Is Gone Home 0.5% better than Grand Theft Auto 5?

This is a very mature game that lacks misogyny. Can we agree with gamespot in

deliberating a general consensus that Gone Home is the better game? And probably GOTY (outside of Shadow Warrior)?

Also I think it's 5% I think. I dono. Maths is stupid.

Custard.

Custard.

lundy86_4

Songbird.

Custard.

lundy86_4

pudding

check Meta-critic. ;)

check Meta-critic. ;)

xhawk27

This isn't metacritic. That has a forum. This is gamespot and what gamespot says, goes.

For the most part.

Mustard has always been the superior condiment.

Carolyn stated in the review that Gone Home's fair treatment of "whatever group you want to call it" contributed to its positive score. She will mark a game down if a game (in her eyes) doesn't do the same as well so I think its dumb for people to get upset about her reviews. Whether a game is .000001 better than another is up to you but we can definitely say that Carolyn factors in how certain groups are portrayed so just make a mental note of that and MOVE ON!

Mustard has always been the superior condiment.

ReadingRainbow4

Those are fighting words! :evil:

[QUOTE="ReadingRainbow4"]

Mustard has always been the superior condiment.

xhawk27

Those are fighting words! :evil:

[QUOTE="xhawk27"]

[QUOTE="ReadingRainbow4"]

Mustard has always been the superior condiment.

CJ_ofCamelot

Those are fighting words! :evil:

In America, Ketchup is the superior condiment! :cool:

Gone Home unfortunately got off on a technicality.

It was the last game reviewed before Gamespot decided to go with a 10-point scale. 

Had it abided by the new score system, it would have either been a 9 (not making it game of the year) or a 10 (which would have been harder to justify)

[QUOTE="CJ_ofCamelot"][QUOTE="xhawk27"]

Those are fighting words! :evil:

xhawk27

In America, Ketchup is the superior condiment! :cool:

mustard=Sony

Mayo= Microsoft

Ketchup= Nintendo

Damn it OP, your understanding of number is hurting my brain.Mcspanky37

Dude...your sig

Damn it OP, your understanding of number is hurting my brain.Mcspanky37

Yes.

Gone Home is free from the cisgendered scum agenda.

Mustard has always been the superior condiment.

ReadingRainbow4

[QUOTE="CJ_ofCamelot"][QUOTE="xhawk27"]

Those are fighting words! :evil:

xhawk27

In America, Ketchup is the superior condiment! :cool:

Custard.

lundy86_4

[QUOTE="xhawk27"]

check Meta-critic. ;)

uninspiredcup

This isn't metacritic. That has a forum. This is gamespot and what gamespot says, goes.

For the most part.

Mustard has always been the superior condiment.

ReadingRainbow4

[QUOTE="CJ_ofCamelot"][QUOTE="xhawk27"]

Those are fighting words! :evil:

xhawk27

In America, Ketchup is the superior condiment! :cool:

[QUOTE="uninspiredcup"]

[QUOTE="xhawk27"]

check Meta-critic. ;)

AmazonTreeBoa

This isn't metacritic. That has a forum. This is gamespot and what gamespot says, goes.

For the most part.

well they do for the whole SW metagame

Did people forget that gamespot changed the score system? There is no .5s anymore. Hench why GTA5 is 9.0 and not 9.5 or higher. Brean24

or it could have just been 9

[QUOTE="uninspiredcup"]

[QUOTE="xhawk27"]

check Meta-critic. ;)

AmazonTreeBoa

This isn't metacritic. That has a forum. This is gamespot and what gamespot says, goes.

For the most part.

Yes they do. You're getting angry about it because you don't like the fact Gone Home scored better than overhyped Auto.

To your mind, the score was already predefined 9.5 amazing buy the game IGN.

Carolyn stated in the review that Gone Home's fair treatment of "whatever group you want to call it" contributed to its positive score. She will mark a game down if a game (in her eyes) doesn't do the same as well so I think its dumb for people to get upset about her reviews. Whether a game is .000001 better than another is up to you but we can definitely say that Carolyn factors in how certain groups are portrayed so just make a mental note of that and MOVE ON!

Zidaneski

So even though you acknowledge that Petit applies an esoteric reviewing standard that has nothing to do with the actual gameplay, you think we should just shut up an take it?

[QUOTE="Brean24"]Did people forget that gamespot changed the score system? There is no .5s anymore. Hench why GTA5 is 9.0 and not 9.5 or higher. lostrib

or it could have just been 9

Custard.

lundy86_4

what is what

[QUOTE="lostrib"]

[QUOTE="Brean24"]Did people forget that gamespot changed the score system? There is no .5s anymore. Hench why GTA5 is 9.0 and not 9.5 or higher. Brean24

or it could have just been 9

I think somewhere it says something about not comparing review scores, of course then SW would have nothing to do

Both are great games, with that said, GTA 5 is my goty so far

0.5% more than 9 is 9.045.

Procent och procentenheter är svårt. Vet inte vad procentenhet är på engelska. Är väl knappast percent unit va? Anyway, custard > mustard.

[QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

Custard.

NameIess_One

Songbird.

[QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

Custard.

AmazonTreeBoa

Atari pr0n.

[QUOTE="NameIess_One"]

[QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

Custard.

Big_Pecks

Songbird.

Indeed.

Custard always makes me think of this guy.

And then of apple pie.

Custard > apple pie.

I don't know where I'd rank Penfold on this list. Haven't seen Danger Mouse in 60 years and have forgotten if it's actually any good or not.

Gone home was worthless.  I haven't felt so ripped off since I bought Bubsy 3D.

For years I've felt the whole "professional reviewer" business was utter nonsense, but this really sealed the deal for me.

[QUOTE="Zidaneski"]

Carolyn stated in the review that Gone Home's fair treatment of "whatever group you want to call it" contributed to its positive score. She will mark a game down if a game (in her eyes) doesn't do the same as well so I think its dumb for people to get upset about her reviews. Whether a game is .000001 better than another is up to you but we can definitely say that Carolyn factors in how certain groups are portrayed so just make a mental note of that and MOVE ON!

Pariah_001

So even though you acknowledge that Petit applies an esoteric reviewing standard that has nothing to do with the actual gameplay, you think we should just shut up an take it?

Gone home was worthless.  I haven't felt so ripped off since I bought Bubsy 3D.

For years I've felt the whole "professional reviewer" business was utter nonsense, but this really sealed the deal for me.

Suddenly_Wasted

People like different things more or less than other people. What are you? 21? You should know better. Shame on you. Also Gone Home was like $10. Be happy that's the most ripped off you've felt for the past 14 years.McStrongfast

Mmm, don't know what my age has to do with it, but I wish I were still 21.

And yep.  People like different things.  And they express their opinions.  Just like how I'm expressing my opinion.  So if there is shame on me then there is also shame on you and shame on the reviewer.

check Meta-critic. ;)

xhawk27