Xbox One's Rise of the Tomb Raider VS PS 4's Unchartered 4

the one that didn't copy tomb raider.

Which is funny considering Tomb Raider sold better on the PS3 and PS4 respectively than the Xbox Consoles.

id rather watch indiana jones temple of the crystal skull then play an uncharted game

im more about gameplay then clickin buttons to get thru a crap story game

Hype for both games. Day One for both of these games.

Batman has a lot of exploration and stealth is used just as much as combat. It would do the games a great disservice to just call them a beat em up.

Uncharted's major gameplay focus is found in the TPS shoot out sections. It's hook is the verticality the same way that Vanquish's hook is the ability to slide across the ground at high speeds.

Batman has a lot of exploration/puzzle solving and stealth is used just as much as combat. It would do the games a great disservice to just call them a beat em up.

Uncharted's major gameplay focus is found in the TPS shoot out sections. It's hook is the verticality the same way that Vanquish's hook is the ability to slide across the ground at high speeds.

Good thing Uncharted has better gameplay than Tomb Raider then :) Making bigger levels to explore is no use if the gun battles and actual action takes place in linear boxed areas. Uncharted 2 knew what it wanted to be and it did what it did vastly better than Tomb Raider did. That's why Tomb Raiders reception was luke warm compared to Uncharted 2's. Don't get me wrong Uncharted 3 is a huge let down in comparison, but Uncharted 2 had pretty snazzy design ideas.

And as you said earlier, Uncharted 4 is a fully current gen game. It's not releasing on PS3 so it has more room to breathe from a game design standpoint.

Vanquish's slide is a mechanic, not a style of gameplay like Uncharted's verticality. It's not just verticality though, it's traversial in general. It's not like other TPS games.

Uncharted 4. The fact that Tomb Raider is even considered to be in the same league as Uncharted makes me laugh.

TR isn't an Xbone exclusive.

Uncharted 4 will be a million times better.

Both will be pretty awesome I think... But considering I only have an Xbone, definitely looking forward to TR more.

Uncharted 4 is very much action adventure. It's pointless to compare it to past titles in the series. You'll be able to get through most of Uncharted 4 by not shooting at all, or even killing. People can choose how much action or how much adventure they want since the areas are open and have multiple paths.

@shibua: lol keep dreaming scrub, PC and PS4 users will get it next year.

Bookmarked hehe

PC will probably get its, that what the timed duration is for as MS will also publish the PC version

Sadly PS4 is going to miss out on the greatest Tombraider and action adventure game ever made

@shibua: hahahaha keep dreaming matey.

If this Tomb Raider recieves massive critical acclaim and sells well I would almost bet that Microsoft ends up buying the IP, with a film to follow shortly after.

OT: I'll enjoy both. Although I have a feeling the new tomb raider will come out on PS4 in the period Uncharted was delayed too.

They both satisfy that treasure hunter roaming an ancient land itch. Uncharted with its many locales already and Tomb Raider exploring that Japanese island with all the creepy war relics.

Didn't sony offer tomb raider as a gift? The series' stale.

Uncharted is ballin'

MS are in the early stages of acquiring CD's, SE ain't interested in the Tombradier franchise and MS publishing and funding the game is the first step in bringing the Tombradier franchise over as a X1 exclusive franchise

If MS paid for timed exclusive why the hell would they publish the game for SE, they paid for more than timed exclusivity they paid for the whole game

One I will enjoy this year and the other not so much.

All your time on here has been lie after lie. Cut the shit. Or you could actually give me a reason to believe what you say and show me some proof.

I liked tomb raider more then any of the uncharted games. But I'll be playing both uncharted 4 and tomb raider once it comes to ps4.

@shibua: Do you actually believe this shit you're spewing?

It's laughably retarded, why the hell would anyone buy Tomb Raider nowadays? the series is still mocked for how lame alot of the entries are, RoTR is going to flop hard.

Have you seen Shibua's other posts? Everything Shibua posts is just made up, constant shit spewing. When you can't beat em, make shit up.

