Pokemon Generation III Remake

  • 52 results
  • 1
  • 2

This topic is locked from further discussion.

#1 Posted by TairuSzoola (83 posts) -

Alright we need it, they finished their sequel which was great but a remake of the best generation is needed. It is tradition for us to get a remake to our favorite generations. So much to be done and stuff that is truley needed. All the other regions have some sort of remake onto the DS, being all were reformed onto another form of accesibility for DS players, although Hoenn got no such treatment.

Here are a couple ideas I thought for this remake

Pokemon follow you

Battle Frontier redone

3D Graphics

Hunger/bathroom meter! (Maybe to add to the realism of the game but maybe implemented later)

Trade with only Black/White 2

Let it continue the story from Black/White 2, like Mass Effect. Turn the game more Role Playing like how it should be. Have the story follow through all games. Stop repetition, let the game decesions actually matter.

Give more decesions

Any more ideas?

#2 Posted by Pixel-Perfect (5778 posts) -

Here are a couple ideas I thought for this remake

Pokemon follow you Cool.

Battle Frontier redone Alright.

3D Graphics Uhuh.

Hunger/bathroom meter! (Maybe to add to the realism of the game but maybe implemented later) ...What? :|

Trade with only Black/White 2 Noooo...

Let it continue the story from Black/White 2, like Mass Effect. Turn the game more Role Playing like how it should be. Have the story follow through all games. Stop repetition, let the game decesions actually matter. I doubt we'd see much change as far as the story is concerned.

Give more decesions Might be cool for gen six if the decisions actually matter, but again, probably won't happen for this remake.

TairuSzoola

#4 Posted by OreoMilkshake (12825 posts) -

Hunger/bathroom meter! (Maybe to add to the realism of the game but maybe implemented later)

TairuSzoola
I'd rather have this for the Pokemon. Just to have more player interaction with them.
#5 Posted by hydralisk86 (8637 posts) -
[QUOTE="TairuSzoola"]

Hunger/bathroom meter! (Maybe to add to the realism of the game but maybe implemented later)

OreoMilkshake
I'd rather have this for the Pokemon. Just to have more player interaction with them.

You know, bathroom break/hunger meter reminds me of those tamagotchis that were popular many years ago xD.
#6 Posted by turtlethetaffer (17198 posts) -

The only thing really and truly necassary for me is to have Pokemon follow you (such an awesome idea! Why remove it form Black and White??!) and maybe a more fleshed out/ better storyline. Also, making it so you can catch event Pokemon (Jirachi, Deoxys) would be nice.

#7 Posted by hydralisk86 (8637 posts) -

The only thing really and truly necassary for me is to have Pokemon follow you (such an awesome idea! Why remove it form Black and White??!) and maybe a more fleshed out/ better storyline. Also, making it so you can catch event Pokemon (Jirachi, Deoxys) would be nice.

turtlethetaffer
But if that happens, then they wouldn't be worth as much, since everyone can catch them, right?
#8 Posted by Blabadon (28457 posts) -
[QUOTE="turtlethetaffer"]

The only thing really and truly necassary for me is to have Pokemon follow you (such an awesome idea! Why remove it form Black and White??!) and maybe a more fleshed out/ better storyline. Also, making it so you can catch event Pokemon (Jirachi, Deoxys) would be nice.

hydralisk86
But if that happens, then they wouldn't be worth as much, since everyone can catch them, right?

They're not worth much anyways, thousands of hacked ones are all over the world.
#9 Posted by hydralisk86 (8637 posts) -
[QUOTE="hydralisk86"][QUOTE="turtlethetaffer"]

The only thing really and truly necassary for me is to have Pokemon follow you (such an awesome idea! Why remove it form Black and White??!) and maybe a more fleshed out/ better storyline. Also, making it so you can catch event Pokemon (Jirachi, Deoxys) would be nice.

Blabadon
But if that happens, then they wouldn't be worth as much, since everyone can catch them, right?

They're not worth much anyways, thousands of hacked ones are all over the world.

