any of the comedy-evidence presented in either thread or future threads. This has been my stance far before the Wii U, Xbone, and PS4 released. My words aren't a shift about whatever it is you imagine. I've said the same thing about Gamecube, Xbox, PS2, 360, Wii, PC, and PS3 threads in years past. I will say the exact same thing when the Wii UU22, Xbox 4, and PS4 release and some other guy is going to quote me and ask me about 4K or some stupid sh**. I'm not talking about resolutions, especially in a troll-bait thread.
It occurs to me we've already had a very similar conversation repeatedly in various threads as you are very, very, very much entrenched in resolution wars. Look to that link for answers.
For proof, I also submit your created and locked thread: "So what happens when XOne COD Ghosts ends up looking better than PS4 COD Ghosts? by greensand24. You may find a lot of my viewpoints and a refresher on your viewpoints there and it would save a rather lengthy discussion.
Massive lemming delusion. Different textures, now Youtube videos aren't compressed? Really?
Lems are the laughing stock of the industry. Don't worry, maybe da cloud will make a difference. In the meantime I can adjust the brightness and sharpness on my TV for the same effect.
I'll take the better looking game running smooth. Also I'll be the first to answer the picture question, I'm guessing the left one is 1080p but I know I am wrong because that's how things turn out.
Oh, I'm sorry the one on the right is the superior 1080p version.
Thanks for playing!
Thanks for ignoring every other post, lemming.
I was doing stuff, jeez.
But the point, I was trying to make. Why are these issues occurring on a much more powerful system. Can't we all ask why? Is that a crime? Why do we get all defensive?
Missing deatail, washed out textures and missing assets to acheive 1080p? Really why? Where is this 75% more power going to?
It's a texture streaming issue and both versions have them. They both have the same textures so your central premise is totally flawed.
Are you blind or did you not see some of the textures were missing in several PS4 screen shots. That has nothing to do with crushed blacks or anything else you're trying to say. Even in FoxbatAlpha's Strider pics you can see some ground textures missing. So devs will sacrifice texture to get the game to 1080P or stay at a higher resoltuion? Your comments are flawed as usual.
Yeah, Strider is one of the few you can have because it was made by crap devs. Thankfully Double Helix is owned by Amazon now so all they'll do is Android games on FireTV.
BTW blackace, you forgotten what year it is? DX12 is the end of 2015. Xbox One: Just Wait.
Why is this troll bait thread still open? This one just got LOCKED (linky), figured all troll baits are getting closed, especially when they cherry pick and use youtube low res screens. Hopefully we aren't seeing cherry picked threads being locked...
His other thread is still open as well, and the OP doesn't even contain any links to any of the blatantly twisted information he presented.
Even after he got school'd by Wasdie for his ignorance.
Why is this troll bait thread still open? This one just got LOCKED (linky), figured all troll baits are getting closed, especially when they cherry pick and use youtube low res screens. Hopefully we aren't seeing cherry picked threads being locked...
His other thread is still open as well, and the OP doesn't even contain any links to any of the blatantly twisted information he presented.
Even after he got school'd by Wasdie for his ignorance.
They really should communicate to each other because some troll bait threads with conjecture designed to troll are allowed, while other troll bait threads are locked after only a few posts. Peculiar. I hate wasting my time in a thread answering a post, only to find it's locked for being troll bait but multiple other troll bait threads are active. I also know they were flagged according to other users as well at spoken about. I'm just curious about the mentality.
I know as I was alerted to this behavior from other gamespot.com users so I'm sure some of the moderators must be aware of the rotating standards if they listen to the community chatter.
this thread got me crying....(cows) now saying DF videos dont count.....i will rent afew of these games on my ps4 and xbone and check them out....funny stuff
I don't have an xbox 1 or ps4, I play pc. I can clearly see details and textures that aren't in the ps4 version. The cows will never accept this, in full blown denial.
@GrenadeLauncher: sometimes when we are told one thing only to see another you have to trust what you see other than what some company (sony)who is trying to sell you stuff said....not everybody who has something to say is a lem...hell i have all the system and a gaming pc....i see some bad textures in those ps4 pic and no youtube video can make those just leave ...
Haha... The funny thing is that very same gif that you're trying to use to make yourself feel better is most appropriate for you because you're the one cow in here TRYING SO SO HARD and working overtime lol to deny what most people are seeing. But carry on COWard.
@GrenadeLauncher: sometimes when we are told one thing only to see another you have to trust what you see other than what some company (sony)who is trying to sell you stuff said....not everybody who has something to say is a lem...hell i have all the system and a gaming pc....i see some bad textures in those ps4 pic and no youtube video can make those just leave ...
Digital Foundry is owned by Sony all of a sudden? Weird.
@greensand24 said:
@GrenadeLauncher:
Haha... The funny thing is that very same gif that you're trying to use to make yourself feel better is most appropriate for you because you're the one cow in here TRYING SO SO HARD and working overtime lol to deny what most people are seeing. But carry on COWard.
Now that I am experiencing PC gaming, I think I'll sacrifice resolution for FPS. I have been experimenting with Dark Souls and Arkham games, and I enjoy a smooth frame rate more.
