can uncharted 2 be better then MGS4??

both tps and uncharted 2 now has stealth so i think its a good comparasin. uncharted had a pretty good story and a amazing single player experience almost as good as mgs4. but i dont know, now that i seen the uncharted 2 online gameplay i have a feeling it will beat my beloved mgs4 :(......:D

It will come close..

It'll most definitely be an amazing game like the first, most likely better. But as a long-time MGS fan, I highly doubt it can outdo MGS4. MGS4 defines the meaning of epic.

I think it will come close, but I very seriously doubt it will be better.

I am already confident I will enjoy Uncharted: Among Thieves more than MGS4.

Sure, MGS4 is a great game, but I didn't enjoy it like I hoped. I can understand why people like it, but strictly fans of the series will enjoy it most, and I had never played a Metal Gear previous to when I played MGS4 back when it was released.

Uncharted is my favourite game for the PS3, it came with my PS3 and I was awe when I first saw the game in motion. It was beautiful and when the twist first happened I liked it, but I know a few people that didn't. And concerning those who think Among Thieves will fail because of the addition of multiplayer/co-op, it won't. You have to remember when Naughty God were developnig Uncharted they had engine issues and it ate up around 6 months of their developing time, yet they still produced one of the most polished games ever created. So, factor in that and the extra resources brought it to focus on the multiplayer for U2, you shouldn't have to worry about the single player.

Gameplay wise could be a tie or maybe Uncharted could do better. As for story I'm probably the only MGS fan who was very disappointed in MGS4 story. But I can't really say if Uncharted can do better than MGS4 in terms of story MGS4 did have it moments.

i dont know.
MGS4 was amazing to me. Uncharted was good but not as good as MGS4.

Uncharted 2 looks good as well but id like to play it first before i can say that its better.

Uncharted > Metal Gear Solid 4.

That said, sure.

i dont get why ppl praised MGS4's single player campaign. it was so short on GAMEPLAY is not even funny. I thought we're into Video Games because of the INTERACTION but it's seem the ratio of gameplay to cutscene is 70% to 30% and that depends how u play. On a GAMEPLAY standpoint MGS4 aint touching MGS2 and as a whole MGS4 aint touching MGS1. MGS4 online is top notch thoughPSP107

lol im quite sure, that there is more gameplay then cut-scenes..

Uncharted > Metal Gear Solid 4.

That said, sure.

Scianix-Black

The thread should be "Will Bayonetta be better than DMC 3?"

depends on what kinda gamer you are XD

The thread should be "Will Bayonetta be better than DMC 3?"

Unknown_Hero3

The thread should be "Will Bayonetta be better than DMC 3?"

Unknown_Hero3

DMC 3 was lame.

:D

[QUOTE="Unknown_Hero3"]

The thread should be "Will Bayonetta be better than DMC 3?"

Scianix-Black

DMC 3 was lame.

:D

TAKE THAT BACK, I'm about to shoe gun your grill! :P

[QUOTE="Scianix-Black"]

[QUOTE="Unknown_Hero3"]

The thread should be "Will Bayonetta be better than DMC 3?"

DMC 3 was lame.

:D

TAKE THAT BACK, I'm about to shoe gun your grill! :P

Nope its impossible but i bet it will still be good :D

I'm a long time MGS fan so MGS4 to me was Amazing. A lot of people complain about it, but that's because MGS4 explained everything and from what I've seen a lot of them were playing the MGS series for the first time so they lack the appreciation for it. As for uncharted that game rocked and if somehow they manage to top MGS4 I say kudos Naughty Dog. I'ts going to be hard to top MGS4 though.

[QUOTE="Unknown_Hero3"]

The thread should be "Will Bayonetta be better than DMC 3?"

Scianix-Black

DMC 3 was lame.

:D

Yes, it will, because as a game I found Metal Gear Solid 4 to be extremely lame.Tikicobra

[QUOTE="Scianix-Black"]

[QUOTE="Unknown_Hero3"]

The thread should be "Will Bayonetta be better than DMC 3?"

hazelnutman

DMC 3 was lame.

:D

I did, and I do not take it back...

DMC 1 & 2 were the best.

:D

i dont get why ppl praised MGS4's single player campaign. it was so short on GAMEPLAY is not even funny. I thought we're into Video Games because of the INTERACTION but it's seem the ratio of gameplay to cutscene is 70% to 30% and that depends how u play. On a GAMEPLAY standpoint MGS4 aint touching MGS2 and as a whole MGS4 aint touching MGS1. MGS4 online is top notch thoughPSP107

[QUOTE="hazelnutman"][QUOTE="Scianix-Black"]

DMC 3 was lame.

:D

Scianix-Black

I did, and I do not take it back...

DMC 1 & 2 were the best.

:D

u should have added " i dun know option"....... but story wise no, game play i dun know, graphics ui dun know.

DMC 2 was terrible...

i voted yes...MGS is amazing, but its unfair to say that uncharted cant be better when anything can happen.

[QUOTE="PSP107"]i dont get why ppl praised MGS4's single player campaign. it was so short on GAMEPLAY is not even funny. I thought we're into Video Games because of the INTERACTION but it's seem the ratio of gameplay to cutscene is 70% to 30% and that depends how u play. On a GAMEPLAY standpoint MGS4 aint touching MGS2 and as a whole MGS4 aint touching MGS1. MGS4 online is top notch thoughUnknown_Hero3

lol im quite sure, that there is more gameplay then cut-scenes..

Yes, why not?! i'm a big MGS fan... but its up to the developers to do the work... though storywise, i think its hard to match MGS... Hope they'll make Uncharted 2 better than MGS4, then a new Metal Gear game will top 'em again... the cycle goes on and our games keep getting better and better... that's gonna be very good for us!

...Um NO

Yes, why not?! i'm a big MGS fan... but its up to the developers to do the work... though storywise, i think its hard to match MGS... Hope they'll make Uncharted 2 better than MGS4, then a new Metal Gear game will top 'em again... the cycle goes on and our games keep getting better and better... that's gonna be very good for us!

taplok

lol becasue they annouced it...

I've been playing MGS games for years and there is no way Uncharted will win me over. They're both great, but MGS4 is greater.

Uncharted was a great game, but being a fan of MGS since the start it would be hard for it to be better in an emotion sense. Graphics and gameplay may be better do to the time and having more people on their team then they did.

I haven't played uncharted but I can't believe any game can be better than MGS4 that game was pretty good and very well made but now I'm gonna have to get uncharted just to compare. 8)

I'd rather not decide which one is better. i loved MGS4, I loved Uncharted, and I'm sure I'll love Uncharted 2. Thats all that matters.

Uncharted is like the earth and MGS4 is like heaven, the gap between them is too far apart from comparison. In conclusion, Uncharted 2 may become a good game, but can't touch the epicness that is MGS4.

No no no hell no Uncharted 2 its gona be amazing game but not somthing that can beat MGS4. Metal Gear Solid 4 its a legend :D

If is has as much replay as MGS4, and MP is as interesting and innovative as MGO, then it can come close, maybe even outdo it.

Hey, anything can happen, and Naughty Dog is definitely a top tier company.

[QUOTE="PSP107"]i dont get why ppl praised MGS4's single player campaign. it was so short on GAMEPLAY is not even funny. I thought we're into Video Games because of the INTERACTION but it's seem the ratio of gameplay to cutscene is 70% to 30% and that depends how u play. On a GAMEPLAY standpoint MGS4 aint touching MGS2 and as a whole MGS4 aint touching MGS1. MGS4 online is top notch thoughjasonharris48

who knows it could be

It might come close, but will not surpass it.