Story- Reach's is a BIT better...

Gameplay- Killzone 3. The cover mechaninc, sliding, brutal melee, mech.s etc. are just TOO good....

Graphics(You missed this out)-Killzone 3 by a LOOOOOOOOOONG shot

Weapons(You missed THIS out too)- Tie....both hv great and innovative weapons....

Music-Reach

Sound Effects(Missed out...)- Killzone 3's bullet shots, impact sounds, explosions etc. create a MUCH more real and believe-able warzone....

Multiplayer-Intense, hectic, realistic, bloody, MORE replayable, longer lasting, more challenging=KZ3

Boxart-KZ3

Manual-Reach. The manual is more detailed...

BOB Description-Tie...

Name-Tie...BOTH hv EPIC names....

Start Menu-Reach...

Credits-Tie

Achievements/Trophies-KZ3

WINEER- KILLZONE 3!!!!!

If you think in the gaming manner then-

Story- GoW without thinking....

Gameplay-NG

Character-Draw....

Replay Value-NG

Blood and Gore-Close 1 but GoW wins 'cause of GoW 3's BADA** finishers.... but the obliration tech. in NG rock 2....

Weapons-NG anyday

So in the end it comes down to personal preference....if you like a GREAT story and 9999999999 gallons of blood pick GoW, if u like BADA** obliration, extreme challenge, 9999999998 gallons of blood and 1 of the BEST fighting mechanics, pick NG.....

For me, NG wins...

But when u compare Ryu and Kratos 1v1 soul caliber type fighting-

Speed-Ryu anyday

Power-Kratos

Magic-Draw

Weapons-Ryu

Dodging-Ryu

Ryu would oblirate Kratos....

NG FTW!!!! WOOT!!!! WOOT!!!!