What is your favorite Star Wars film?

the third (the last)

[QUOTE="campzor"]oldie - return of the jedi newie - phantom menace overall - cannot...decide... rotj had ewoks but phantom had anakin/padme.... both horrible partsTheShadowLord07

Don't be silly. Valve will never release Episode 3.

[QUOTE="campzor"]oldie - return of the jedi newie - phantom menace overall - cannot...decide... rotj had ewoks but phantom had anakin/padme.... both horrible partsTheShadowLord07

[QUOTE="KH-mixerX"]

Yes, tolerated. The dialogue in them is a horrid as it gets. Most people don't notice it though due to the nostalgia associated with the trilogy. They would be laughed as much as the prequels if they were released during today's cinema scene. The prequels were only trying to imitate the the originals. That's why they can be so cringe-worthy at times.

Palantas

So...you mean tolerated by you? I see nitpicks here, nothing that would detract from Star Warsbeing thestillmost beloved trilogies of all time, even by modern audiences. Most people do not "tolerate" Star Wars; your statement is a canard.

That's exactly my point. The original trilogy is a landmark in cinematic history. It's cla$$ic. Which is exactly why the horrid dialogue is mostly ignored. Plus they came out during a time when that sort of thing was expected from sci-fi. You know what would happen if you brought those movies out today with current visuals? The prequels. That's what would happen. The prequel trilogy is a victim of the times, and of it's predecessors. Both are separated only by different standards. Other than that, the criticisms of the prequels can be applied equally to the originals.

[QUOTE="Palantas"]

[QUOTE="KH-mixerX"]

Yes, tolerated. The dialogue in them is a horrid as it gets. Most people don't notice it though due to the nostalgia associated with the trilogy. They would be laughed as much as the prequels if they were released during today's cinema scene. The prequels were only trying to imitate the the originals. That's why they can be so cringe-worthy at times.

KH-mixerX

So...you mean tolerated by you? I see nitpicks here, nothing that would detract from Star Warsbeing thestillmost beloved trilogies of all time, even by modern audiences. Most people do not "tolerate" Star Wars; your statement is a canard.

That's exactly my point. The original trilogy is a landmark in cinematic history. It's cla$$ic. Which is exactly why the horrid dialogue is mostly ignored. Plus they came out during a time when that sort of thing was expected from sci-fi. You know what would happen if you brought those movies out today with current visuals? The prequels. That's what would happen. The prequel trilogy is a victim of the times, and of it's predecessors. Both are separated only by different standards. Other than that, the criticisms of the prequels can be applied equally to the originals.

KH-mixerX

None of this addresses my rebuttal. The original trilogy is not "tolerated" by anyone except you and a few others. Most people today still like them. The end.

Mine is the empire strikes back. "Luke i am Your father"

i could watch it forever

Return of the Jedi- I thought it was pretty great. I Liked Episode one though too, because of Darth Maul and I like Jar Jar (Even though I know people find him a humiliation) Also it was interesting how they showed Anikans Origions

[QUOTE="KH-mixerX"]

[QUOTE="Palantas"]

So...you mean tolerated by you? I see nitpicks here, nothing that would detract from Star Warsbeing thestillmost beloved trilogies of all time, even by modern audiences. Most people do not "tolerate" Star Wars; your statement is a canard.

mitu123

That's exactly my point. The original trilogy is a landmark in cinematic history. It's cla$$ic. Which is exactly why the horrid dialogue is mostly ignored. Plus they came out during a time when that sort of thing was expected from sci-fi. You know what would happen if you brought those movies out today with current visuals? The prequels. That's what would happen. The prequel trilogy is a victim of the times, and of it's predecessors. Both are separated only by different standards. Other than that, the criticisms of the prequels can be applied equally to the originals.

They were trying to keep a persistent tone throughout the series. That's how I see it at least.

Don't be silly. Valve will never release Episode 3.

Am_Confucius

Then we must use dire measures.

[QUOTE="mitu123"]

[QUOTE="KH-mixerX"]

That's exactly my point. The original trilogy is a landmark in cinematic history. It's cla$$ic. Which is exactly why the horrid dialogue is mostly ignored. Plus they came out during a time when that sort of thing was expected from sci-fi. You know what would happen if you brought those movies out today with current visuals? The prequels. That's what would happen. The prequel trilogy is a victim of the times, and of it's predecessors. Both are separated only by different standards. Other than that, the criticisms of the prequels can be applied equally to the originals.

KH-mixerX

They were trying to keep a persistent tone throughout the series. That's how I see it at least.

empire by a mile.

I never like Star Wars. I've always thought it was pretty ***

The Empire Strikes Back

Star Wars: Ep VI, I, V, II, VI, IIISandulf29

[QUOTE="Sandulf29"]Star Wars: Ep VI, I, V, II, VI, IIITheShadowLord07