Ultimate PS3 vs 360 Battle Revival 80+Metacritic Library Duel to the Death.

This topic is locked from further discussion.

#1 Posted by Eddie-Vedder (7802 posts) -

Good Day System Wars!

vs

  • I have compiled every AA+ game on Metacritic for the 360 and the PS3 that is NOT on the other system, doesn't matter if it's multiplat or exclusive, this is the fairest way to compare the 360 to the PS3 in terms of Quality Games.
  • No PSN Titles. No Arcade Titles. No DLC. Only Retail games.
  • The PS3 has more exclusives, more variety, more award winning games and what I consider to be very crucial a much more up to date library.
  • This thread isn't meant to sway your already defined preference, it was only made with the System Wars Metagame in mind. So be reasonable!
  • I'll ad this to my sig and update it whenever a new game comes out.
  • It is what it is.
  • Keep it clean.

Xbox 360

Total: 40

2005 Titles: 6

2006 Titles: 7

2007 Titles: 7

2008 Titles: 7

2009 Titles: 5

2010 Titles: 4

2011 Titles: 4

2012 Titles: 1

Exclusives: 23

  1. Gears of War 94 - 2006
  2. Halo 3 94 - 2007
  3. Gears of War 2 93 - 2008
  4. Forza Motorsport 3 92 - 2009
  5. Mass Effect 91 - 2007
  6. Forza Motorsport 4 91 - 2011
  7. Gears of War 3 91 - 2011
  8. Halo Reach 91 - 2010
  9. Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter 90 - 2006
  10. Forza Motorsport 2 90 - 2007
  11. The Witcher 2 89 - 2012
  12. Fable II 89 - 2008
  13. Left 4 Dead 89 - 2008
  14. Left 4 Dead 2 89 - 2009
  15. Project Gotham Racing 3 88 - 2005
  16. Call of Duty 2 86 - 2005
  17. Dance Central 2 86 - 2011
  18. Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Conviction 85 ? 2010
  19. Project Gotham Racing 4 85 ? 2007
  20. Dead or Alive 85 ? 2005
  21. Dead Rising 85 - 2006
  22. Viva Pinata 84 - 2006
  23. Halo 3 ODST 83 - 2009
  24. Crackdown 83 - 2007
  25. Alan Wake 83 - 2010
  26. Halo Wars 82 - 2009
  27. Dance Central 82 - 2010
  28. Viva Pinata TIP 82 - 2008
  29. Halo Combat Evolved: Anniversary Edition 82 - 2011
  30. Stoked Big Air Edition 81 - 2009
  31. Rockstar Table Tennis 81 - 2006
  32. Condemned 81 - 2005
  33. Saints Row 81 - 2006
  34. Perfect Dark Zero 81 - 2005
  35. Ace Combat 6 80 - 2007
  36. Moto GP'06 80 - 2006
  37. Naruto 80 - 2008
  38. NBA 2k6 80 - 2005
  39. Flatout: Ultimate Carnage 80 - 2007
  40. Bully: Scholarship Edition 80 - 2008

