Bioshock infinite review changed, now has a 4 instead of 9.

This topic is locked from further discussion.

Avatar image for lightleggy
#1 Posted by lightleggy (16090 posts) -

Seems Mcshea didnt liked the game

Avatar image for PhazonBlazer
#2 Posted by PhazonBlazer (12013 posts) -

What in the actual...I don't even...for the sake of...

Avatar image for lightleggy
#3 Edited by lightleggy (16090 posts) -

I guess it's fair to ask for a new SMG2 and GTA IV review then.

Avatar image for ManInFlames
#4 Posted by ManInFlames (434 posts) -

lol

Avatar image for drinkerofjuice
#5 Posted by drinkerofjuice (4567 posts) -

That's hilarious.

Avatar image for glez13
#6 Edited by glez13 (9749 posts) -

GS staff will continue to have a lot of work...

Avatar image for tubbyc
#7 Edited by tubbyc (3893 posts) -

A poor game? Gee that's harsh. It wasn't one of the best I've played, but still pretty good.

Avatar image for lightleggy
#8 Edited by lightleggy (16090 posts) -

@glez13: yeah a lot of crap needs fixing, I already reported this in the feedback forum.

Avatar image for fueled-system
#9 Posted by fueled-system (6529 posts) -

Score is harsh but he makes alot of valid points and I am nowhere near McShea's biggest fan..

Avatar image for PhazonBlazer
#10 Posted by PhazonBlazer (12013 posts) -

Alot of you may not have liked the game. But a 4/10 this game is not.

Avatar image for lightleggy
#11 Posted by lightleggy (16090 posts) -

@fueled-system said:

Score is harsh but he makes alot of valid points and I am nowhere near McShea's biggest fan..

Regardless of how good or bad the game is, GS had already chosen Van0rd's review, and GS has said multiple times that review scores are always final.

If they don't change this back then I really don't see why should they still have the "10/10" reviews from GTA IV and SMG2, or the "its very mysoginistic and politically incorrect" 9/10 GTA V review.

Avatar image for charizard1605
#12 Posted by charizard1605 (82622 posts) -

So according to McShea, The Last of Us is twice as good as Bioshock Infinite

#SDC #ThankYouLordKaz #ThankYouSony

Avatar image for funkymonkey4710
#13 Posted by funkymonkey4710 (1835 posts) -

I am pretty sure it didn't officially change, it is merely a second opinion. Gamespot is going to now do multiple reviews for games to gauge other people's opinions.

Avatar image for fueled-system
#14 Posted by fueled-system (6529 posts) -

@lightleggy said:

@fueled-system said:

Score is harsh but he makes alot of valid points and I am nowhere near McShea's biggest fan..

Regardless of how good or bad the game is, GS had already chosen Van0rd's review, and GS has said multiple times that review scores are always final.

If they don't change this back then I really don't see why should they still have the "10/10" reviews from GTA IV and SMG2, or the "its very mysoginistic and politically incorrect" 9/10 GTA V review.

I agree.. there is no reason to change the score maybe they can add some kind of "flashback" or after the credits type review that supplements the official one but yeah it messes up alot

Avatar image for SuperNecro
#15 Edited by SuperNecro (1423 posts) -

Retroactively trolling since 2013.

Avatar image for Animal-Mother
#16 Posted by Animal-Mother (27350 posts) -

Damn, Infinite really did suck though.

Avatar image for lightleggy
#17 Edited by lightleggy (16090 posts) -

@funkymonkey4710:

That would entirely kill the point of editor reviews...

So which score is the official score of the game? Imagine the SW arguments...."PS4 has 10 AAA games!"- "No-uh it only has 2, rest of them are not even A games!".

Avatar image for charizard1605
#18 Edited by charizard1605 (82622 posts) -

@lightleggy said:

@funkymonkey4710:

That would entirely kill the point of editor reviews...

So which score is the official score of the game? Imagine the SW arguments...."PS4 has 10 AAA games!"- "No-uh it only has 2, rest of them are not even A games!".

The first score is the official score, the others are all second or third or fourth opinions.

Alternatively, the 'official' score is the average of all the scores, this makes Bioshock what, a 6.5/10?

Avatar image for starjet905
#19 Edited by starjet905 (2062 posts) -

Wait, what? I thought the story was overrated, just praised by the gamers who never really played games with good stories, but giving it a 4/10? This is all I can say about this score:

Link because new GS doesn't want my images, apparently

I agree with some of the points he makes, but no way can this score be anything but bait, simply put.

Avatar image for Harbinger_CR
#20 Edited by Harbinger_CR (146 posts) -

Wether you like the game or not, its definetely not a 4/10 game. The pros overweight the cons too much.

Avatar image for TheEroica
#21 Edited by TheEroica (17227 posts) -

The new gamespot was programmed to auto troll...

Avatar image for lostrib
#22 Posted by lostrib (49999 posts) -

why does the average user score say 0.9 at the end of the review but on the Bioshock Infinite page it says 8.7?

Avatar image for sagejonathan
#23 Posted by sagejonathan (519 posts) -

Infinite was one of the best games I've ever played. Not that I play a crazy load of games, but it was really good and made the Bioshock series my 2nd favorite series ever.

Avatar image for Stevo_the_gamer
#24 Posted by Stevo_the_gamer (44839 posts) -

How is this new review ordeal going to work with flops? First review counts? What if they both release at the same time? Oh my!

Avatar image for Giancar
#25 Edited by Giancar (19155 posts) -

Hipsters FTL!

The game is one of the best this gen.

And had one of the best storytelling ever put in a videogame.

Avatar image for LA-Nighthawk
#26 Posted by LA-Nighthawk (335 posts) -

He nailed it pretty much. Shallow game with shallow gameplay.

