If you don't want it to be frustrating to learn either works. If you want to play a realistic baseball game with your friend(s) then MLB 09 the show is your game. If you want a baseball game where its unrealistic and everyone is so buff that the worst hitter in baseball could hit a home run then The Bigs 2 is for you. I prefer MLB 09

NCAA football 2009. It was the same as 08.

I don't hate them i love them i just wish they would make more RPG's and action-adventures