What does Zelda Wii have to do to get a 10?

I made a thread like this for SMG2 a few weeks ago and I saw many cool ideas. Now I am doing it for Zelda Wii.

I think with the addition of WiiMotion+ Zelda Wii could quite possibly be the best game of all time. I thought the Wii waggle was great, but 1:1 would just be amazing. Of course I would like to see all of these things listed, but if I had to pick one, it would be 1:1 controls.

Well, considering that Ocarina of Time got a 10 for being the first 3D Zelda, it logically follows that the next Zelda should be in 4D to get another 10. :P

There should be an 'All of the Above' option.

There should be an 'All of the Above' option.

Phoenix534

That's what the "Other" button is for. :)

Not fail like Twilight Princess is one thing.nintendoboy16

How did it fail?

Nothing

As we've seen from Wii Sports and now Wii Sports Resort the Wiimote is great but even at it's main "tech demo" gameplay it just can't deliver the flawless experience everyone expects. That's not anyone's fault, it just the limitations this gen.

I think with the Wiimote paired with Nintendo's new venture of having the games play themselves there's just too much experimentation going on to deliver a top tier game that is seen as near flawless.

I think it could be a solid experience but I don't expect much more then that

sorry for double post, please dont mod me gabu :P

now for my own fanboy annoyances (everyone has an inside fanboy :P), i'd like a harder challenge not on the puzzles (they're on the right difficulty for me :P), but on the combats. and a more in-depth combat. something that wont let me kill all those moblins with oversized pigs from TP without epona and without a shield (and without losing health or using the "rupee armor") :P

and definitely more combat uses for the items, like they're doing with darksiders: wrath of war.

EDIT: i took so long to post it it's not a double post anymore. yayz! :P

Get ported to another system ;)TheLordMagnus

all of the above

I think it needs to get ported over to either the 360 or PS3. More power = Epic battles.
I Can see it now, the next game will have link commanding armies and fighting in huge battles with over 10000 npcs on screen. During the gameplay link would go out recruiting newer soldiers and finding newer weapons and gear via dungeons or ect. This would only be a small part of the game of course.

Nothing

As we've seen from Wii Sports and now Wii Sports Resort the Wiimote is great but even at it's main "tech demo" gameplay it just can't deliver the flawless experience everyone expects. That's not anyone's fault, it just the limitations this gen.

I think with the Wiimote paired with Nintendo's new venture of having the games play themselves there's just too much experimentation going on to deliver a top tier game that is seen as near flawless.

I think it could be a solid experience but I don't expect much more then that

i would like it to have a dark story line sorta like majoras mask but its just what i think lol

[QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

Nothing

As we've seen from Wii Sports and now Wii Sports Resort the Wiimote is great but even at it's main "tech demo" gameplay it just can't deliver the flawless experience everyone expects. That's not anyone's fault, it just the limitations this gen.

I think with the Wiimote paired with Nintendo's new venture of having the games play themselves there's just too much experimentation going on to deliver a top tier game that is seen as near flawless.

I think it could be a solid experience but I don't expect much more then that

freakbabyblues

Where wasn't I clear enough?

i would like it to have a dark story line sorta like majoras mask but its just what i think lol

ragapan

[QUOTE="freakbabyblues"] [QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

Nothing

As we've seen from Wii Sports and now Wii Sports Resort the Wiimote is great but even at it's main "tech demo" gameplay it just can't deliver the flawless experience everyone expects. That's not anyone's fault, it just the limitations this gen.

I think with the Wiimote paired with Nintendo's new venture of having the games play themselves there's just too much experimentation going on to deliver a top tier game that is seen as near flawless.

I think it could be a solid experience but I don't expect much more then that

Where wasn't I clear enough?

[QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

[QUOTE="freakbabyblues"] What are you talking about?freakbabyblues

Where wasn't I clear enough?

Even with Wiimotion the controls aren't exact, people want perfect controls when they play a game

They're greatly improved with it's new add on but it's not perfect yet

[QUOTE="freakbabyblues"][QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

Where wasn't I clear enough?

Jaysonguy

Even with Wiimotion the controls aren't exact, people want perfect controls when they play a game

They're greatly improved with it's new add on but it's not perfect yet

Two facepalms in just a few minutes. You deserve a cookie.

