SW Votes: Best Pokemon of all time? (Charizard Dominates)

@jg4xchamp: This is Pokemon War, we battle to see who can win in points. Only the top will survive.

1. Gengar

2. Fereligator

3. Mew

4. Blastoise

5. Charizard

1.Pikachu

2 Greninja

3 Charizard

4 Milotic

5 Metagross

Gengar

1. Togekiss
2. Glaceon
3. Umbreon
4. Gardevoir
5. Garchomp

Why is Scizor number 1? Has this become a joke thread?

1. Pikachu
2. Jigglypuff
3. Mew
4. Mewtwo
5. Charizard

I'm a bit surprised Charizard didn't top Charizard's list though.

1. Scyther (Give him more love guys. He looks bad***.)

2. Scizor

3. Haunter

4. Kadabra

5. Mewtwo

Seriously? Where did all this love for Scizor come from? I've literally never met anyone who says Scizor is one of their favourite Pokemon. And this is coming from a guy who grew up with Pokemon since Red/Blue.

1. Charizard

2. Mewtwo

3. Lapras

Man... I didn't mean to pick all gen 1 but I guess I have a serious soft spot for them when it comes to favorites. Gen 1 and 2 are after all my most replayed Pokemon games.

Tallies updated.

Currently, Mewtwo and Charizard are locked in an epic battle for supremacy.

Gengar

FEMALE Gardevoir (Male Gardevoir DID exist)

Aggron

1. Ampharos
2. Feraligator
3. Dragonair
4. Arcanine
5. Gyarados

Just thought I would post some pictures of the early victor. I really enjoy the original Sugimori art and sprite. Although I also really enjoy Mewtwo Y.

1. Gengar (despite cancerous mega evolution)
2. Smeargle
3. Snorlax
4. Breloom
5. Skarmory

All legendaries are pancreas cancer.

This is too hard to really choose, but I'll just list the coolest ones that comes to mind at this moment:

1. Charizard
2. Charmander
3. Squirtle
4. Dragonite
5. Alakazam

@pikachu1605

I'm a bit behind on my Pokemen, but what the hey.

1. Dragonite
2. Pidgeot
3. Charizard
4. Umbreon
5. Golem

1. Blastoise
2. Charizard
3. Primape
4. Machamp
5. Gyrodos

What do you guys think of Ninetales? I think he's pretty cool.

Damn... let me think this through.

1. Suicune
2. Ho-Oh
3. Charizard
4. Lapras
5. Gogoat

I'd like to say sorry to:

• Gengar
• Wailord (I love whales)
• Rapidash
• A bunch of legendaries
• Jolteon and Luxray, I can't decide which I find cooler

@trugs26: Well, people are allowed to have an opinion.

@Ovirew: Obviously. I'm asking for their reasons. I'm genuinely wondering why so many people like such a random Pokemon.

@trugs26: Scizor has been a favorite ever since Gen 2, man. Nothing random at all, he's one of the best designed Pokemon.

Charizard sucks, but Charizard is awesome. :P

1. Charizard
2. Tyranitar
3. Garchomp
4. Zapdos
5. Snorlax

I like Pancham the best.

No way. I'm a huge Pokemon fan and this is the first I've heard of this.

@trugs26: Well, the amazing thing is, there are hundreds to choose from, so you having been a fan and still unaware of this is entirely possible :p

Holy shit...just how can anyone make a proper choice?

My knowledge is very limited, stopped watching/playing after the 151st pokemon.

I remember from the pokemon red/blue and stadium days that I was unbeatable with Zapdos, Articuno and Moltres.

*edit lol you're actually tallying? good luck with that.

• Zapdos
• Moltres
• Articuno
• Charizard
• Alakazam

1. Mewtwo
2. Alakazam
3. Haunter
4. Kabutops
5. Gyarados

1.) Charmander

2.) Mew

3.) Dragonite

4.) Lugia

5.) Kyogre

Updated the thread again.

Charizard is dominating, having overtaken Mewtwo, landed in a comfortable first place, and also having become the first Pokemon to breach the 1000 point mark.

Gengar made some serious gains.

The entire Top 5 is now comprised exclusively of Gen 1 Pokemon.

Stupid ass Blastoise getting rekt Mems, getting rekt.

Where as your shitty ass boy at? Bottom of the starting 6 team bro, get rekt.

sounds rigged

The lack of Magikarp love is disappointing. For shame SW, for shame!

Also,

1. Gengar
2. Charizard
3. Greninja
4. Pikachu
5. Magikarp

Looks like Hypnosis worked for some.

1. Charizard

2. Pikachu

3. Mew

4. Lugia

5. Oshawott

1. Magikarp
2. Slowpoke
3. Mudkip
4. Bidoof
5. Sudowoodo

W8 m8, Sudowoodo is legit.

EDIT: Sorry if I thought your list was a joke post.

Just to throws the Mew among the Pidgeottos

1. Rayquaza

2. Arcanine

3. Trevanent

4. Krookodile

5. Garchomp

Gen 1 dominates, quelle surprise :P

It sort of is and sort of isn't.

Nobody votes for the shitty Pokemon, so I thought I would.

And I spent ages training up a Magikarp, named "Magikrap" to become an incredibly powerful Gyrados.

Honestly don't know why some pokemon fans think gen 1 pokemon aren't good. Clearly they either missed out on the phenomenon, are hipsters, or blind. :P

Have you been involved in the Competitive scene? Scizor has consistently been one of the better Pokemon for online battles for a while now. Even Charizard was pretty terrible for a while until it got a Mega Evolution.

No I haven't been in that scene, which does explain a lot. Because aesthetically, he isn't that great. It makes sense if he's been popular for competitive reasons then. Thanks for that.

Yeah, I get that. I chose some obscure ones too, although those are genuinely my favorites. :P

Oh, Slowpoke and Bidoof are among my favourites. Way back when in the 1990's when the series first started, I had a lvl 99 Slowbro on my secondary team, and Bidoof was one of my mains for a while in Pearl.

Never played with Mudkip or Sudowoodo though.

1. Mewtwo

2. Shuckle

3. Blaziken

I love Shuckle because he drove my friends nuts when I was using him in battle against them lol with his insanely high defensive stats.