It's funny, but it seems like some people pick Paragon options because they feel it is the "right" thing to do. On sister site GiantBomb, Alex Navarro played through ME 1&2 and you could hear him talking through his feelings at certain points in the game. It would seem like he wanted to be dickish to a character... but would then choose the Paragon option. I went for more what I felt I'd be more likely to do for real and for the most part, that was Renegade. I mean, I talked Wrex down, because I really liked Wrex. I killed the Rachni Queen because a) I hate roaches, b) seemed like too big a threat. I was maxed out Renegade but still was able to be merciful here and there.

Edit: And I absolutely loved Hale's Renegade FemShep!

My waifu may be Makoto, but the answer here is Kawakami. Being able to do night confidants after palace exploring is game changing.

(Tae, Dr. Takemi to me 'cause I'm nasty, is a very close second with the adhesives.)

Interesting that y'all are posting 'first Star Wars' games and none have mentioned simply, "Star Wars" the vector graphics arcade game. Sitting in that cockpit-cabinet was like the coolest thing ever! (Yes, I'm old.)

@howlingfantod: Portal 2 comes to mind, but needing to reach back that far I guess kinda proves your point. :)