:( That makes me sad somehow. Hacks just ruin the game IMO.
#10 Posted by Blabadon (28457 posts) -
[QUOTE="hydralisk86"][QUOTE="Blabadon"][QUOTE="hydralisk86"] But if that happens, then they wouldn't be worth as much, since everyone can catch them, right?

They're not worth much anyways, thousands of hacked ones are all over the world.

:( That makes me sad somehow. Hacks just ruin the game IMO.

I'm all okay with someone hacking their game as long as they don't disrupt others. Besides, Nintendo's events and other methods of getting these Pokemon used to be terrible so hacks were even more beneficial to the regular player. I'm not ever going to hack my game though, I like Game Freak's games the way they are
#11 Posted by rubber-chicken (2066 posts) -
I have a feeling that they won't do another remake until the next Pokemon gen. I'd assume that they'd want to use the same engine as a 3DS Pokemon game, which doesn't yet exist. Don't know if they'd make a new engine just for a remake.
#12 Posted by YoshiYogurt (5991 posts) -
No we just a got a game. A gen 3 remake is not even needed and your idea suck TBH.
#13 Posted by The_Last_Ride (74436 posts) -

Let it continue the story from Black/White 2, like Mass Effect. Turn the game more Role Playing like how it should be. Have the story follow through all games. Stop repetition, let the game decesions actually matter.

Give more decesions

TairuSzoola
i would like that more
#14 Posted by funsohng (28994 posts) -
Pokemon follow you - Yeah Battle Frontier redone - Yeah 3D Graphics - It will be using 5th gen engine, so it will be half 3D Hunger/bathroom meter! (Maybe to add to the realism of the game but maybe implemented later) - why in the god's name do you want Pokemon game to have that? Why the hell does Pokemon need to be realistic? Trade with only Black/White 2 - .... why the limit? Let it continue the story from Black/White 2, like Mass Effect. Turn the game more Role Playing like how it should be. Have the story follow through all games. Stop repetition, let the game decesions actually matter. - Mass Effect is a RPG? That's new to me..... Pokemon is not about the superfluous story "decisions" that Mass Effect tries to fool its players that they are getting, it's about a complete freedom in your party members. Give more decisions - Like I said, it's hardly necessary. It won't hurt, but I'd rather have them divert the resources to make that to actually making a good story to begin with.
#15 Posted by GreekGameManiac (6439 posts) -

*Sigh*

You guys never learn,do you?

They will NOT remake Gen III,Arceus-damnit!

#16 Posted by Pixel-Perfect (5778 posts) -

*Sigh*

You guys never learn,do you?

They will NOT remake Gen III,Arceus-damnit!

GreekGameManiac

Nothing you've said on the subject is very convincing, so maybe we have a bad teacher. Xat-chew.gif

#17 Posted by GreekGameManiac (6439 posts) -

Nothing you've said on the subject is very convincing, so maybe we have a bad teacher. Xat-chew.gif

Pixel-Perfect

Hah,that's YOUR opinion my dear!

:)

Seriously,i doubt they are remaking them,they are probably thinking of new Pokemon games atm.

#18 Posted by turtlethetaffer (17198 posts) -

[QUOTE="Pixel-Perfect"]

Nothing you've said on the subject is very convincing, so maybe we have a bad teacher. Xat-chew.gif

GreekGameManiac

Hah,that's YOUR opinion my dear!

:)

Seriously,i doubt they are remaking them,they are probably thinking of new Pokemon games atm.

The remakes are bound to happen at some point.

#19 Posted by dsrules13 (1624 posts) -

Hunger/bathroom meter! (Maybe to add to the realism of the game but maybe implemented later)

Trade with only Black/White 2

Let it continue the story from Black/White 2, like Mass Effect. Turn the game more Role Playing like how it should be. Have the story follow through all games. Stop repetition, let the game decesions actually matter.

