Heart Gold and Soul Silver are the best pokemon remakes. In fact, they're one of the best examples of how a remake should be done for any game. The perfect balance of nostalgia and fanservice while further improving the series with new, fun features and not feel outdated. It successfully integrated story elements from Crystal without completely deviating from the original G/S plot. It did not scrap any content available from GSC or Gen IV. It brought everything back and more. We didn't ask for the Pokewalker or every single pokemon following you, including their shiny, gender and form differences, but we still got it. GSC never had a Battle Frontier, but we still got Sinnoh's. Gym leader rematches? That too. GB Sounds to every music track in the game? God bless. They were a step ahead with the IR sensor in the cartridges, which was later used in 5th gen, just like how FRLG introduced wireless trading before it was possible on the DS.
ORAS were utter disappointments. They felt rushed. Incomplete. My expectations for them were not "too high." I expected them to get the same treatment as HGSS. I was spoiled by HGSS. As the generation that introduced gym leader rematches and the battle frontier, I was incredibly distraught by their absences in ORAS. Features that have been in Pokemon games for years, completely gone. And don't even come up to me with that "Emerald introduced them and these aren't Emerald remakes" BS excuse. HGSS was the complete 2nd Gen package with a 4th Gen facelift. It had the story elements from Crystal despite it not being a Crystal remake. It had gym leader rematches despite it not being in 2nd Gen. It had the Sinnoh Battle Frontier despite the concept not existing until Emerald. AND Gamefreak has the audacity to omit the Hoenn Battle Frontier from the Hoenn remakes, replace it with the already boring Battle Maison, AND TEASE US WITH AN "BATTLE FRONTIER UNDER CONSTRUCTION" TEASE RIGHT NEXT TO IT?! Nah. Don't get me started. And how about the trainer customization from XY? There's absolutely no reason for trainer customization to be a "Kalos exclusive feature." Character customization has been a default gameplay feature for RPGs for over a decade. That's the stuff you expect them to continue improving and expanding, to make the player relate more with the main character. And to honor Emerald, they give us a completely gimped Sky Pillar with an hour long fetch quest after beating the game? Thanks for all these legendaries and mega evolutions, but I was not satisfied. ORAS was made with competitive battles and pokedex completion in mind, but that's not enough for me. Especially after how great the DS games were. Gamefreak continues to be one step forward, two steps back.
/rant
Log in to comment