It has come to my attention over the years that I've been posting on the GameSpot forums, making comments on articles that the quality of moderation on GameSpot is dubious at best, highly inconsistent and discriminatory at worst.
I've been modded six times since I've been here. Not really a figure to be proud of, but I still maintain to this day that not one of the cases in question was justified. After being modded four times in one month for reasons I cannot begin to explain or believe, I even submitted my request for my account to be deleted. I have reduced my participation in GameSpot even to this day, because I no longer believe that I can discuss my views about video gaming properly here without having some kind of censorship heaped upon me.
But I digress - I'm not here to talk about my cases specifically, rather the quality of moderation as a whole - meaning comments that I have been modded for, that I have reported, seen directed against other and had directed against me. What I mention above were just examples of the inconsistent way that the forums are modded.
The mods also seem to have a very peculiar problem with telling the difference between a flame war, flaming and trolling. I've been trolled on more than one occasion, I've reported it several times and received the message "Thank you for notifying the moderators. Appropriate action has been taken." I look there a day later and the message is still there, yet I've seen other messages being modded for much less, mine and others.
In one case, I was modded and received a point loss for using "offensive" words (if the mod team is reading this - PM #32045103). The mod team has some very interesting ideas about what constitutes foul language. Not only because the word I used is not swearing in the least, but also because I've seen more offensive terminology being used here on a highly regular basis - of course, with little reaction from the mods.
There was one instance I can personally name where a dispute with Renevant42 and WufusRainwright, who had both thrown insults at me accusing me of being a pirate (which I reported and against which no action was taken) resulted in me being modded when I referred to this. I basically told someone to simply ignore the trolls, and I was the one modded for it!
As an another example not related to me, I quote a comment by drew36chambers made on August 13 at 3.56 pm CET:
@Oozyrat first of all, who gives a crap if I criticize them, critics do it all the time. secondly, I don't have to be wowed by a game just because the first one was great. thirdly, this thing about a gaming company "treating fans good" is a ridiculous statement. they are not releasing this information for the fans, if they were so tight lipped about it before, why release it 2 years before launch? money, Im a fan of levine just as much as the next guy but there is alot of other factors that go into making a game and you need to consider them before simply seeing the word 'bioshock' and jumping for joy. Im not saying it will be good or bad, I'm saying you need to use your brain and not automatically go nuts because a developer you like is putting out a game. its attitudes like that which gives rise to games like tekken vs street fighter. fanboys rarely do this industry service. then again, your probably a 14 year old boy in which case rescind my argumentdrew36chambers
I'll quite happily quote more when I see them, but I think I can quite happily rest my case now.
The GameSpot team needs to start being more consistent with their modding.
Note: I put this in Feedback because I feel that it affects the site as a whole. If the mods feel that it is better placed in "Ask the mods", please feel free to move it there.
Log in to comment