I really don't care about 10s and what not, I just have to admit it would be pretty sweet.

• Better, more memorable characters, like Saria
• Full on orchestra with Koji Kondo composing most of the music
• New items that really change up the gameplay
• Diverse and artistic Hyrule
• Challenging and unique bosses and dungeons (like in Majora's Mask)
• A new transport like Epona. A dragon you can fly around perhaps?!:D

M+ is already confirmed. I hope Nintendo takes it's time to really make this one THE BEST Zelda. Who wouldn't want that.:P

[QUOTE="freakbabyblues"][QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

Where wasn't I clear enough?

Jaysonguy

Even with Wiimotion the controls aren't exact, people want perfect controls when they play a game

They're greatly improved with it's new add on but it's not perfect yet

Not fail like Twilight Princess is one thing.nintendoboy16

It's not Twilight Princess. It's you. Twilight Princess didn't overhype itself.

[QUOTE="nintendoboy16"]Not fail like Twilight Princess is one thing.Brawl578

It's not Twilight Princess. It's you. Twilight Princess didn't overhype itself.

Get ported to another system ;)TheLordMagnus

Well done......well done. If this happened nintendo would fail and it would be a two system race! (360-----Ps3)

But in all honesty, zelda needs everything you put up on the poll. And even than it will get an 8.8 because gamespot is biased.lol.

lol I must have played a different Majora's Mask from what you people played, Majora's Mask was standard Zelda fare through and through. I actually found bosses like Morpheel and Argorok to be more unique then any of the bosses faced in Majora's Mask, which were mostly variations of creatures and environments found in Ocarina of Time. Majora's Mask gets more bad press than it deserves but it also gets way too much praise for being different when it really wasn't, lose Ganondorf and the Master Sword from Ocarina of Time and you got Majora's Mask. Sepewrath

[QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

[QUOTE="freakbabyblues"][QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

Where wasn't I clear enough?

BrunoBRS

Even with Wiimotion the controls aren't exact, people want perfect controls when they play a game

They're greatly improved with it's new add on but it's not perfect yet

Watch Ign's video review at 1:51

Now you know 2 people :P

All the above would be preferable, but if I had to narrow it down I would say a better story. Collaborate with BioWare on the story writing or something.. Zelda is too epic of a universe for the cut n paste stuff it always gets..

[QUOTE="BrunoBRS"][QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]

Even with Wiimotion the controls aren't exact, people want perfect controls when they play a game

They're greatly improved with it's new add on but it's not perfect yet

wiifan001

Watch Ign's video review at 1:51

Now you know 2 people :P

:lol: I laugh at this topic. Since when the crap did us consumers know what what we want in a video game, alone the Zelda franchise?wiifan001

Nitnendo has already proven we have no clue what we want! *cough*Metroid Prime*cough*

They know more than we do, that's why they are Nintendo!Nintendo has someof the best or the best developers in the world!

Wii Motion Plus seems to be boosting review scores dramatically (look at Tiger Woods 2010 and Wii Sports Resort compared to their previous iterations). The next Zelda Wii could be the first adventure game to successfully utilize and revolutionize one-to-one sword-playing, which would provide a gaming experience unlike any other, and hence give it a 10.

I believe it's that unique "never-been-done-before" factor in games that drives them to get a 10 review score. I disagree with games like MGS4 and GTAIV getting 10s, but the 10s for Ocarina of Time and FFVII were well deserved because they introduced game design templates that are still copied by today's games. Once Nintendo perfects the one-to-one controls for Zelda Wii enough to make it the definitive way to play an adventure game, then every adventure game after that would need to match that greatness. It's like how every FPS is compared to Halo; every adventure game would be compared with Zelda Wii. It needs to be that good to get a 10.

One other thing...I'm not sure if Zelda Wii should have Motion +...I'm worried that it will get tireing...boring...feel like it's being forced on you... the gameplay with it wont be great [Imight be able to tellhow good it will be when i get a hold of Resort]... it won't feel like zelda... So just a lot... This is Miyamoto! He almost alwase pleases... Hopefully this one will be as liked as Ocarina of Time was back in the day.

If it came over and made me a cherry pie, Id give it a 10.

