I think you all need to think about this seriously bcoz basically all of you are just putting games in that are fun, just plain boring games that are overrated and unoriginal, i would put in games like:

NFS: Underground 1 (for starting the underground racing and "modding" genre of games.)

Grand theft auto (these games started the action-free roaming genre, look at all the games that have tried to copy it. brilliant and original idea for a game)

DEFINITLY the final fantasy's, theres a reason why theres about 20+ FF games have been made.

i think games like god of war are EXTREMELY overrated, and alot of the other games you guys have put down, these are just lame games that get boring really quick.

OH yeah i couldnt forget TOMBI, a personal favourite since i was like 5 lol, most of you wouldnt have played it but this games is pure genious.

start putting some REAL best games of all time!!!