TairuSzoola

Having a hunger or bathroom meter is a terrible idea. That makes it more simulation-esque than it needs to be. If it's largely implemented than it would be too annoying when you're trying to grind or do whatever you want to do. And what would the repercussions of not maintaining the Pokemon be? If it's level or stats loss it would have too much of an impact on the game. So to force an idea like this into Pokemon would be foolish. Having the ability to do something such as communicate with the Pokemon would be interaction enough.

Why would limiting trade be a good idea? I see only negatives to this.

And since when is Mass Effect more of an rpg than Pokemon? Pokemon is a very traditional rpg. It has a traditional, well done turn-based battle system. It has potions and such, as well as battle items. It has traditional boss battles in the way of gym leaders and the final four. The thing that sets it apart is how well done the monster catching and training aspect is. Mass Effect is a more modern, "western" rpg that does not share common rpg roots with Pokemon. And how would continuing the story make it more of an rpg? As a new region is introduced, the story breaks up into a new journey with new characters. It's a system that works just fine and introduces some amount of freshness to each installment.

Your comments show a lack of appreciation for, as well as a lack of knowledge of the franchise, its roots, its history, and what makes it so great. The suggestions I have responded to would be a detriment to the franchise and its future.

#20 Posted by GreekGameManiac (6439 posts) -

The remakes are bound to happen at some point.

turtlethetaffer

Are they?

Maybe,but there's a possibility they won't happen.

And it's NOT a slim one.

#21 Posted by turtlethetaffer (17198 posts) -

[QUOTE="turtlethetaffer"]

The remakes are bound to happen at some point.

GreekGameManiac

Are they?

Maybe,but there's a possibility they won't happen.

And it's NOT a slim one.

Based on what? They've remade every game thus far, what's to stop them from remaking gen 3? they'd be foolish not to.

#22 Posted by Rod90 (7266 posts) -
Just give us Gen6 on the 3DS!!
#23 Posted by GreekGameManiac (6439 posts) -

Based on what? They've remade every game thus far, what's to stop them from remaking gen 3? they'd be foolish not to.

turtlethetaffer

>_>

*Sigh*

Did u see remakes of every game in every series ever made?

No.

Just because they remade the first two gens,doesn't mean they will do Gen III.

We don't have a guarantee.

#24 Posted by turtlethetaffer (17198 posts) -

[QUOTE="turtlethetaffer"]

Based on what? They've remade every game thus far, what's to stop them from remaking gen 3? they'd be foolish not to.

GreekGameManiac

>_>

*Sigh*

Did u see remakes of every game in every series ever made?

No.

Just because they remade the first two gens,doesn't mean they will do Gen III.

We don't have a guarantee.

Ok, let me phrase it this way... if the pattern that started at gen 3 continued, we will get a gen 3 remake at some point.

#25 Posted by MrNuttyboh (137 posts) -

Hunger/bathroom meter! (Maybe to add to the realism of the game but maybe implemented later)

TairuSzoola

Their Pokemon not Giga Pets

#26 Posted by darkspineslayer (20431 posts) -

[QUOTE="turtlethetaffer"]

Based on what? They've remade every game thus far, what's to stop them from remaking gen 3? they'd be foolish not to.

GreekGameManiac

>_>

*Sigh*

Did u see remakes of every game in every series ever made?

No.

Just because they remade the first two gens,doesn't mean they will do Gen III.

We don't have a guarantee.

You still haven't provided a reason within the series. Here are several good reasons why it could happen. 1. GBA games and the systems they play on are becoming more and more outdated. Not everybody has access to the gen 3 games anymore and importing is not as easy as the D/P days. 2. All the Kanto, and Johto Pokemon were made avalible between all the gen 3 games, including Firered/Leafgreen. Heart gold and soul silver were technicly superflouious in this regard, which brings me to my next point... 3. Fans clearly want them, hence this conversation. 4. Money. Pokemon brings in the money and Gamefreak being a business, likes money. So while there is a chance they won't happen, your incorrect, it's actually a pretty slim chance they won't come at some point. Next gen if not this one.
#27 Posted by Toxic-Seahorse (4346 posts) -

We don't need a Gen III remake. The games still stand very well against even the newer pokemon games. Although it would be interesting to see what they could do with it on the 3DS.

