Quoted for Truth: Episode 4

Our weekly video game news discussion show with John Davison, Brendan Sinclair, and Tom Mc Shea. Topics: New Gears of War at E3, PS4 due in 2013, and more on this week's Quoted for Truth.

Discussion

96 comments
SolidTy
SolidTy

I had no idea my saying would be this huge, it's amazingt!!!!

Megotaku77
Megotaku77

The original endings of Mass Effect 3 was not an artistic risk.  You only need to play the game to see the gaping plot holes you could drive a military convoy through that were not present at ANY other point in the game except in the last 10 minutes.  They ran out of time, period.  The endings were so bad and nonsensical that I was prepared to NEVER purchase another BioWare title and every time I tried to play through Mass Effect 3 again I was stopped in my tracks with the looming knowledge that I would be facing the ending again and it sapped my interest completely.  Them releasing more complete endingscan only be good.

FreedomPrime
FreedomPrime

The hotspot needs to come back, this is not enough.

destroyeur
destroyeur

So I guess this one has tanked. Can we get the HotSpot back now? Even if traffic would have increased in the last months, fidelity is going ddddaaaaooooowwwnnnnn!

kedj
kedj

Where is the new Quoted for Truth, why is this not up on the YouTube channel yet, and why doesn't Quoted for Truth have it's own page on Gamespot yet?

mtait01
mtait01

my comment got mentions XD

Yukeshime
Yukeshime

 @Polybren 

Will there be any sort of podcast type recap show during e3?

a HOT feature like that would really hit the SPOT...

DeathMetalPizza
DeathMetalPizza

I've never purchased a console within a year of it's release. I don't plan on changing my ways any time soon.

 

innocent69
innocent69

amazing how Bredan Sinclair keeps implying that there was not a single internal programer (minority group of programmers) working at these companies saying "no that choice is a stupid idea". But their boss at that company was in love with that stupid idea. So he squashed/stomped on their opinion and he placed that stupid idea into the final game.

maitkarro
maitkarro

Dudes this the INJUSTICE league is the total opposite of Justice League, it's a different universe where they are the bad guys, so this game makes total sense why they are fighting each other. There was even an animated movie about Injustice League where the Lex Luthor from Injustice League Universe comes to ask aid from the Justice League Universe, because the Injustice League Batman is figuring out what planet is the Multiverses centre, so called the First Universe and mess with it somehow, so the Injustice league can control the entire Multiverse.

Lord_Python1049
Lord_Python1049

This is a good show and all, but I still prefer The Hotspot! With live calls! Get Kevin and "The other one" in as well. Hotspot out!

awesomenessone
awesomenessone

I believe that Epic already announced that this will not include the original characters.  I remember reading somewhere that the original cast is done and that this new one is most likely done by one of the studios that Epic has acquired.

twztid13
twztid13

So when you all critize choices, it's okay, but when others do it, it's not? How do you know it wasn't the devs original idea to put the flashlight on the armor, but couldn't? When devs take criticism to heart, and change games for the better, it's not a bad thing. Your gripes seem to be whose idea it was. When devs start changing things because the random game reviewer whines about it, then we're in trouble. Until then, play what you like. Ignore what you don't.

ttttrton
ttttrton

PS4........It won't do everything?? Playing or running physical media is important.  My PS3 is at the center of most of my entertainment because of this.  It's more mobile than my PC and is higher end than my laptop.  From HULU to streaming vids or watching Blu-Ray in 3D, it does it all.  I have all gaming systems and an high end gaming rig, but PS3 is my favorite because it really does everything without finicky software/firmware, sound issues and hacks.  May not be a master of all but a jack of all.  And what about the potential of the Blu-Ray media and games?  :(

chrisangelo2k7
chrisangelo2k7

Did this idiot just say that Marvel VS. Capcom 2 (which was only a dream match, no endings, and not even Win Quotes... WTFFFFF)  is "so lined on story" ???

