Which is the one game that you think has the best re-play value ?

In before people say Oblivion.

Oblivion, in my opinion.

depends. for a single player-oblivion or mass effect.

but for mp-call of duty 4. it was nice to see the presitige system there. it always kept me coming back for more..

all time-Diablo 2
360-oblivion

Definitely Diablo 2 if we are going cross- platform.

Gears of War for 360- no matter how many new games I buy, I keep going back to Gears. And I buy alot of games

All time would either be Quake 3 arena or Diablo 2.

Lately it's been COD4.

Well all time I'd say FF7 or RE4.

For the 360 I'd say Dead Rising or a guitar hero game

All Time

Morrowind - not so much replay value, but there is just so much to do in a single playthrough you don't need to replay it to find new stuff. I have several characters I've played this with, and a couple for easily more than 100 hours each.

Diablo 2 - I've probably had around 20 characters on this, trying out different combinations of skills for the different characters. No idea how much time I've spent on this, but it would be huge

Fallout - replayed this fully about 7 times, and the sequel almost as much.

Xbox 360

Crackdown - love coming back to this, though have to resort to Keys to the City, since it won't let you reset your character stats, or have more than one character per profile/gamertag. Collecting orbs with a new character is great fun.

Test Drive - great fun driving game with a huge gameworld, loads of different cars, races and challenges, and plenty of people playing online to have custom races with.

All-time

goldeneye 007-

360

Halo 1, Dead Rising, crackdown

Either Call of Duty 4 or Gears of War.

Gears of War - I can play the single play over and over and over again. Not to mention that the multiplayer is good as well.

Call of Duty 4 - The offline is great, but the multiplayer is the best EVER in my opinion. Case closed.

NHL 08

Well all time I'd say FF7 or RE4.

For the 360 I'd say Dead Rising or a guitar hero game

xFuryx

ah men you beat me... then i'll have to say dead rising..

i know i know that was LAMEEE

Saints Row - i played it the longest

Oblivion - 2nd

Marvel: Ultimate Alliance - 3rd

NBA Live 08

In before people say Oblivion.

Oblivion, in my opinion.

Andrn

i have to agree. oblivion has so much that you can do it's easy to replay it over and over.

COD4 online!!!

NHL 08

xxxMoreBeerxxx

Pretty much any sports game that is decent. In my opinion Madden. Over 600 ranked games and countless games in franchise mode just in 08 alone. (And if you think thats bad people on the top of ranking board have thousands of games)

For me , it would have to be GTA 4 .. have not played mass effect .. from what i've heard it can be played over and over again ..Dragoniser

Yes Mass Effect can be played over and over again I now am playing with 2 characters at the same time.

Mass Effect and the KOTOR series. I've played KOTOR three times, KOTOR 2 three times, and Mass Effect three times. I intend to play KOTOR 2 one more time after I get to rank 25 in Bad Company.

Bioware games = pure gold.

Edit: Yes, I know that Bioware did not make KOTOR 2 and that it was made by Obsidian. But Obsidian did such an excellent job of creating a Bioware-esque story and emulating the original's formula that I consider it both an Obsidian and a Bioware game.

Call of Duty 4- the SP was great and very intense, but it was too short. But MP on the other hand, is very fun and addicting.

GTA IV for me.twopic58

ah, atleast one more person said gta 4.