@ImBatman-: Oh I've seen him on IGN and Gamespot, it's sad how someone can be this stupid.

I will buy and play them both. Neither warrants a day one buy from me, but I'll get them when they reach $20 on Amazon.

I'm more hyped for Tomb Raider after the great job done on the 2013 game, I liked it better than any of the Uncharted games. That being said, I'll probably still end up getting both.

uncharted. rise of the tomb raider hasnt shown me that its better than uncharted other than the aiming isnt as clunky

Uncharted 4 will probably be better then tomb raider as its Naughty Dog after all but you don't get to play that game on ps4 this year ... you only get greatness awaits

Ill play both, but obviously Uncharted is the one Im hyped for the most.

I'll play Tomb Raider when its $25 or free one PSN+ cuz thats how I got the first Tomb Raider.

Tomb Raider because she's a hot piece of ass.

Well I gotta admit the last Tomb Raider was/is one of my favorite games ever. I'm kinda asshurt still the sequel (probably) won't be on my PS4, and I'm not buying the last gen version on my 360.

If Uncharted 4 can match or exceed Uncharted 2, then that'll be more than enough for me, 'cause UC2 was the only game I couldn't seem to stop playing in the series. I'm about 99.9% positive UC4 will have a much stronger narrative than Rise of The Tomb Raider, because Naughty Dog excels in writing characters and scripts. But the gameplay department though; coin flip. This is where Rise of The Tomb Raider can potentially be stronger than Uncharted 4.

I used to like tomb raider before it became an uncharted clone but anyway I will pick tomb raider because uncharted sucked imo I just can't get into it.

Uncharted got the better story, graphic and pretty much everything except for the gameplay.

Uncharted told the same story 3 times

Better story and graphics? Uncharted 3 was better graphically than Tomb Raider? I beg to differ but that's all based on opinion.

Difference? PS4 gets both games

@finalstar2007: tomb raider hasn't been announced for PS4

I would have thought by now people stopped falling for these gaming sales puff. Nonetheless I'm sure both would be fun. I'm looking forward to uncharted more because based on past performance NaughtyDog has a much better record than squareenix.

Better story? lol. Better graphics? UC3 looked worse than TR, so...

Me too, provided that Uncharted isn't like UC3. I still haven't finished that game.

I had to force myself to finish UC3...wasn't a fan. I am hoping for a better game with UC4.

UC 3 sucked True.

The Uncharted 3 people aren't at Naughty Dog anymore. TLoU people are on Uncharted 4, which means guaranteed GOAT status.

Uncharted. Tomb Raider is a 360 game and that last one sucked ass.

That is good news

Pass.

they need to kill the 360 version of this game....and announce its never coming to playstation otherwise im holding out buying this on xbox one

theres no reason for to buy it for 60 when i can pick up the remastered version on ps4 with all dlc for 20 or whatever later on

ANNOUNCE Never on playstation or im waiting till its 20 dollars on pc/ps4

and announce that the 360 version couldn't run the game and shut that one down being able to run on 360 means the game didn't truely go next gen look at batman see the diff in marketing CANT RUN on older systems

jesus its like these ocmpanies dunno what hype means anymore or exclusives

u say ur GAME CANNOT run on ps4 or sony platforms and u say it can't run on old system either = hype if u dont have hype nobody gives a crap

@indzman: I'll take Tomb Raider over Uncharted 4.

Unfortunately I only have a PS4 and so will have to wait. As long as it doesn't become a mindless shooter like Uncharted that is. That is why I hated Uncharted, the first time you even get control of Nathan in Drake's Fortune he immediately picks up a handgun and starts killing pirates.

If Tomb Raider starts doing something similar I won't be buying either of them. I did think Uncharted was about treasure hunting but didn't realise that by the time I'd find some treasure I'd have killed a couple of thousand people.

Tomb Raider (2013) was too heavy on the killing as well but at least there she was on an island and trying to survive. Nathan shoots his way through an island of mercenaries and then goes back for seconds, thirds and now fourths in later games. I'm bored of that shooting for the sake of shooting crap games did last gen.