Catherine Scores 8.5 on Gamespot!!

Catherine is involving, intense, and unlike anything you've ever played. - Gamespot

• Compelling, personal story
• Devious, challenging puzzles
• Unusual morality system eschews notions of good and bad
• Constant sense of urgency enhances both the story and the gameplay
• Fantastic use of sound effects and music.

• Overly demanding requirements for unlocking additional modes
• Occasional camera and control troubles
• Intimidating difficulty.

Looks like my next $120 for games will be spent on Catherine and Shadows of the Damned.

I didn't expect this. I hope it sells well.

Great score,I honestly was expecting it to be much lower.Arach666

was going to get it even if it scored a 5 here

Still hoping the game will somehow get a PAL release.

I am so arou--

Interested in this game :D

I posted this in the other thread, but just in case: I recommend reading my review if you can, if only from a selfish standpoint. I really loved this game, and I loved writing about it. I read some other reviews after I finished writing mine last night, and they are all so--straightforward. I wanted not just to describe and evaluate the game, but also to capture its essence. I am not sure if my writing did the game justice, but hopefully the passion comes through. That said, Catherine is unique. It's also an interesting amalgam of story and gameplay in which one strengthens the other. Just as Vincent got more panic-stricken as the story pushed on, so did I. I also think the game deserves special kudos for how it uses sound effects and music to communicate a state of mind. Catherine isn't for everyone, but I think those that it speaks to will find it special and memorable.Kevin-V

I posted this in the other thread, but just in case: I recommend reading my review if you can, if only from a selfish standpoint. I really loved this game, and I loved writing about it. I read some other reviews after I finished writing mine last night, and they are all so--straightforward. I wanted not just to describe and evaluate the game, but also to capture its essence. I am not sure if my writing did the game justice, but hopefully the passion comes through. That said, Catherine is unique. It's also an interesting amalgam of story and gameplay in which one strengthens the other. Just as Vincent got more panic-stricken as the story pushed on, so did I. I also think the game deserves special kudos for how it uses sound effects and music to communicate a state of mind. Catherine isn't for everyone, but I think those that it speaks to will find it special and memorable.Kevin-V

Its exciting to see GS reviewers put passion in their work.

Intimidating difficulty How is that a bad thing ?TheGuardian03

Can't wait to get my hands on this one.

[QUOTE="TheGuardian03"]Intimidating difficulty How is that a bad thing ?Kevin-V

I agree, the difficulty put me off even though I'm interested in everything else.

[QUOTE="TheGuardian03"]Intimidating difficulty How is that a bad thing ?Kevin-V

[QUOTE="Kevin-V"][QUOTE="TheGuardian03"]Intimidating difficulty How is that a bad thing ?lawlessx

Edit: Now that I remember, the camera did get caught behind objects at times. It rarely ever got me in trouble though. Maybe it varies per person.

Will pick it up when it's less than $20. Heil68

[QUOTE="Kevin-V"][QUOTE="TheGuardian03"]Intimidating difficulty How is that a bad thing ?lawlessx

HA! Well, you caught me: I am a big fan of both. The good news is that Catherine's camera isn't bad--it's just sometimes limited in ways it shouldn't be. I don't like when a developer prioritizes "hey, look at me!" cinematics and long, drawn-out animations in favor of proper controls and consistent, logical camera angles. Catherine doesn't do those kinds of things often, but when it does, it's irritating. But usually, things are fine, so if the game sounds like it's for you, don't hesitate to grab it.

If choosing between platforms, I'd say go with PS3. I liked playing with the PS3's d-pad over it's loosey-goosey analog stick. On the 360, the analog stick was a better option than the stiff d-pad. But I think I felt most in control when using the PS3's d-pad. Otherwise, they both seemed the same to me.