Boy now I know why I stopped taking seriously Gamespot game reviews... Most of the reviewers are either naturally high or they just don't know what they're talking about... As a matter of fact, the MVC (Mainly 1, 3, and Ultimate 3) series had the most WTF storylines, and you just play it for the sake of fun.

And MK VS. DC actually had a very decent storyline that made sense, based that both the worlds consist of different realms and dimensions (compatibility). MVC series never even bothered explaining how Ryu ended up meeting Wolvering, or how Dante ended up fighting Dead Pool.

I'M OOOOUT...

WCAR18
WCAR18

New Gears is stupid. DC Injustice will be good. These guys calling MK 9 without Fatalities a clunky fighter is ridiculous. The fighting is fun and smooth. Doom 3 will be BETTER with a mounted flashlight. The whining over the change by Brendan is foolish.

Not every game will be COD because ID and Bioware decide to listen to their fans. FYI... I liked ME 3's ending but I don't have a problem looking at it again.

 

InSayNine
InSayNine

QFT needs an audio only version

destroyeur
destroyeur

Brendan, how do you manage to both work at Gamespot and do play by play commentary on Hockey Night in Canada?

elbauto
elbauto

F$%K I'll have nighjtmare with tha PS3 baby(again)Good video guys,nothing else...oh,I almost forget,I think DC Injustice will be great,the new Cyberpunk RPG too but i don't have a lot of faith in new Gears of War...

elbauto
elbauto

F$%K I'll have nighjtmare with tha PS3 baby(again)Good video guys,nothing else...

mahkcloud
mahkcloud

final fantasy 25th

december 18, 1987

Jestersmiles
Jestersmiles

I agree with one thing, A new Gears is way too soon. I mean here epic had a chance to grow, why fall back to " oh it those guys that make gears". I am even looking more forward to fortnite after hearing this.

 

Also it not like people where asking for a new gears.

thekey
thekey

All I care about is games I don't care about new consoles and I hope PC games steal the show.

 

 

Redley911
Redley911

GOW is just probably THE BEST third person shooter of all time

MagnusXilorius
MagnusXilorius

Well Silicon Knight's failed... I just hate that nothing was done with MGS Twin Snakes with the MGS HD Collection...

Jlanger96
Jlanger96

I agree with them that Sony makes the best first party games, and I hope the PS4, whenever it comes, has backwards compatibility.

Somnam3ulist
Somnam3ulist

Don't you think that complaining about fan response (and the POOR response from Bioware to EXTEND the ending rather than retooling it) is silly considering that the ending completely smacks in the face of the diverse endings of Mass Effect 1 & 2. You speak of abandoning artistic vision, and yet don't seem to realize that the outrage about Mass Effect 3's ending, was that it had none. I agree with you completely about Doom 3 and the flashlight being changed, but not about ME3 at all.

Daian
Daian

You guys really have to change the intro/outro music. :|

 

Other than that, great stuff.

Metroid345
Metroid345

Highly disagree with Brendan Sinclair on Gears of War having a 'shallow story with no substance'. The stories in the games are very linear, but the characters themselves do develop and offer interesting stories to tell for themselves. Sinclair mentioned that he read the first story arc of the comics (#1-6 I believe), but that gives him no right to offer a 'final' and 'concrete' opinion of the Gears story. Especially when the novels (I've only just finished the first one myself) offer an immersive, and emotional story that really exposes the characters and introduces their pasts while retaining the familiarity we have grown accustomed to. The story of Gears of War is far from shallow, and there is plenty of substance that can be used (whether you or I agree on it being used is a completely different argument) for creating new stories for future games in the series.

jinkaytm
jinkaytm

It's baird in the cuff's and onyx guards escorting.Not guy's in glowing masks

tommystockley
tommystockley

Some people just don't understand that this isn't a Mortal Kombat game... I'm a Mortal Kombat fan, and believe it or not, I accept this game for what it is, a DC Fighter. And what is up with these guys hating on Mortal Kombat? Did they even play the new game? Did they not try it competitively? Or maybe they should do what street fighter done and pump out the same game for 25 years with slightly revised graphics.