Sony Playstation 3

Total: 43

2005 Titles: 0

2006 Titles: 1

2007 Titles: 5

2008 Titles: 10

2009 Titles: 8

2010 Titles: 7

2011 Titles: 10

2012 Titles: 2

Exclusives: 33

  1. Uncharted 2: Among Thieves 96 - 2009
  2. LittleBigPlanet 95 - 2008
  3. Metal Gear Solid: Guns of the Patriots 94 - 2008
  4. God of War III 92 - 2010
  5. LittleBigPlanet 2 92 - 2011
  6. Uncharted 3: Drakes Deception 92 - 2011
  7. The ICO and Shadow of the Colossus Collection 91 - 2011
  8. MLB 10: The Show 91 - 2010
  9. God of War Collection 91 - 2009
  10. Killzone 2 91 - 2009
  11. MLB 11 The Show 90 - 2011
  12. Demon's Souls 89 - 2009
  13. Racthet & Clank Future: Tools of Destruction 89 - 2007
  14. Uncharted: Drake's Fortune 88 - 2007
  15. Ninja Gaiden Sigma 88 - 2007
  16. Heavy Rain 87 - 2010
  17. MLB 09: The Show 90 - 2009
  18. Wipeout HD 87 - 2008
  19. Resistance 2 87 - 2008
  20. Ratchet & Clank Future: A Crack in Time 87 - 2009
  21. MLB 12 The Show 86 - 2012
  22. Valkyria Chronicles 86 - 2008
  23. Resistance: Fall of Man 86 - 2006
  24. The Sly Collection 85 - 2010
  25. MLB 08: The Show 85 - 2008
  26. Infamous 85 - 2009
  27. Godo f War Origins Collection 84 - 2011
  28. Killzone 3 84 - 2011
  29. Gran Turismo 5 84 - 2010
  30. Motorstorm 84 - 2007
  31. Warhawk 84 - 2007
  32. Resistance 3 83 - 2011
  33. Infamous 2 82 - 2011
  34. Modnation Racers 82 - 2010
  35. Motorstorm: Pacific Rift 82 - 2008
  36. Singstar 82 - 2008
  37. Jak and Daxter Collection 81 - 2012
  38. Prince of Persia ****c Trilogy HD 81 - 2011
  39. Hot Shots Golf: Out of Bounds 81 - 2008
  40. Disagea 4: A Promise Unforgotten 80 - 2011
  41. Yakuza 3 80 - 2010
  42. Buzz! Quiz TV 80 - 2008
  43. Buzz! Quiz World 80 - 2009
#2 Posted by gamebreakerz__ (5120 posts) -
We didn't need another on bro.....
#3 Posted by waltefmoney (18030 posts) -

You included collections.

Wait a minute, you're this prick? You're a bandodger :lol:

#4 Posted by Eddie-Vedder (7802 posts) -

You included collections.

waltefmoney

Point? Multiplats only count when they're 360/PC? Is that it? Oh look Halo Combat Evolved is up there too.

#5 Posted by shinrabanshou (8458 posts) -

Comparisons of metascores are inherently flawed. Not only do they utilise different sources to determine a score, but the different review scores are weighted by an unknown amount in an entirely arbitrary and subjective manner.

#6 Posted by Eddie-Vedder (7802 posts) -
We didn't need another on bro.....gamebreakerz__
What's wrong with updated data, that's all it is. Updated data.
#7 Posted by waltefmoney (18030 posts) -

Point? Multiplats only count when they're 360/PC? Is that it? Oh look Halo Combat Evolved is up there too.

Eddie-Vedder

Wait, you're including multiplats too? Then why not include all the multiplats?

#8 Posted by Eddie-Vedder (7802 posts) -

Comparisons of metascores are inherently flawed. Not only do they utilise different sources to determine a score, but the different review scores are weighted by an unknown amount in an entirely arbitrary and subjective manner.

shinrabanshou
Obviously, no need to single out Metacritic either, REVIEWS period are a flawed way to judge these things, but they are also our only way try to keep it objective. Yes it's flawed, as is system wars. It is what it is. Either way, I did include lists, with actual games listed, so it's not just mindless numbers and stats.
#9 Posted by gamebreakerz__ (5120 posts) -
[QUOTE="gamebreakerz__"]We didn't need another on bro.....Eddie-Vedder
What's wrong with updated data, that's all it is. Updated data.

Post it tomorrow or in a few days instead of thread spam.... Mods will just lock them all.
#10 Posted by Eddie-Vedder (7802 posts) -

[QUOTE="Eddie-Vedder"]

Point? Multiplats only count when they're 360/PC? Is that it? Oh look Halo Combat Evolved is up there too.

waltefmoney

Wait, you're including multiplats too? Then why not include all the multiplats?

I did include all multiplats, just not multiplats that are on both 360 and PS3 because that's redundant. They cancel each other out. Check out the list, plenty of multiplats like Mass Effect, Left 4 Dead, Bully, etc etc.
#11 Posted by waltefmoney (18030 posts) -

Obviously, no need to single out Metacritic either, REVIEWS period are a flawed way to judge these things, but they are also our only way try to keep it objective. Yes it's flawed, as is system wars. It is what it is. Either way, I did include lists, with actual games listed, so it's not just mindless numbers and stats. Eddie-Vedder

And can I just ask - what in the world possessed you to make the exact same thread that you made with your banned acount months ago? Are you trying to get banned?