#28 Posted by videog (327 posts) -

Guys did you forget about black 2 and white 2 or something. We arent gonna get anything for a while now....No Gen 6, No remakes.

#29 Posted by HotelShy (28 posts) -

I havent played Pokemon in a long time and dont plan to buy bw2. But if a 3rd gen remake did come out i would get back into the series. btw Mudkip is so cute :3

#30 Posted by Aquat1cF1sh (10936 posts) -
I'd buy it but I doubt they'd remake it.
#31 Posted by Toxic-Seahorse (4346 posts) -

Guys did you forget about black 2 and white 2 or something. We arent gonna get anything for a while now....No Gen 6, No remakes.

videog
Which is stupid. Instead of an original game we get a rehash of B/W. Nintendo seems to finally understand that they can milk the main pokemon games too, which isn't good news.
#32 Posted by Kaze_no_Mirai (11645 posts) -
[QUOTE="videog"]

Guys did you forget about black 2 and white 2 or something. We arent gonna get anything for a while now....No Gen 6, No remakes.

Toxic-Seahorse
Which is stupid. Instead of an original game we get a rehash of B/W. Nintendo seems to finally understand that they can milk the main pokemon games too, which isn't good news.

I think it was GF's decision to make sequels as opposed to Nintendo.
#33 Posted by Toxic-Seahorse (4346 posts) -
[QUOTE="Toxic-Seahorse"][QUOTE="videog"]

Guys did you forget about black 2 and white 2 or something. We arent gonna get anything for a while now....No Gen 6, No remakes.

Kaze_no_Mirai
Which is stupid. Instead of an original game we get a rehash of B/W. Nintendo seems to finally understand that they can milk the main pokemon games too, which isn't good news.

I think it was GF's decision to make sequels as opposed to Nintendo.

Nintendo has to approve it though, they are the publishers. They tell GF what to do.
#34 Posted by GreekGameManiac (6439 posts) -

You still haven't provided a reason within the series. Here are several good reasons why it could happen. 1. GBA games and the systems they play on are becoming more and more outdated. Not everybody has access to the gen 3 games anymore and importing is not as easy as the D/P days. 2. All the Kanto, and Johto Pokemon were made avalible between all the gen 3 games, including Firered/Leafgreen. Heart gold and soul silver were technicly superflouious in this regard, which brings me to my next point... 3. Fans clearly want them, hence this conversation. 4. Money. Pokemon brings in the money and Gamefreak being a business, likes money. So while there is a chance they won't happen, your incorrect, it's actually a pretty slim chance they won't come at some point. Next gen if not this one.

darkspineslayer

1.it doesn't matter,that doesn't guarantee a remake.

2.They can just include them in the new games,you know....

3.So? just because so many Gen III fans want it,doesn't mean it will.We don't always get what we want,you know.

4.They already are making money,and new and hugely improved games can bring them money.

#35 Posted by darkspineslayer (20431 posts) -

[QUOTE="darkspineslayer"]You still haven't provided a reason within the series. Here are several good reasons why it could happen. 1. GBA games and the systems they play on are becoming more and more outdated. Not everybody has access to the gen 3 games anymore and importing is not as easy as the D/P days. 2. All the Kanto, and Johto Pokemon were made avalible between all the gen 3 games, including Firered/Leafgreen. Heart gold and soul silver were technicly superflouious in this regard, which brings me to my next point... 3. Fans clearly want them, hence this conversation. 4. Money. Pokemon brings in the money and Gamefreak being a business, likes money. So while there is a chance they won't happen, your incorrect, it's actually a pretty slim chance they won't come at some point. Next gen if not this one.

GreekGameManiac

1.it doesn't matter,that doesn't guarantee a remake.

2.They can just include them in the new games,you know....

3.So? just because so many Gen III fans want it,doesn't mean it will.We don't always get what we want,you know.

4.They already are making money,and new and hugely improved games can bring them money.