[QUOTE="lawlessx"]

[QUOTE="Kevin-V"] For many people, punishing difficulty is a bad thing. Usually Catherine is hard but doable (on medium at least), but you can spend hours on a single stage. I wouldn't have mentioned it in the bad if the game didn't occasionally break its own rules, but when the camera decides to do its swooping business during boss fights, and at other times (stage 8 comes to mind; I can't say why without spoiling things), it goes too far. It would have helped if the game made it easier to change difficulty on the fly. But don't dwell on that issue too much. It bothered a lot of other reviewers and players more than it did me, even though I certainly cursed a lot while playing. Kevin-V

HA! Well, you caught me: I am a big fan of both. The good news is that Catherine's camera isn't bad--it's just sometimes limited in ways it shouldn't be. I don't like when a developer prioritizes "hey, look at me!" cinematics and long, drawn-out animations in favor of proper controls and consistent, logical camera angles. Catherine doesn't do those kinds of things often, but when it does, it's irritating. But usually, things are fine, so if the game sounds like it's for you, don't hesitate to grab it.

If choosing between platforms, I'd say go with PS3. I liked playing with the PS3's d-pad over it's loosey-goosey analog stick. On the 360, the analog stick was a better option than the stiff d-pad. But I think I felt most in control when using the PS3's d-pad. Otherwise, they both seemed the same to me.

I want this game but I don't want to spend $60 on it:( I guess I'll just trade in a bunch of games to gamestop tomorrow so I can get the preorder bonus.

[QUOTE="Kevin-V"]

[QUOTE="lawlessx"] So if your a big fan of Ninja gaiden or demon souls the poor camera should make you feel right at home:P

NerubianWeaver

HA! Well, you caught me: I am a big fan of both. The good news is that Catherine's camera isn't bad--it's just sometimes limited in ways it shouldn't be. I don't like when a developer prioritizes "hey, look at me!" cinematics and long, drawn-out animations in favor of proper controls and consistent, logical camera angles. Catherine doesn't do those kinds of things often, but when it does, it's irritating. But usually, things are fine, so if the game sounds like it's for you, don't hesitate to grab it.

If choosing between platforms, I'd say go with PS3. I liked playing with the PS3's d-pad over it's loosey-goosey analog stick. On the 360, the analog stick was a better option than the stiff d-pad. But I think I felt most in control when using the PS3's d-pad. Otherwise, they both seemed the same to me.

The real question is: is the game good enough to justify having to explain that "no, it isn't a Japanese porn game" every time someone sees the box sitting by your TV?

I will play on easy since puzzles aren't my strong suit:P

[QUOTE="Arach666"]Great score,I honestly was expecting it to be much lower.lawlessx

another great game the sheep miss out on

after the demo I expected a major flop...I was wrong...still not mu cup of tea though

The real question is: is the game good enough to justify having to explain that "no, it isn't a Japanese porn game" every time someone sees the box sitting by your TV?

PBSnipes

You can get the alternate box off amazon, and I assume retail sells that version too. Can always store it separatly if its genuinely an issue.

Hell yeah! I'm so stoked for my Deluxe Edition to arrive on Tuesday! Catherine is gonna be hot!!!!!

Damn, I was wanting to go hard (ahem) difficulty....but I want the story to flow too...but then I should just keep quiet and hope for a UK release... From the demo I too felt way more comfortable using the d-pad over analog stick (PS3). Oh well, I'll just have to wait.Sphire

Im happy to see this do well criticly but its just to bad its a puzzel type game. Im horrible in those games and it kinda drives me away from buying it. Ill proboly take the risk when its 20 bucks.

[QUOTE="Sphire"]Damn, I was wanting to go hard (ahem) difficulty....but I want the story to flow too...but then I should just keep quiet and hope for a UK release... From the demo I too felt way more comfortable using the d-pad over analog stick (PS3). Oh well, I'll just have to wait.spookykid143

I will if it never comes here. I prefer to keep my collection the same region where possible though. Helps me out in the long run.

Great, I might get it. The game always seemed to have an intriguing premise.