#12 Posted by PAL360 (27158 posts) -

Like i said in your other thread, it´s pretty easy to make any system look bad, if you exclude every good stuff on it and turn the few negatives into something substancial!

People get games, not exclusives. Try to make a thread about overall libraries and you will figure 360 has the clear advantage.

#13 Posted by waltefmoney (18030 posts) -

I did include all multiplats, just not multiplats that are on both 360 and PS3 because that's redundant. They cancel each other out. Check out the list, plenty of multiplats like Mass Effect, Left 4 Dead, Bully, etc etc. Eddie-Vedder

Not when you're limiting it to games that scored 80+..

#14 Posted by Eddie-Vedder (7802 posts) -

Like i said in your other thread, it´s pretty easy to make any system look bad, if you exclude every good stuff on it and turn the few negatives into something substancial!

People get games, not exclusives. Try to make a thread about overall libraries and you will figure 360 has the clear advantage.

PAL360
You didn't read the thread did you? This is overall, there are multiplats included. These are all the best games of this generation on each of these consoles.
#15 Posted by Eddie-Vedder (7802 posts) -

[QUOTE="Eddie-Vedder"]I did include all multiplats, just not multiplats that are on both 360 and PS3 because that's redundant. They cancel each other out. Check out the list, plenty of multiplats like Mass Effect, Left 4 Dead, Bully, etc etc. waltefmoney

Not when you're limiting it to games that scored 80+..

I had to stop somewhere, the further down the more work, and this is a perfectly reasonable cutoff.
#16 Posted by waltefmoney (18030 posts) -

I had to stop somewhere, the further down the more work, and this is a perfectly reasonable cutoff. Eddie-Vedder

Well it isn't - Metacritic acknowledges games that scored 75+ as "Generally favorable reviews", you could have stopped there, this isnt' Gamespot.

#18 Posted by PAL360 (27158 posts) -

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

Like i said in your other thread, it´s pretty easy to make any system look bad, if you exclude every good stuff on it and turn the few negatives into something substancial!

People get games, not exclusives. Try to make a thread about overall libraries and you will figure 360 has the clear advantage.

Eddie-Vedder

You didn't read the thread did you? This is overall, there are multiplats included. These are all the best games of this generation on each of these consoles.

My bad, sorry. Some multiplats are indeed there. Still, if you are talking about quality games on both consoles, you should includde A games and downloadable stuff.

#19 Posted by Eddie-Vedder (7802 posts) -

[QUOTE="Eddie-Vedder"]I had to stop somewhere, the further down the more work, and this is a perfectly reasonable cutoff. waltefmoney

Well it isn't - Metacritic acknowledges games that scored 75+ as "Generally favorable reviews", you could have stopped there, this isnt' Gamespot.

Well it isn't? :lol: LOL dude. Yes it is. I'm not some mindless moron, 80+ is PERFECTLY fine to debate quality games. I'd have no problem if you made the list lower, but don't pretend that it being at 80+ makes this list meaningless and if was was 75 it would all of a sudden be perfection.

  • These are the last 10 games on the 360's list
  • Stoked Big Air Edition 81 - 2009
  • Rockstar Table Tennis 81 - 2006
  • Condemned 81 – 2005
  • Saints Row 81 – 2006
  • Perfect Dark Zero 81 – 2005
  • Ace Combat 6 80 – 2007
  • Moto GP'06 80 – 2006
  • Naruto 80 – 2008
  • NBA 2k6 80 - 2005
  • Flatout: Ultimate Carnage 80 - 2007
  • Bully: Scholarship Edition 80 - 2008

Noone cares about these games, I'd say I've gone low enough. And chill out with the hostility, I have no Idea why this is making you so angry, it's just a list of facts. Like I said in the OP, it is what it is. Chill out.

#20 Posted by waltefmoney (18030 posts) -

Well it isn't? :lol: LOL dude. Yes it is. I'm not some mindless moron, 80+ is PERFECTLY fine to debate quality games. I'd have no problem if you made the list lower, but don't pretend that it being at 80+ makes this list meaningless and if was was 75 it would all of a sudden be perfection.

