Neither personally. MK Wii was such a disapointment for my friends and I. We all find MKDD to be the best console MK. If you don't necesarily have friends to play with locally, I'm sure either MK will fill your needs with online play. Just the Wii version will allow for people to play locally when you want, so that right there would win me over.

Heres hopnig to a better Maro Kart in the future!

A lot of us naturally choose Brawl. I beleive this is because Brawl will have the greatest improvement overall from Melee to Brawl than Double Dash to Wii's new version. Mario Kart is a really solid game with minor problems where as Melee is a great game with very unblanced gameplay.

Brawl is most likely going to be the "better" game since all the problems with melee are suposedly being resolved. However, if the new Mario Kart increases its gameplay equal or near that Brawl will, MK will "win" out.

I was one of the few who did paly Mario Kart DD with 8 real players. It is by far the best gaming experience I've ever had and the new Mario Kartis doing better than that. I'm giddy with excitement for both games really!