@esqueejy: Would you care to name these socialist countries that are so wonderful? Last I checked, such countries - the ones who identify themselves as socialist - weren't doing so well. Then of course we have the socialist countries that discarded it into the dustbin of history.
Socialists have long been immune to evidence. Their beliefs and arguments most closely resemble that of a religion now.
"All that means is that the intent is for these to be public companies in which individuals own stock/shares"? This is BS. Why? Because this happens already under capitalism. When a socialist talks about public ownership, they mean government ownership. To claim otherwise is to take anyone who's actually studied socialism for a fool.
As for the rest of your discussion about "Big Pharma" and "climate disaster", talk about a disjointed mess. Johnson & Johnson, Pfizer, Roche - the top 3 "Big Pharma" companies - are already publicly owned. How they possibly relate to the GND and developing "green energy sources" is beyond me.
In any case, this discussion is beside the point. Our centuries-long experience with socialism has proven it an unimaginable disaster. This is the point. Prove me wrong.
@MigGui: The GND text states that it "will require the following: … providing and leveraging, in a way that ensures that the public receives appropriate ownership stakes and returns on investment...". It would have the central government direct and control vast swathes of the economy.
You appear to be confused about what a fallacy is. Please identify the one you say I'm committing.
The fact is, you're committing a fallacy. Whatever "death toll" you imagine for democracy and liberal capitalism is irrelevant to the issue of socialism's devastation. This is known as a red herring.
@MigGui: If AOC favors social democracy, then she can call herself a social democrat. But instead she calls herself a "democratic socialist". Her "Green New Deal" aligns with traditional socialist thought.
Communism is a "higher stage" of socialism and I'm fully aware of the differences, as did socialists in times past. Why do you think the Soviet Union was called the "Union of Soviet Socialist Republics"?
"Disgruntled survivors"? My god, you really don't know what you're talking about.
"there is a ton of misery happening under...democratic governments"? Then why does AOC support democracy then? Or are you saying she doesn't?
@MigGui: Nope, just eminently reasonable conclusions based on years of study. Heck, you don't even need that to witness the horrors of socialism. Simply talk to those who lived under it or read about the countries that still practice it.
@esqueejy: Hi...do you understand what the words "on par" mean? And for your information, I graduated top in my class in political science. I also studied socialism extensively.
Why is Gamespot promoting these politicians? They espouse socialism, an ideology on par with racism and Nazism in the misery, suffering, and death it's caused.
You guys need a serious reality check. Educate yourselves, and stop promoting such vile individuals.
whizler's comments