@Willy105 said:
@oliver8114: What would you consider to be an extreme viewpoint regarding social justice?
I don't know his position but I could tell mine. I consider myself left wing, I'm pro women and minorities rights, I have read about feminism and many of the things I read I can get behind 100%. I think blaming immigrants for problems is short sighted. I'm against generalizations based on people's religious or ethnic backgrounds. I think societies can get richer with more diversity of cultures. I'm in favor of sexual freedom, gay marriage, abortion, etc. My political views could even be regarded as social anarchism because I think humans work better if organized in self-sustained communities but I also acknowledge that in our current reality the state is a necessary evil to keep some sense of order so I can get behind social democratic ideals. I'm against the libertarian notion of the invisible hand of capitalism somehow making sense out of everything and letting society be ruled be greed and personal interest which I think is absurd as we are a social species first and foremost. So yeah I'm pretty leftist but I still think the social justice movements can become similar to what they fight against and in some ways they have.
For example take this book written by a libertarian feminist: https://www.amazon.com/Unwanted-Advances-Sexual-Paranoia-Campus/dp/0062657860
I only read the introduction which is extensive but I agree pretty much 100% with it. It talks about how the PC culture has taken over social justice discourse and how it has become full of drama and people getting offended by everything. It is a way to make victims be treated as children and, therefore, protecting them from real life, challenges, personal growth, etc. Needless to say the author and her supporters have been attacked by many social justice proponents mercilessly to the point that the woman had to quit her position at her University and even sued.
I grew up on a catholic household and went to catholic school. As I child I remember that the catholic tradition made me feel both guilty and scared all the time. Guilty because of my condition as a sinful human being and scared because I was being judged all the time by an all-seeing God on every action I took or even on my thoughts. This facet of religious conservatism made me create antibodies to any type of moralist movement that tries to manipulate people with fear and guilt rather than championing more rewarding venues like reason, debate, consensus and discourse.
I feel the social justice movement in many ways became like this religious fundamentalist moralism. I am supposed to feel guilty now because of my condition as a male and I am supposed to feel scared because society is always watching and judging my behavior and thoughts due to my condition, women are also supposed to live in constant fear and a defensive state because they can get raped at every corner and by everything. Even in private settings like the bedroom, passion and freedom from taboos has to be substituted by extreme carefulness and control because you can end up in jail if your partner suddenly decides that you went too far, even if it all happens after the fact and everything seemed ok at the moment. Worst is for the women victims because they are infantilizing them. Suddenly all the empowerment of women is not about women being responsible and making their own decisions without relying in men but is about society setting a safe space so women never feel threatened, offended, contradicted, etc. In other words they are trying to shield potential victims from living, from making mistakes, from dealing with problems, from growing up. I can't think of anything that could take more power away from victims than making them over-protected inepts.
As long as the social justice movements remain lead by the politically correct crowd as their standard they're going to become more and more ridiculous and extreme to the point of being the other side of the coin of right wing conservative moralist movements.
Log in to comment