Avatar image for Randolph
#27 Posted by Randolph (10542 posts) -

@LA-Nighthawk:

You don't have to use an alt, Tom.

Avatar image for ChubbyGuy40
#29 Posted by ChubbyGuy40 (26428 posts) -

People mad because of how right he is (for once.) It's a 5 at most with the terrible combat and how damn linear it is.

Avatar image for LA-Nighthawk
#30 Edited by LA-Nighthawk (335 posts) -

@Randolph said:

@LA-Nighthawk:

You don't have to use an alt, Tom.

Your joke is a 3/10.

Avatar image for haziqonfire
#31 Edited by Haziqonfire (36344 posts) -

It didn't change. It's a secondary review. Tom's review actually has the original one by Kevin at the end.

Avatar image for heytheredarlin
#32 Posted by heytheredarlin (869 posts) -

GameSpot is getting pathetic. If this isn't a clickbait review I don't know what is.

Avatar image for StrifeDelivery
#33 Edited by StrifeDelivery (1901 posts) -

@Giancar:

Pffft.... good luck with that

Avatar image for NeonNinja
#34 Posted by NeonNinja (17318 posts) -

It's just a second take. When clicking on the reviews page, it stands as a 9 out of 10. McShea is a second opinion below it, but the 9 is the featured review. I imagine for the metagame we will count the first review since that's the one featured front and center.

http://www.gamespot.com/bioshock-infinite/reviews/

Avatar image for deactivated-58b6232955e4a
#35 Posted by deactivated-58b6232955e4a (15594 posts) -

Maybe people will finally stop praising it around here.

Avatar image for Randolph
#36 Posted by Randolph (10542 posts) -
@SAGE_OF_FIRE said:

Maybe people will finally stop praising it around here.

Anyone who lets the opinions of that man change what they like or don't like needs to find a new hobby.

Avatar image for remiks00
#37 Posted by remiks00 (3788 posts) -

@heytheredarlin said:

GameSpot is getting pathetic. If this isn't a clickbait review I don't know what is.

Avatar image for nutcrackr
#38 Edited by nutcrackr (13029 posts) -

Well now if they take the average of the two reviews, you are getting close to what the game deserves.

Avatar image for Jonwh18
#39 Posted by Jonwh18 (9350 posts) -

@heytheredarlin said:

GameSpot is getting pathetic. If this isn't a clickbait review I don't know what is.

QFT.

Also screw all the people pretending like this is a bad game now.

Avatar image for the_bi99man
#40 Posted by the_bi99man (11242 posts) -

Just in case people are still confused, Gamespot has introduced a "second opinion" feature for their reviews of particularly big name games. If you just go directly to the Bioshock Infinite page, the original review is still the official one. Tom's new review is linked at the bottom, as a second opinion. They're going to be doing this alot with big-name, heavily hyped games. You can expect the second opinion reviews to be very much in disagreement with the originals, because otherwise there really wouldn't be much of a point.

Avatar image for LongZhiZi
#41 Posted by LongZhiZi (2453 posts) -

If that was the review for the original Bioshock, I'd say they finally got it right. But I haven't played Infinite, so I can't judge that game.

Avatar image for Grey_Eyed_Elf
#42 Edited by Grey_Eyed_Elf (5231 posts) -

I don't think Tom realizes what the point of a scoring system is, If Infinite is a 4/10 then the majority of games are a 3/10 and no game will ever be able to score higher than a 7/10.

More importantly what's the point of a lower scoring secondary review or maybe a higher scoring secondary review?... Simple its a cop-out. That way users from both sides of the opinion spectrum will be voiced and feel valued in my opinion its takes away the value of a review site. This is to me sites nail in the coffin. I will stay on it for the forums but aside from that I see no use for this site.

Avatar image for rjdofu
#43 Posted by rjdofu (9171 posts) -

I've completely lost my respect for this reviewer. A 4, are you fvcking serious? That's a score for games that fundamentally bad, something like nonfunctional gunplay or full of glitches.

WTF GS? Are you THAT thirsty for hits?

Avatar image for cain006
#44 Edited by cain006 (8625 posts) -

That's great. I think McShea genuinely believes that to be a correct score and he strikes me as a guy who actually uses all the numbers unlike most reviewers.

But sadly people will try and defend this "magnum opus of humanity"

Avatar image for lightleggy
#45 Posted by lightleggy (16090 posts) -

The user score is also 0.9 when I was sure it was over 8 in the old site...

Avatar image for VendettaRed07
#46 Posted by VendettaRed07 (14012 posts) -

If someone else on here had posted everything he wrote in the actual review, some people would disagree but not everyone would say he's outright wrong because he's not.

I think Tom just goes to show why this score system is broken. People rarely ever have a problem with what he actually says in his reviews just his scores which is stupid.

The 1up review scale is the best. A, B, C, D, and F. You don't need anything more than that. it doesn't matter if a game is a 4, 3 or a 2, or a 1. All those mean "Game not good, me reviewer no like" Its dumb for them to have to curb scores so that the scale doesn't seem as broken as it is.

Giving Bioshock an F, as in it failed to do the job it set out to do, might not be such a horrible message. But we have this really sensitive view on these numbers its ridiculous. Its scared reviewers into not being able to use scales correctly.

Avatar image for Heil68
#47 Posted by Heil68 (57704 posts) -

I love Tom.

Avatar image for chessmaster1989
#48 Edited by chessmaster1989 (30204 posts) -

ahahahaahahahahaahahahahaha

Avatar image for FinalFighters
#49 Posted by FinalFighters (2781 posts) -

lmao thats hilarious