Ignoring my points doesn't mean you made any yourself. I never said it was a guarantee either, I just said here are some reasons Game freak is probably considering it. You have yet to provide any valid reasons to the contrary other than they don't need to exist. Like I said, neither did HG/SS. (and in this case, historically backed arguments and observations are valid, not halfhearted attempts at rebuttals that have little to do with what I actually said.)
#36 Posted by GreekGameManiac (6439 posts) -

Ignoring my points doesn't mean you made any yourself. I never said it was a guarantee either, I just said here are some reasons Game freak is probably considering it. You have yet to provide any valid reasons to the contrary other than they don't need to exist. Like I said, neither did HG/SS. (and in this case, historically backed arguments and observations are valid, not halfhearted attempts at rebuttals that have little to do with what I actually said.)darkspineslayer

>_>

I never fckn "ignored" your points,damnit.

And i'm sure i did have one.

There's no absolute guarantee,mate.

:/

And that's all.

#37 Posted by darkspineslayer (20431 posts) -

[QUOTE="darkspineslayer"]Ignoring my points doesn't mean you made any yourself. I never said it was a guarantee either, I just said here are some reasons Game freak is probably considering it. You have yet to provide any valid reasons to the contrary other than they don't need to exist. Like I said, neither did HG/SS. (and in this case, historically backed arguments and observations are valid, not halfhearted attempts at rebuttals that have little to do with what I actually said.)GreekGameManiac

>_>

I never fckn "ignored" your points,damnit.

And i'm sure i did have one.

There's no absolute guarantee,mate.

:/

And that's all.

You sure as hell didn't prove them wrong if you didn't ignore them. Maybe you did in another thread. Please feel free to repost it once you find it. Again, I never said there was a guarantee. I simply argued for why they could be considered, 'mate'. Calm down, bro. Your getting worked up over a simple debate.
#38 Posted by GreekGameManiac (6439 posts) -

[You sure as hell didn't prove them wrong if you didn't ignore them. Maybe you did in another thread. Please feel free to repost it once you find it. Again, I never said there was a guarantee. I simply argued for why they could be considered, 'mate'. Calm down, bro. Your getting worked up over a simple debate.darkspineslayer

Well i can't be searching for a thread.

:/

It don't matter anyway.

#39 Posted by darkspineslayer (20431 posts) -

[QUOTE="darkspineslayer"][You sure as hell didn't prove them wrong if you didn't ignore them. Maybe you did in another thread. Please feel free to repost it once you find it. Again, I never said there was a guarantee. I simply argued for why they could be considered, 'mate'. Calm down, bro. Your getting worked up over a simple debate.GreekGameManiac

Well i can't be searching for a thread.

:/

It don't matter anyway.

Yeah, ok :roll: Back up your bold assertations with fact next time. Save yourself the grief.
#40 Posted by GreekGameManiac (6439 posts) -

Yeah, ok :roll: Back up your bold assertations with fact next time. Save yourself the grief.darkspineslayer

:s

I don't even know wtf you mean!!

:/

Be specific?

And as i said,i can't be searching over a thread.

Are you kidding me?

And i already said what i had to say,get it.

I GAVE you reasoning,now get that.

Thank you.

And i said i'm done,didn't i?

#41 Posted by darkspineslayer (20431 posts) -

[QUOTE="darkspineslayer"]Yeah, ok :roll: Back up your bold assertations with fact next time. Save yourself the grief.GreekGameManiac

:s

I don't even know wtf you mean!!

:/

Be specific?

And as i said,i can't be searching over a thread.

Are you kidding me?

And i already said what i had to say,get it.

I GAVE you reasoning,now get that.

Thank you.

And i said i'm done,didn't i?

