What will end up the Wii's best-seller?

Mario Kart

Same as last gen

Super Smash Bros Brawl.....same as last gen.....ozzsoad

Kart outsold Smash last gen

[QUOTE="ozzsoad"]Super Smash Bros Brawl.....same as last gen.....Jaysonguy

Kart outsold Smash last gen

[QUOTE="ozzsoad"]Super Smash Bros Brawl.....same as last gen.....Jaysonguy

Kart outsold Smash last gen

Since when?

[QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

[QUOTE="ozzsoad"]Super Smash Bros Brawl.....same as last gen.....ozzsoad

Kart outsold Smash last gen

Since when?

Ever?

[QUOTE="ozzsoad"][QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

[QUOTE="ozzsoad"]Super Smash Bros Brawl.....same as last gen.....Jaysonguy

Kart outsold Smash last gen

Since when?

Ever?

Because everyone knows Mario Kart Double Dash is the best selling Gamecube game ever. Right. Who here has ever heard of MKDD outselling SSBM, besides Jaysonguy?

[QUOTE="Jaysonguy"][QUOTE="ozzsoad"][QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

[QUOTE="ozzsoad"]Super Smash Bros Brawl.....same as last gen.....ozzsoad

Kart outsold Smash last gen

Since when?

Ever?

Because everyone knows Mario Kart Double Dash is the best selling Gamecube game ever. Right. Who here has ever heard of MKDD outselling SSBM, besides Jaysonguy?

Anyone smart enough not to use Wikipedia?

I mean Kart sold 6.6 million for the Gamecube while Smash only sold 6.58

More impressive then that win is the fact that Smash was released two year earlier then Kart was.

[QUOTE="Jaysonguy"][QUOTE="ozzsoad"][QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

[QUOTE="ozzsoad"]Super Smash Bros Brawl.....same as last gen.....ozzsoad

Kart outsold Smash last gen

Since when?

Ever?

Because everyone knows Mario Kart Double Dash is the best selling Gamecube game ever. Right. Who here has ever heard of MKDD outselling SSBM, besides Jaysonguy?

i have no idea. you guys could put up some sources. but really, the topic is about what will be the best seller THIS gen.

Anyone smart enough not to use Wikipedia?

I mean Kart sold 6.6 million for the Gamecube while Smash only sold 6.58

More impressive then that win is the fact that Smash was released two year earlier then Kart was.

Jaysonguy

I don't need Wikipedia to know that Smash Bros. Melee is the best selling GC title, I though it was common knowledge. I never once heard Mario Kart was the best selling game for that console. May I ask where you are getting your figures?

[QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

Anyone smart enough not to use Wikipedia?

I mean Kart sold 6.6 million for the Gamecube while Smash only sold 6.58

More impressive then that win is the fact that Smash was released two year earlier then Kart was.

ozzsoad

I don't need Wikipedia to know that Smash Bros. Melee is the best selling GC title, I though it was common knowledge. I never once heard Mario Kart was the best selling game for that console. May I ask where you are getting your figures?

HERE

HERE

While their recent numbers can be argued their long term numbers never come into question.

I want to change my answer

I now choose Wii Play

Anyone smart enough not to use Wikipedia?

I mean Kart sold 6.6 million for the Gamecube while Smash only sold 6.58

More impressive then that win is the fact that Smash was released two year earlier then Kart was.

Jaysonguy

Wikipedia says SSBM was #1, Sunshine was #2 and Kart was #3.

Gamecube sales Link

[QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

Anyone smart enough not to use Wikipedia?

I mean Kart sold 6.6 million for the Gamecube while Smash only sold 6.58

More impressive then that win is the fact that Smash was released two year earlier then Kart was.

Oleg_Huzwog

Wikipedia says SSBM was #1, Sunshine was #2 and Kart was #3.

Gamecube sales Link

Yeah you see where I said NOT to use Wikipedia?

See how you linked Wikipedia?

This is the first I've ever heard of DD outselling Melee. I find it slightly odd as well. I mean, everyone I knew with a Gamecube has Melee, while my sister is the only one I know with Double Dash. Besides, I'm unwilling to trust any site that replaces an "S" with a "Z". Its like when people trust nexgenwars.com, when all that they do is calculate the rate of sales and let their counter go, they're usually off by a million or so.jmangafan

You have your sites mixed up

Yeah you see where I said NOT to use Wikipedia?

See how you linked Wikipedia?

Jaysonguy

D'oh. Reading comprehension is fun.

[QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

Yeah you see where I said NOT to use Wikipedia?

See how you linked Wikipedia?

Oleg_Huzwog

D'oh. Reading comprehension is fun.

lol

No sweat

Probably Wii play...Arnalion

Yup, this is why I changed my answer (not because I knew you'd say that but because it makes good sense)

I want to change my answer

I now choose Wii Play

Jaysonguy

Wii Play is my choice, it's selling amazingly, I hope people are buying it for the controller and not the game!!

This is the first I've ever heard of DD outselling Melee. I find it slightly odd as well. I mean, everyone I knew with a Gamecube has Melee, while my sister is the only one I know with Double Dash. Besides, I'm unwilling to trust any site that replaces an "S" with a "Z". Its like when people trust nexgenwars.com, when all that they do is calculate the rate of sales and let their counter go, they're usually off by a million or so.jmangafan

Not that I want to keep this going, but it doesn't make any sense. I've been searching for the past half hour for any other source citing Mario Kart Double Dash as the best selling Gamecube game, and I haven't found one. Every other site claims Smash Bros. Brawl as the top seller. I've been reading recent comments from people on sites showing a list of the top Gamecube games, and none of them argue against SSBM. No one else seems to think it's true. It's more than odd. I don't buy it. That's all I have to say about it.

[QUOTE="ozzsoad"][QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

Anyone smart enough not to use Wikipedia?

I mean Kart sold 6.6 million for the Gamecube while Smash only sold 6.58

More impressive then that win is the fact that Smash was released two year earlier then Kart was.

Jaysonguy

I don't need Wikipedia to know that Smash Bros. Melee is the best selling GC title, I though it was common knowledge. I never once heard Mario Kart was the best selling game for that console. May I ask where you are getting your figures?

HERE

HERE

While their recent numbers can be argued their long term numbers never come into question.

I 've heard both versions, SSBM outselling MKDD and MKDD outselling SSBM. In my opinion, SSBM was the winner but at the end I don't care which one had the best sellings, I just know both are pretty funny and excellent multiplayer games. And answering to the topic forum, I think SSBB will be the best seller for Wii.

[QUOTE="Jaysonguy"][QUOTE="ozzsoad"][QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

Anyone smart enough not to use Wikipedia?

I mean Kart sold 6.6 million for the Gamecube while Smash only sold 6.58

More impressive then that win is the fact that Smash was released two year earlier then Kart was.

huntervaneg

I don't need Wikipedia to know that Smash Bros. Melee is the best selling GC title, I though it was common knowledge. I never once heard Mario Kart was the best selling game for that console. May I ask where you are getting your figures?

HERE

HERE

While their recent numbers can be argued their long term numbers never come into question.

I 've heard both versions, SSBM outselling MKDD and MKDD outselling SSBM. In my opinion, SSBM was the winner but at the end I don't care which one had the best sellings, I just know both are pretty funny and excellent multiplayer games. And answering to the topic forum, I think SSBB will be the best seller for Wii.

Electronic Gaming Monthly says Super Smash Bros. I don't remember the exact issue, but I'll post it later.

I should point out something amusing though.... I searched "mario kart outsold smash bros" in Google and the link to this thread was the first to pop up in the list. Does that say anything? lolozzsoad

it comes down to mario kart wii and ssbb. tough choice but im going to have to say ssbb, because not only can u play the classic 4 player modes, but u have a variety of other options such as the homerun contest, and the special events. mario kart will come down to racing and battle mode which i think is limited in variety compared to ssbb. Not to mention that ssbb will have most of the mario kart characters and more including sonic and solid snake.

I have a subscription to Nintendo power and any time they talk about brawl they talk about how Melee was the best selling gamecube game..Even when they used to have top ten charts of gamecube sales Melee was always ahead of the rest..

SSBB is going to take the crown i think this Gen...I dont say Wii play becuase in my opinion its a controller with a free game not the other way around..

Super Smash Bros Brawl.....same as last gen.....ozzsoad

I was going to say Wii Play in the bundle with the remote, but alot of people arent into those sort of games?

So in that case im going Mario kart Wii, im sure almost every Wii owner will consider buying it, its a must have!

either SMG or SSBBI3loo

yep! nintendo's strongest franchises are Super Mario , Super Smash Bros, and Mario Kart. the wii does or will have all of those sequels and they will be the top of the line just like they have always been. (this is not to say that Metroid and Zelda aren good, but apparently not at the level of the top three) [personally i think SSBB will reign supreme..... i mean honestly have you seen it?!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!