Now that's a list thread worth replying to. I agree with none of your choices, but they're personal and I enjoyed reading the write ups.
Some-Mist has a very interesting list too. I really need to give Bayonetta a shot (I hate its art style, but if its combat is better than DMC3's I should play it!)
Here are my favourites, in no particular order
Unreal Tournament 2004
This game, in my opinion, is the epitome of the pure deathmath genre. Yes, I think it's better than Quake 3 and UT99. Its movement mechanics really make it reach the next level. I was amazed when I first realized what dodge-jumping and wall-jumping entailed, and I still am. The community never really took off as much as its 1999 predecessors, which is a shame.
STALKER: Shadow of Chernobyl
Despite all of its glitches and lack of polish, this game stands above all others in the single-player FPS genre. Its core gameplay is tight, its AI is very good, its environments are amazing, its atmosphere is unequalled, and it's just a very interesting game experience.
Ikaruga
Ikaruga is not the best-designed shmup. It's not very hard (well, compared the to rest of the genre), and it's not very deep. But as an overall game, it's my favourite of the genre. It's beautiful, its soundtrack is amazing, and I actually like its color-changing gimmick a lot, a lot, a lot. When the genre fell out of the mainstream, I kinda stopped paying attention to it, until this gem came out for the Dreamcast and woke me up. Shmups are still my favourite genre, though I don't have enough free time to actually be decent at them anymore.
Grim Fandango
I wish I could say that my favourite adventure game is something other than everyone else's favourite adventure game. It's not. Grim Fandango has such a charming, funny, well-written story that it's impossible for me to name anything else.
F-Zero GX
My favourite racer of all times, by a very wide margin. It's unforgiving, it's fast, it's silly. It's both fun and mean. It makes you want to throw your gamepad at your TV, but you can't stop playing it because it's so good.
Aquaria/Metroid Prime/Super Metroid
I couldn't choose which one I prefered, so here's all three. I love them all for the same reasons: their worlds are perfectly designed, they are very atmospheric games with excellent exploration, they are contemplative and interesting, they have great soundtracks and they're beautiful games. (To me, Metroid Prime is a perfect 3D successor to Super Metroid. Aquaria is different enough to stand on its own, and it's high-quality enough to be compared directly to its influences.)
FTL: Faster Than Light
This is a game that I will still be replaying 20 years from now. Its design is fantastic and timeless, and everything about it is essentially perfect. These guys took a (fairly simple) concept and explored it in depth to create a well-balanced, extremely well designed game that does everything that you'd expect it to do. I can't wait to see what they come up with next.
Honorable mentions: Death Rally (the original), Panzer Dragoon Saga, Dangun Feveron (for its crazyness), DoDonpachi (for its design), No One Lives Forever 1&2, Pac-Man, Shadow of the Colossus, Vampire The Masquerade - Bloodlines, Batman: Arkham City (imo, this is the game that represents the 360/PS3 generation)
Log in to comment