@Renoo27: imo it makes it feel less natural. She's a runner, not a cop. If we were playing as Kate or something, then sure. We're not though. I've always felt that the guns in Mirror's Edge made the gameplay feel unnatural due to how out of place they were when compared with the rest of the gameplay.

@G4mBi7: Your comment was a bit presumptuous. Release dates and announcements don't tell you conceptual ideas or planning. It's very likely that they were working on PT (A completely separate project to Silent Hills) a while before TLOU was released, which would also mean they were probably coming up with those ideas for Silent Hills. It's crazy that someone has to explain that out O.o