  • These are the last 10 games on the 360's list
  • Stoked Big Air Edition 81 - 2009
  • Rockstar Table Tennis 81 - 2006
  • Condemned 81 – 2005
  • Saints Row 81 – 2006
  • Perfect Dark Zero 81 – 2005
  • Ace Combat 6 80 – 2007
  • Moto GP'06 80 – 2006
  • Naruto 80 – 2008
  • NBA 2k6 80 - 2005
  • Flatout: Ultimate Carnage 80 - 2007
  • Bully: Scholarship Edition 80 - 2008

Noone cares about these games, I'd say I've gone low enough. And chill out with the hostility, I have no Idea why this is making you so angry, it's just a list of facts. Like I said in the OP, it is what it is. Chill out.

Eddie-Vedder

"I made my own rules bro, I win by them"

And yes, I have a dislike for bandodgers, sue me.

#21 Posted by freedomfreak (42322 posts) -

lol collections.

and we didn't need another one.

#22 Posted by kuraimen (28078 posts) -
Everyone knows the PS3 library destroy the 360's. The 360 doesn't even have real games anymore.
#23 Posted by sts106mat (20370 posts) -
Everyone knows the PS3 library destroy the 360's. The 360 doesn't even have real games anymore.kuraimen
you really are one of the worst trolls in history dude, at least try and make an effort like tintedeyes / tormentos used to.
#24 Posted by Badosh (12741 posts) -
but they are also our only way try to keep it objective.Eddie-Vedder
What? Nothing about reviews are objective.
#25 Posted by Eddie-Vedder (7802 posts) -
[QUOTE="Eddie-Vedder"]but they are also our only way try to keep it objective.Badosh
What? Nothing about reviews are objective.

Why did you leave out the rest of the quote?
#26 Posted by Badosh (12741 posts) -
] Why did you leave out the rest of the quote?Eddie-Vedder
Because I could?
#27 Posted by sonic1564 (3265 posts) -

Guys its a cow and arbitor's friend. Of course he's gonna say something positive towards sony and the PS3. TC, if you want to see someone agree with you, go to IGN since it is cow paridise.

#28 Posted by Eddie-Vedder (7802 posts) -
[QUOTE="Eddie-Vedder"]] Why did you leave out the rest of the quote?Badosh
Because I could?

You just self owned yourself lol. Your response was in the original quote. Derp.
#29 Posted by Eddie-Vedder (7802 posts) -

Guys its a cow and arbitor's friend. Of course he's gonna say something positive towards sony and the PS3. TC, if you want to see someone agree with you, go to IGN since it is cow paridise.

sonic1564
It's who's friend? Why are you angry?
#30 Posted by sonic1564 (3265 posts) -

[QUOTE="sonic1564"]

Guys its a cow and arbitor's friend. Of course he's gonna say something positive towards sony and the PS3. TC, if you want to see someone agree with you, go to IGN since it is cow paridise.

Eddie-Vedder

It's who's friend? Why are you angry?

You are arbitor's friend. I not angry, you just failed this useless troll and should play you games and not care what everyone else does. You're just like shadowmoses.

#31 Posted by sonic1564 (3265 posts) -

Everyone knows the PS3 library destroy the 360's. The 360 doesn't even have real games anymore.kuraimen

Can you at least try to troll or just not troll at all.

#32 Posted by Eddie-Vedder (7802 posts) -

[QUOTE="Eddie-Vedder"][QUOTE="sonic1564"]

Guys its a cow and arbitor's friend. Of course he's gonna say something positive towards sony and the PS3. TC, if you want to see someone agree with you, go to IGN since it is cow paridise.

sonic1564

It's who's friend? Why are you angry?

You are arbitor's friend. I not angry, you just failed this useless troll and should play you games and not care what everyone else does. You're just like shadowmoses.

I have no idea who your talking about. And this isn't a troll. These are facts that you can look up.
#33 Posted by Badosh (12741 posts) -
You just self owned yourself lol. Your response was in the original quote. Derp. Eddie-Vedder
No where did you state that reviews are not objective, you say they are flawed and continue to use them as if they are in any way, useful.
#34 Posted by tjricardo089 (7429 posts) -

This is the fourth «Ultimate/Final battle PS3/360» I've seen..

#35 Posted by sonic1564 (3265 posts) -

[QUOTE="sonic1564"]

[QUOTE="Eddie-Vedder"] It's who's friend? Why are you angry? Eddie-Vedder

You are arbitor's friend. I not angry, you just failed this useless troll and should play you games and not care what everyone else does. You're just like shadowmoses.

