It's weird how this game gets such a high score, when the controls are so bad. I miss the old reviewers, those were actually good professionals who knew how to review a game.
It has a great atmosphere and good scares, sure, but that's about it. It can be finished in under an hour or so. Amnesia received the same score and was way, way better (and longer!), the only thing it didn't have was cutting edge graphics (but they were still pretty good and effective).
skr10's comments