John Marston may easily be one of my favorite character of all time... I know that seems a little intense but considering the amount that I truly did enjoy RDR, it's not that far out there for me.

I don't think that Phelps himself is that great of a character. Had it not been for the facial capture technology, he would be just another character to get lost in the mix. I think some of the other characters in the game are far more interetsing than Phelps himself.

Patrickbrown56

You, like the vast majority here, probably have not finished LA Noire. As much as I love John Marston, he was not too complex a man.

However, Cole Phelps, while he initially seems a stuck up simpleton, has an incredible story of his own, and is fleshed out much more over the game.

Cole may not be a bettwe man, but he was a far more interesting character.