• Better, more memorable characters, like Saria
• Full on orchestra with Koji Kondo composing most of the music
• New items that really change up the gameplay
• Diverse and artistic Hyrule
• Challenging and unique bosses and dungeons (like in Majora's Mask)
• A new transport like Epona. A dragon you can fly around perhaps?!:D

M+ is already confirmed. I hope Nintendo takes it's time to really make this one THE BEST Zelda. Who wouldn't want that.:P

FFCYAN

Besides for the Epona comment, I totally agree with you. The game certainly needs to be one that is well remembered, like OOT, and not because the game is subpar, but because it is amazing! :) I think that one thing that makes OOT great is the fact that it is so memorable. Sure part of this is because it was the first 3-d Zelda, but that isn't the only reason. Actually if you look at Gamespot's original review of OOT the reviewer makes a comment similar to "This is a game people will still be talking about 10 years down the road." And here we are. :) I also really like the idea of a full orchestra. Music is one part of a game that can really add an "epic" feel to everything. Koji Kondo is a very talented artist, and I think that giving him the opportunity to use a full orchestra would greatly enhance the game. Too often in a game the music is just "there" and sometimes it is even annoying. However, when the music is well done I think it can have just as huge an impact as, say, graphics.

New items, or new ways to use items would be a refresher. I thought the staff in TP that controlled the statues was an unique idea. However, overuse of such an item can quickly become mundane. Another aspect is Hyrule itself. Sure, the Hyrule in TP was very impressive graphically and quite diverse, however, I think Nintendo can do better. The more "real" and "immersive" Hyrule is, the better. I think a truly "real", "living" and "breathing" Hyrule would be fantastic. I also really liked the bosses from TP, they were very creative and fun to fight, but I thought they were a bit on the weak side. All Nintendo would need to do is extend the bosses health, or give them a few different tactics, and that problem would be solved. And as for new transport, I don't think that is overly necessary. I am fine with Epona, and would rather they keep Epona. I don't think they have overused the horse riding theme yet and I actually think it works quite well with the game. Finally, the M+. The "waggle" was okay, but definitely needs to be improved upon. As long as the M+ isn't overused, too simple, or too complex, it should work great. I know that sounds very vague and particular, but its true. The control needs to be spot on. Something simple like the "waggle" wouldn't be enough of an improvement, but if they tried to overcomplicate or overuse the motion control, then it could certainly hinder the game. The control need to be a perfect, intuitive balance.

It will not get a 10 here. If Galaxy could not pull it off Zelda won't either. It doesn't matter anyway, as long as I like it I could care less what others say about it. What I would like to see are some truely epic bosses that are not just big, but fun to battle, like Goma (spell?) in OoT or the goat machine thing in MM.ekalbtwin

The only I thing I can think of is have a better combat system.

Through my eyes, if Twilight Princess used the Wii Motion Plus, it would be perfect.

not listen to any of the fanboys (as awesome as TP was IMO, according to some people it was too much "OoTish" and many sites didnt give it a 10. i personally liked TP alot more than OoT) and come with something epic and refreshing to the series, while keeping the quality and the aspects that makes zelda... zelda.BrunoBRS

The only I thing I can think of is have a better combat system.

Through my eyes, if Twilight Princess used the Wii Motion Plus, it would be perfect.

awssk8er716

I agree 100%

I think it needs to get ported over to either the 360 or PS3. More power = Epic battles.
I Can see it now, the next game will have link commanding armies and fighting in huge battles with over 10000 npcs on screen. During the gameplay link would go out recruiting newer soldiers and finding newer weapons and gear via dungeons or ect. This would only be a small part of the game of course.

zaku101

ya we all know more power means epic battles :roll:

if you want to make it to some sorta game zelda really isnt, that its not gone be good at all

zelda is about exploration, not about fighting alone,

thats what sets it abow all other advanture games on the other systems

zelda dosent need more power,

even zelda TP which people consider to be the worse 3d zelda yet(i disagree) but its still so much better then any advantrue game on any other system

a big hype and nice graphics is enough

just look at GTA 4 , bad controls (on foot) , boring gameplay but has a perfect 10 score , had much more fun with twilight princess , stopped playing GTA4 in the middle of the game after git more ps3 games