I have no idea who your talking about. And this isn't a troll. These are facts that you can look up.

Want a fact? Here's a fact, you have included collections that I can play on the PS2. It seems a waist to add stupid collections if they don't count cow. You're just like arbitor. What are you going to do now? I'm looking more towards you saying that you get laid more than anyone here.

#36 Posted by HavocV3 (7950 posts) -

[QUOTE="Eddie-Vedder"]

Well it isn't? :lol: LOL dude. Yes it is. I'm not some mindless moron, 80+ is PERFECTLY fine to debate quality games. I'd have no problem if you made the list lower, but don't pretend that it being at 80+ makes this list meaningless and if was was 75 it would all of a sudden be perfection.

  • These are the last 10 games on the 360's list
  • Stoked Big Air Edition 81 - 2009
  • Rockstar Table Tennis 81 - 2006
  • Condemned 81 – 2005
  • Saints Row 81 – 2006
  • Perfect Dark Zero 81 – 2005
  • Ace Combat 6 80 – 2007
  • Moto GP'06 80 – 2006
  • Naruto 80 – 2008
  • NBA 2k6 80 - 2005
  • Flatout: Ultimate Carnage 80 - 2007
  • Bully: Scholarship Edition 80 - 2008

Noone cares about these games, I'd say I've gone low enough. And chill out with the hostility, I have no Idea why this is making you so angry, it's just a list of facts. Like I said in the OP, it is what it is. Chill out.

waltefmoney

"I made my own rules bro, I win by them"

And yes, I have a dislike for bandodgers, sue me.

let me fuel your hatred.

http://www.gamespot.com/forums/topic/27359395/carmack-either-console-could-look-superior?page=11

post #4.

#37 Posted by Badosh (12741 posts) -

This is the fourth «Ultimate/Final battle PS3/360» I've seen..

tjricardo089
Really? It's at least the 10th I've seen.
#38 Posted by LazySloth718 (2345 posts) -

To me 360 wins

Hear me out

Yes PS3 has more/better exclusives.

But %90 of what I play are multiplats.

And too many PS3 multiplats are botch jobs.

My use of the 360 is not a vote for Halo over Uncharted

My use of the 360 is a vote for Fallout 3, Fallout NV, Oblivion and Skyrim over Uncharted.

#39 Posted by waltefmoney (18030 posts) -

let me fuel your hatred.

http://www.gamespot.com/forums/topic/27359395/carmack-either-console-could-look-superior?page=11

post #4.

HavocV3

He was banned originally?

What the hell mods?

#40 Posted by kuraimen (28078 posts) -

[QUOTE="kuraimen"]Everyone knows the PS3 library destroy the 360's. The 360 doesn't even have real games anymore.sonic1564

Can you at least try to troll or just not troll at all.

Ok, but you shouldn't get so mad.
#41 Posted by Eddie-Vedder (7802 posts) -

[QUOTE="waltefmoney"]

[QUOTE="Eddie-Vedder"]

Well it isn't? :lol: LOL dude. Yes it is. I'm not some mindless moron, 80+ is PERFECTLY fine to debate quality games. I'd have no problem if you made the list lower, but don't pretend that it being at 80+ makes this list meaningless and if was was 75 it would all of a sudden be perfection.

  • These are the last 10 games on the 360's list
  • Stoked Big Air Edition 81 - 2009
  • Rockstar Table Tennis 81 - 2006
  • Condemned 81 – 2005
  • Saints Row 81 – 2006
  • Perfect Dark Zero 81 – 2005
  • Ace Combat 6 80 – 2007
  • Moto GP'06 80 – 2006
  • Naruto 80 – 2008
  • NBA 2k6 80 - 2005
  • Flatout: Ultimate Carnage 80 - 2007
  • Bully: Scholarship Edition 80 - 2008

Noone cares about these games, I'd say I've gone low enough. And chill out with the hostility, I have no Idea why this is making you so angry, it's just a list of facts. Like I said in the OP, it is what it is. Chill out.

