@khaleefa91: Evolve is a good game, it was just over-priced for what it offered. And Witcher 3 is an amazing game, on a technical level, on a story level, and on a gameplay level. Might not be everyone's cup of tea, but that doesn't take away from what it does. Your criticism about the combat is weak - it's an RPG, you can do the combat however you want. If you Quen spam, then that is your lack of originality and reflex, not the game's.

Mad Max wasn't as bad as the 6 it got, but it didn't deserve much higher, either. You want to complain about generic combat lacking depth, pointless missions and loot drops, weak story, etc., Mad Max has it in spades.