And yet you continue to post? Done, huh? All I'm asking for is a valid reason why you think gen 3 won't get a remake. So far, I've given 4 reasons why it probably will. And "Just because they remade the first two generations doesn't mean they will remake the third" isn't a reason. Your right, it doesn't mean sh*t, and it defiantly doesn't mean they HAVE to do it. But it's not a reason why they would gloss over it either. Asking you to search for a thread was rhetorical. I never assumed you would. But you clearly have a position on the matter...I'm just asking you to defend it a little better.
#42 Posted by funsohng (28994 posts) -
[QUOTE="videog"]

Guys did you forget about black 2 and white 2 or something. We arent gonna get anything for a while now....No Gen 6, No remakes.

Toxic-Seahorse
Which is stupid. Instead of an original game we get a rehash of B/W. Nintendo seems to finally understand that they can milk the main pokemon games too, which isn't good news.

3rd version with a bit of improvement = good thing a new sequel with tons of additions = milking WTF? Besides, it usually takes around 3-4 years to get to a new generation anyway, so I really don't see why people are whining.
#43 Posted by Toxic-Seahorse (4346 posts) -

[QUOTE="Toxic-Seahorse"][QUOTE="videog"]

Guys did you forget about black 2 and white 2 or something. We arent gonna get anything for a while now....No Gen 6, No remakes.

funsohng

Which is stupid. Instead of an original game we get a rehash of B/W. Nintendo seems to finally understand that they can milk the main pokemon games too, which isn't good news.

3rd version with a bit of improvement = good thing a new sequel with tons of additions = milking WTF? Besides, it usually takes around 3-4 years to get to a new generation anyway, so I really don't see why people are whining.

If you actually read my posts in this thread you'd see that I don't want a Gen III remake. Also, the same region with a worse story and new features is hardly a good new game. It's like what Call of Duty does, but even worse. At least in CoD you get all new places to go. I know B/W 2 has some new places, but it also uses a lot of old ones. Please note that I'm not saying B/W 2 is a bad game, it's definitely good, but don't say it's not milking.

#44 Posted by dsrules13 (1624 posts) -

I could see them doing a Gen III remake obviously for money, and the systems they play on phased out. However, the games still hold up well technically. Gens I and II had very poor graphics and less features than what we have now. Gen III's graphics are obviously not on the same level as the new gens, but are much more comparable.

I personally don't think they need a remake, but I think there's a good chance they'll get one at some point.

#45 Posted by The_Last_Ride (74436 posts) -
it would be a great place to start for making a 3D game only for the 3DS
#46 Posted by Rod90 (7266 posts) -
[QUOTE="Toxic-Seahorse"][QUOTE="videog"]

Guys did you forget about black 2 and white 2 or something. We arent gonna get anything for a while now....No Gen 6, No remakes.

funsohng
Which is stupid. Instead of an original game we get a rehash of B/W. Nintendo seems to finally understand that they can milk the main pokemon games too, which isn't good news.

3rd version with a bit of improvement = good thing a new sequel with tons of additions = milking WTF? Besides, it usually takes around 3-4 years to get to a new generation anyway, so I really don't see why people are whining.

So when do you think we will get Gen6?
#47 Posted by NirdBerd (2116 posts) -

Gen 3 is extremely underrated compared to the overrated Gen 1/2. So yeah, I'd support a remake, although I don't care if they don't go through with it, the GBA ones are perfect enough.

#48 Posted by swat1912 (40 posts) -

Pokemon follow you-- YES!!

Battle Frontier redone-- YES

3D Graphics--YES

Hunger/bathroom meter! (Maybe to add to the realism of the game but maybe implemented later)

i don't think this would work good in this game it would eb annoying to have to eat/go to washroom

Trade with only Black/White 2-- why just black and white why not other games :/

Let it continue the story from Black/White 2, like Mass Effect. Turn the game more Role Playing like how it should be. Have the story follow through all games. Stop repetition, let the game decesions actually matter.

--na new people makes the game more interesting maybe cross region in one game but idk

Give more decesions--yes why not but not to many

#49 Posted by homegirl2180 (7161 posts) -
They need to make sure you are able to swim faster with surf by holding down "B."
#50 Posted by Superzone (3713 posts) -
Sapphire is my all time favorite Pokemon game, so I am really hoping that Gen III remakes for the 3DS will be the next Pokemon games.