Megavideogamer
Megavideogamer

Gears of War will make MS some money before the 8th generation hits. That is all more cash for MS. Still I'll play new Gears of  war

Tallwhitemocha
Tallwhitemocha

"Artistic vision" doesn't excuse poor design and execution. And when that poor design negatively impacts the game play or story the developers have an obligation to the consumer to fix it. By Brendan's logic all those bad games gamespot reviews should be respected for their "artistic vision"; and the reviewers should just accept the games the way they are and stop being overly critical.

DigitalDame
DigitalDame moderator moderatorstaff

 @kedj E3 happened to QFT ;) Trust me there will be an episode later today (Friday June 29th)

Minasodrom
Minasodrom

@twztid13 critisizing is something different then making em change it!

twztid13
twztid13

 @Jestersmiles

 It seems that People Can Fly is doing most of the development, not Epic. I agree it's too soon, as I have yet to play through part 3, even though I bought it day one (but I did sell it :P).

RitsukoEX
RitsukoEX

@thekey

PC games steal the show? HA! what? in graphics? and thats it!

Metroid345
Metroid345

 @jinkaytm At the time this video was made, I believe there was  no news confirming that it was Baird (I believe that news came out today or late last night). But I do agree that "guys in masks" comment shows a tad bit of ignorance.

Polybren
Polybren

 @Tallwhitemocha I never said the faults should be excused. They're fair game for criticism in reviews and from fans. But even a bad creative decision has some inherent value, because those are the leaps into the unproven that yield the best creative decisions. If nobody had bad decisions to learn from, we'd get far fewer great decisions in the long run.

kedj
kedj

 @Synthia I've watched it :D What about getting a dedicated page for the Show?

twztid13
twztid13

 @Minasodrom  @twztid13

 What is the difference? ME fans decided to criticize Bioware for the misleading statements they made about the 3rd & final game in Shepard's story (said Bioware). What did they do different thanpeople that criticize other issues in gaming? Their collective voice was louder because it was a LOT of people, but they can't control the actions of a developer (meaning they can't "make em change it").

Jestersmiles
Jestersmiles

 @RitsukoEX  yeah steal the show just like most analyst have been saying it could due just that.,Console fanboy

Tallwhitemocha
Tallwhitemocha

 @PolybrenCreative leaps are great when they work-Braid, Journey, Mirrors Edge, Rayman and Catharine-but terrible when they don't. And when they don't the publisher should acknowledge it, fix it if possible; and if not make sure they learn from their mistake. The problem with publishers like SiliconKnights, Gearbox and now Bioware is that they don't cop to their mistakes and because of that don't learn from them. I get where you're coming from but I think you're cutting the publishing community to much slack. Thanks for replying and explaining your point further, I appreciate the chance to converse with someone in the industry.

twztid13
twztid13

 @Minasodrom  

 You are not understanding. The ONLY difference between legitimate criticism, and whether or not a game gets changed, is ENTIRELY up to the developer. The person that criticizes is okay if the devs of the game he finds fault with do nothing. If that same person has the exact same criticism, and that developer listens to it & changes the game, that person is bad. Very flawed, imho.

 

The short point is, the gamer that criticizes can NOT change the game. Only the devs can. You want to be mad cuz people have opinions, then you will be mad forever. Take your frustrations out on the devs that change stuff, not humans, who inherently have opinions on games, and are willing to voice them.

Minasodrom
Minasodrom

@twztid13 the difference is that they helped children to change the game ending. that goes way beyond criticizm imo. when they develop a game they should learn from past mistakes and not tangle with their finished creation. at least not in that fashion that it feels forced!