How would you rank the Sonic games you've played?

So having been playing Sonic 06, I honestly think it's somewhere in the lower end of the middle tier of games. It's certainly not as bad as Game Gear Spinball, Secret Rings, Shadow's game (which I'm surprised), or Labyrinth, but it's also showing some moments where Sonic Team seemed to really be trying to recapture the audience they were losing when Shadow's game was bombing and Adventure lovers were alienated by Heroes.

When the game is WORKING it honestly controls better than Heroes... Heroes had such slippery, floaty controls it's sad.

Ha! Sonic Adventure 2 was 30% good. The rest was crappy shooting and TEDIOUS AND LONG treasure hunts. Don't even get me started on SA2......ShadowofSonic

[QUOTE="ShadowofSonic"]Ha! Sonic Adventure 2 was 30% good. The rest was crappy shooting and TEDIOUS AND LONG treasure hunts. Don't even get me started on SA2......TAMKFan

[QUOTE="macrules_640"]I always found it funny we people tried to defend Sonic Adventure and how I said Big made it worse, then they shut up. :PShadowofSonic

[QUOTE="ShadowofSonic"][QUOTE="macrules_640"]I always found it funny we people tried to defend Sonic Adventure and how I said Big made it worse, then they shut up. :PSuperSmashBro1

Although I did finish his story thank goodness in about an hour's time.macrules_640

They've lived and learn. *rimshot*macrules_640

No, Shadow just likes to be anti-SonicSpot's general opinion in order to try and humor himself because he has nothing else better to do with his time.

I got the reference if it makes you feel any better, Mac.

No, Shadow just likes to be anti-SonicSpot's general opinion in order to try and humor himself because he has nothing else better to do with his time.

I got the reference if it makes you feel any better, Mac.

Cloud_765

Going around trolling other people's comments with cycnical remarks? THAT'S MY JOB!!!

[QUOTE="TAMKFan"][QUOTE="ShadowofSonic"]Ha! Sonic Adventure 2 was 30% good. The rest was crappy shooting and TEDIOUS AND LONG treasure hunts. Don't even get me started on SA2......Cloud_765

No, Shadow just likes to be anti-SonicSpot's general opinion in order to try and humor himself because he has nothing else better to do with his time.

Cloud_765

Okay here we go and how I rate them out of 10

1.Sonic the Hedgehog 2 : 10

2.Sonic 3 and Knuckles: 10

3.Sonic CD: 9.6

4.Sonic the Hedgehog: Sega Genesis/Mega Driv: 9.5

5.Sonic Rush:9.4

6.Sonic Adventure 2: 9.2

7.Sonic Advance 3:9.0

8.Sonic Rush Adventure: 8.8

9.Sonic Colors: 8.6

10.Sonic Adventure:8.5

11.Sonic Advance 2:8.5

12. Sonic Generations:8.4

13.Sonic Advance:8.2

14.Sonic 4 Episode 1:8

15.Sonic Triple Trouble:7.8

16.Sonic Chaos:7.8

17.Sonic and SEGA All Star Racing:7.7

18.Sonic and the Secret Rings:7.5

19.Sonic 2 GG:7.4

20.Sonic 1 GG:7

21.Mario and Sonic at the Olympic Games:7

22.Sonic Unleashed:6.5

23.Sonic Heroes:6.5

24.Sonic Spinball: SEGA Genesis Version:6

25.  Robotniks Mean Bean Machine: 6

26.Sonic Choronicles:5.5

27.Tails Adventure: 5.0: I am gonna make kbaily upset here I think.

28.Sonic Drift 2:3

29.Sonic 3D Blast:Saturn Verion:3

30.Sonic 3D Blast:Genesis Version:2.5

31.Sonic Drift:1.5

32.Sonic Shuffle:1

33:Sonic Spinball:GG version:0.8

34.Tails Skypatrol:0.5

35.Sonic R:0.2

36.Sonic Labrthyn: - 5.5:: It's so bad it makes Sonic 2006 look like the best game ever. It's the only game in the series that needs a minus sign.

I guess I am one of the lucky ones who hasn't played Shadow,Sonic the Disaster,Sonic and the Blacjk Knight and Sonic Fighters.

Now that I've actually played and beaten Sonic Generations, here's where it is on my list:

1. Sonic 3 & Knuckles
2. Sonic Adventure 2 Battle
3. Sonic Generations
4. Sonic 2
5. Sonic Colors (Wii)

The rest of my list is the same as it was before.

[QUOTE="Cloud_765"]

No, Shadow just likes to be anti-SonicSpot's general opinion in order to try and humor himself because he has nothing else better to do with his time.

I got the reference if it makes you feel any better, Mac.

kbaily

Going around trolling other people's comments with cycnical remarks? THAT'S MY JOB!!!

So uhm, how about that ranking our top Sonic games? Mine would go like this:

1. Sonic the Hedgehog 2
2. Sonic Colors (Wii)
3. Sonic Generations (HD)
4. Sonic 3 & Knuckles
5. Sonic Rush Adventure
6. Sonic the Hedgehog (GEN)
7. Sonic Advance 3
8. Sonic Adventure 2: Battle
9. Sonic Advance 
10. Sonic Advance 2

Yeah, I'm actually pretty balanced between new and old... 

1. Sonic R

Trash: The rest

1. Sonic R

Trash: The rest

kjhg53

[QUOTE="TAMKFan"][QUOTE="ShadowofSonic"]Ha! Sonic Adventure 2 was 30% good. The rest was crappy shooting and TEDIOUS AND LONG treasure hunts. Don't even get me started on SA2......Cloud_765

Actually, after going back and playing a few of the games in my top 10, a few spots got moved since I last ranked them.

[QUOTE="kjhg53"]

1. Sonic R

Trash: The rest

Cloud_765

[QUOTE="Cloud_765"][QUOTE="kjhg53"]

1. Sonic R

Trash: The rest

kjhg53

[QUOTE="Cloud_765"][QUOTE="kjhg53"]

1. Sonic R

Trash: The rest

kjhg53