@GrenadeLauncher: ps4 is owned by sony ...everything people put on this board is pr hype ...the most powerfull console every built...thats not hard to do ps1,xbox,snes,etc...they old....all the crap you post on here is junk....hell the xbone is the 2nd most powerful console every built....7790/7850/7870......not a big differents
@GrenadeLauncher: ps4 is owned by sony ...everything people put on this board is pr hype ...the most powerfull console every built...thats not hard to do ps1,xbox,snes,etc...they old....all the crap you post on here is junk....hell the xbone is the 2nd most powerful console every built....7790/7850/7870......not a big differents
I'm sure there's a coherent point you were attempting to make hiding in there.
Why is this troll bait thread still open? This one just got LOCKED (linky), figured all troll baits are getting closed, especially when they cherry pick and use youtube low res screens. Hopefully we aren't seeing cherry picked threads being locked...
Not only did the mod lock the thread, but when it was locked both 360 and Xbone had equal votes (3 and 3). Now it has 4 more votes all for Xbone meaning mods went in and up-voted Xbone lol!
Why is this troll bait thread still open? This one just got LOCKED (linky), figured all troll baits are getting closed, especially when they cherry pick and use youtube low res screens. Hopefully we aren't seeing cherry picked threads being locked...
Not only did the mod lock the thread, but when it was locked both 360 and Xbone had equal votes (3 and 3). Now it has 4 more votes all for Xbone meaning mods went in and up-voted Xbone lol!
Anyway back on topic: 1080P at what cost?
$400 ;)
Because AppleFan is very selective in what he deems an appropriate topic.
I agree. The most important thing is image quality, not resolution. On the PC, the resources are theoretically limitless so if your system is powerful enough, it can run ANY GAME at 1080p or 4K and at over 60 fps. Even with a brand new demanding game that no current hardware exists that can achieve that, just wait a year and it will.
With consoles it's different because you have limited resources. The PS4 devs should concentrate on maximizing those resources, not just getting 1080p for the sake of it to have a buzz word.
@Xplode_games: Yeah MS agrees. Allow developers create their vision of the game and not cut corners to get your LOD 1080p.
Quote:
"We've chosen to let title developers make the trade-off of resolution vs. per-pixel quality in whatever way is most appropriate to their game content. A lower resolution generally means that there can be more quality per pixel. With a high quality scaler and anti-aliasing and render resolutions such as 720p or '900p', some games look better with more GPU processing going to each pixel than to the number of pixels; others look better at 1080p with less GPU processing per pixel," replied Goossen.
@Pray_to_me: Too bad we don't have an Xbox One version so we could see what Sucker Punch had to cut from the game to get it to run at 1080p.
Here's your Xbone version. The only open world game on Xbone. 720P and still looking fugly as hell.
Keep making graphics threads nub. I really enjoy pounding you out. And deep down you know you enjoy it too. ;)
That's not even Dead Rising 3 frames per second's biggest problem.
That crap can't be true.
Well considering GravityX is abusing DF anals for his argument and Pray_to_me is using the same source then I'm afraid it is true, that's regarding the frame rate picture anyway. The other picture has a bunch of other funny memes 'shopped into it but the original IQ off the game is still there and it ain't pretty. lol
@Pray_to_me: Too bad we don't have an Xbox One version so we could see what Sucker Punch had to cut from the game to get it to run at 1080p.
Here's your Xbone version. The only open world game on Xbone. 720P and still looking fugly as hell.
Keep making graphics threads nub. I really enjoy pounding you out. And deep down you know you enjoy it too. ;)
That's not even Dead Rising 3 frames per second's biggest problem.
That crap can't be true.
Well considering GravityX is abusing DF anals for his argument and Pray_to_me is using the same source then I'm afraid it is true, that's regarding the frame rate picture anyway. The other picture has a bunch of other funny memes 'shopped into it but the original IQ off the game is still there and it ain't pretty. lol
Its disappointing to see the xbox one holding back the game. Wont be the last unfortunately.
Later in the gen we will see developers lowering resolution to get more on screen, better physics, better AI, and other stuff. Utilizing more of the GPU for other tasks besides graphics will be necessary. Most games later on may drop as low as 720p native on the PS4, and then upscaled. But what will devs do on the X1 then, go as low as 360p :p.
@Pray_to_me: Too bad we don't have an Xbox One version so we could see what Sucker Punch had to cut from the game to get it to run at 1080p.
Here's your Xbone version. The only open world game on Xbone. 720P and still looking fugly as hell.
Keep making graphics threads nub. I really enjoy pounding you out. And deep down you know you enjoy it too. ;)
That's not even Dead Rising 3 frames per second's biggest problem.
That crap can't be true.
For the record, DR3 fixed its framerate issues with a patch which was after the DF analysis. The final version with the day 1 patch had no framerate issues. Also you have to account for the literally 100s of enemies on screen at once (probably close to a thousand) and the fact the world is huge and has 0 loading screens. even at 720p Its impressive for them to fit all that in one game and make the launch
Log in to comment