I've just finished the game in solo campaign and it is full of awesome. The graphics and the locations are really good, the story has a good development and the end is just appropiate for the whole trilogy. It is true there is action but actually not enough to make you feel it's not horror anymore. The fact that some (not all the game is like that) locations and maps are so repetitive that you get lost, gives you even more sense of danger because in the back of your head you keep repeating "I need to go back to the last bench, or to a safe place", especially in the side missions. In my opinion this game was as good as the first one and with the same level of horror (in solo campaign). The only con for me is the weapon crafting because makes you spend a lot of time at the bench but you can only carry 2 weapons so the game doesn't encorage you to use all the weapons you craft. I think this game deserves a higher score for sure... an 8 is not a fair score to this game.