HavocV3

"I made my own rules bro, I win by them"

And yes, I have a dislike for bandodgers, sue me.

let me fuel your hatred.

http://www.gamespot.com/forums/topic/27359395/carmack-either-console-could-look-superior?page=11

post #4.

Why so much hate? These lists of facts of mine really piss you guys off. And your not throwing anything anywhere, This account I'm on was banned. Gamespot let me back because of the new rules. None of this is a secret, you can stop pretending we're under the old CaseyWegner regime.
#42 Posted by Eddie-Vedder (7802 posts) -

[QUOTE="HavocV3"]

let me fuel your hatred.

http://www.gamespot.com/forums/topic/27359395/carmack-either-console-could-look-superior?page=11

post #4.

waltefmoney

He was banned originally?

What the hell mods?

New rules, dude, you can ask for your original account too, and stop bandodging.
#43 Posted by waltefmoney (18030 posts) -

New rules, dude, you can ask for your original account too, and stop bandodging. Eddie-Vedder

I was under the impression they only bring back decent users. Why are you back?

#44 Posted by Eddie-Vedder (7802 posts) -

[QUOTE="Eddie-Vedder"]New rules, dude, you can ask for your original account too, and stop bandodging. waltefmoney

I was under the impression they only bring back decent users. Why are you back?

I see why you need to keep the act up then.
#45 Posted by sonic1564 (3265 posts) -

[QUOTE="sonic1564"]

[QUOTE="kuraimen"]Everyone knows the PS3 library destroy the 360's. The 360 doesn't even have real games anymore.kuraimen

Can you at least try to troll or just not troll at all.

Ok, but you shouldn't get so mad.

I'm not mad, but you are a stupid troll. Just saying

#46 Posted by waltefmoney (18030 posts) -

I see why you need to keep the act up then. Eddie-Vedder

I've never been banned. There are users on this board who aren't so dumb as to get themselves banned.. several times.

#47 Posted by sts106mat (20370 posts) -

[QUOTE="Eddie-Vedder"]I see why you need to keep the act up then. waltefmoney

I've never been banned. There are users on this board who aren't so dumb as to get themselves banned.. several times.

same here, i have never been banned, got suspended for a week once for calling someone an idiot i think.
#48 Posted by razgriz_101 (16871 posts) -

[QUOTE="waltefmoney"]

[QUOTE="Eddie-Vedder"]I had to stop somewhere, the further down the more work, and this is a perfectly reasonable cutoff. Eddie-Vedder

Well it isn't - Metacritic acknowledges games that scored 75+ as "Generally favorable reviews", you could have stopped there, this isnt' Gamespot.

Well it isn't? :lol: LOL dude. Yes it is. I'm not some mindless moron, 80+ is PERFECTLY fine to debate quality games. I'd have no problem if you made the list lower, but don't pretend that it being at 80+ makes this list meaningless and if was was 75 it would all of a sudden be perfection.

  • These are the last 10 games on the 360's list
  • Stoked Big Air Edition 81 - 2009
  • Rockstar Table Tennis 81 - 2006
  • Condemned 81 – 2005
  • Saints Row 81 – 2006
  • Perfect Dark Zero 81 – 2005
  • Ace Combat 6 80 – 2007
  • Moto GP'06 80 – 2006
  • Naruto 80 – 2008
  • NBA 2k6 80 - 2005
  • Flatout: Ultimate Carnage 80 - 2007
  • Bully: Scholarship Edition 80 - 2008

Noone cares about these games, I'd say I've gone low enough. And chill out with the hostility, I have no Idea why this is making you so angry, it's just a list of facts. Like I said in the OP, it is what it is. Chill out.

Ace combat 6 is probably a better game than any polished turd most people hype on here and one of the most underrated games this gen, maybe you should go get familiar with the series.

Bully's a cult classic from last gen aswell, and strangely im replaying it so yes there is still people out there that care.Just because it aint new and shiny doesnt mean people dont care.

#49 Posted by super600 (30947 posts) -

[QUOTE="Eddie-Vedder"]New rules, dude, you can ask for your original account too, and stop bandodging. waltefmoney

I was under the impression they only bring back decent users. Why are you back?

Their letting everyone back,but the mods and admins are most likely watching the TC.

#50 Posted by super600 (30947 posts) -

I hate when people use arbitary categories to show howsuperior their platform is to another platform.