@madrocketeer said:
@ghosts4ever said:
No they dont. they are just as bad. Witcher 3 was just checklist ubisosft style open world game and Cyberpunk is watch dogs in disguised.
id software are the one who have heart and passion for product and always released finish products. even 4A games Metro developers do more good than CDPR when it comes to narrative SP games.
Just one question; what did you think of Skyrim?
As for id, they've still yet to prove themselves after John Romero left and took his chaotic imagination with him. Quake II was stale run through John Carmack's papier mache corridor. Doom 3 was a mediocre System Shock 2 rip-off. Rage was a Mad Max knock-off with none of its bombastic charm. The one time they managed to get back on their feet was when Bethesda intervened to make them ditch their original "Call of Doomy" plans, forcing them to go back to one of John Romero's works, and Ctrl-C-Ctrl-V'd. Doom Eternal, all told by people with a bit of objectivity, was a bloated and haphazard attempt at improvement that resulted in a game that was arguably worse than Doom 2016 - I mean, who ever thought the Marauder was good idea?
Let's see them try a new IP that didn't come out looking like a pile of ceiling tiles, then we'll talk about them being a top tier dev.
Doom 3 was masterpiece and better than anything CDPR ever done in thier career, so was Doom 2016 and Eternal which turn out to be best FPS of decade. infact both Doom games are best FPS of decade and one of the best games of all time.
Eternal have different combat loop that is refreshing from previous Doom games and other FPS. its thinking man old school shooter.
other than that id software remain constantly in quality. Rage 1 was release at time when id was adopting pure modern style as a result only id game having regen health and ADS shooting. it was very un-id game.
Eternal being worse than 2016 is just a preference as most people prefer Eternal over 2016. proof that made poll and every time Eternal wins. I on other hand think both have advantage and disadvantage over other games as 2016 have better atmosphere, Eternal have better combat and less repetitive.
point is, even at worst, id been better than CDPR at thier best.
Witcher 1 suck, 2 was ok game with amazing lore/universe, bad gameplay, TW3 just another ubisoft open world game, Cyberpunk is watch dogs in disguise. 4 games. complete shallow and dull games company had made that people praise them as King of Gaming industry.
Log in to comment