Haven't played dark souls so I won't comment there. I do like skyrim more then demon souls though and I played that. On a side note for anyone who has played both the ps3 and xbox360 versions. Just WOW. I initially purchased it for ps3 but its one of the worst ports ever. Real talk. Two different games. If you played the ps3 version only I can understand all logic
I never implied they HAVE to pick the highest scoring game, was just throwing a few numbers out there. As for gears 3 getting a 9.5 here this is true, thus the reason I said well go ahead and put it in the running. Your one game greater then the other IMO are not facts toward the cause. Uncharted 3 could easily get a 9.5 here seeing its predecessor was one of the best games ever made in reviewers eyes. Most perfectt scores ever(can't remember exact amount). Anyways, they(gamespot) do pick the winner but we can still debate it here all we want. Just bring facts with your opinions
In the running and winning are two different things. Portal 2 was good for what is was worth but Definetely not epic in anyone's right. Hasn't even benn mentioned around here. Gears 3 is the lowest scoring of the series as well as Forza. Didn't improve enough. Skyrim I'll give you has a chance but besides that it's still batman, with it's MAJOR improvement or UC3( doesn't need to be released yet, we've seen enough). And played if you like the full multiplayer like me
Plus there all going against the only unbashed multiplatform game here in system wars. Batman is so well received amongst all hermits, lems, and cows alike. We all seen to agree on that for the most part
Even if skyrim beats the last one it still won't get GOTY. It won it already plus as already mentioned its easier to put that as rpg of the year due to its overall basis. New IPS and or great multiplayer usually get GOTY
Dark souls or skyrim will get rpg of the year. They fit that category perfect. Batman as a new ip this gen has best chance even though I love uncharted more. Uncharted got GOTY already and batman is a major improvement also. Not often we see a comic brought to videos done right
TW2 is good but not GOTY. Lots of quality. Gears of war 3 and Forza too. But batman and uncharted front runners still based on batman metacritic and we all know uncharteds track record
So with 2 months left which will win. Battlefield 3 or MW3 for multiplayer of the year. Skyrim or dark souls rpg of the year. Which will win GOTY? Uncharted 3 or Batman?
Log in to comment