What is the greatest Nintendo game of all time?

Yeah same... but considering the Gamecube was my first Nintendo console I owned, I obviously haven't played a lot of the classics.

Also really liked Twilight Princess.

@ charizard1605

Exactly ! :D

you're a sour person in general though

I am going to be the big elephant in the room, My favorite nintendo game is eternal darkness, it's the only game that has scared the pants off of me and i really liked the different time periods.

Tie between these two masterpieces

Mario Kart 64 imho

Ocarina of Time. Honorable mentions: Metroid Prime, Super Mario 64 and Kirby: Canvas Curse. The latter never gets mentioned, but the game is just loaded with creativity and, to date, is the game that's made the best use of the dual- and touch-screen format.

Majora's Mask. any other answer is wrong.

LTTP without a doubt. Was from a time I actually played on consoles.

no Earthbound love makes me sad. I would like to see more modern dayish rpgs released

Best? Super Metroid

My fav? Metroid Prime: Echoes

Picking my fav was easy, picking the best was tougher, those N64 Zeldas, the Mario Galaxy games, the first Metroid Prime. It was tough but I'm confident in my pick.

Pikmin 2. It perfected an already amazing experience. The simple subtraction of a 30-day limit and the addition of new Pikmin made it a sublime experience. Game absolutely blew me away as a younger kid.

they really need to remake Ocarina of Time and i dont mean the shitty little 3ds version, i want it on wii u with good graphics like wind waker. remake that and remake majora mask + metroid trilogy + new zelda and i will buy wii u.

earthbound/mother never got enough love outside of japan for many to really take notice. the only way for most of us to play mother 3 is technically illegal, isn't it?

Donkey Kong Country 2 or Yoshi's Island, hard pick

Obviously Super Metroid followed closely by A Link to the Past.

super mario bro 3

Super Mario Galaxy 2.

Nah, flip that :-3

There are tons of them that are great but for me it will be a split between Super Mario World and Super Mario 64. Both great games to this day.

My personal favorite, or the best of all time? I'd say my personal favorite is Link to the Past, most likely. However, the best of all time would either go to Super Mario Bros or Mario 64 as they paved the way for two of the most popular genres to ever grace the gaming scene. Numbers don't like, and the number of games influenced by these two is staggering.

Seriously, LTTP is way overrated. Zelda: The Minish Cap is the best Nintendo game of all time. It's underrated, too.

it on the Wii U e-shop

Majora's Mask

Followed my Mario 64

Ooh boy, what did I do to make you mad? lol.

Ocarina of Time or Super Mario Galaxy 2

Making a small joke is being mad now? Sure you're not projecting your sourness on other people?

I wasn't aware you were capable of humor. You get to learn something new everyday around here.

The 3d in link between worlds awesome and really popped out of the screen. Outside of some of the dungeons being short it is in no way simple and wall merging mechanic just added to the puzzles in many ways

Needless to say it got goty for a reason, easily the best zelda since the n64 era

The one with "quirky" characters !

Super Metroid. It's the game that cemented me a gamer for life. Aside from that I'd say SMG 2, although Pikmin 3 is really impressing me so far and I'm finding it to be one of Nintendo's best. It's incredibly addictive.

Don't ask me why I'm bothering, but...

There were third party multiplatform games in that era.

it's a tie between Metroid Prime and Pokemon Gold/Silver

Personal favorite: Majora's Mask or Yoshi's Island

Based on its impact: Ocarina of Time

Ocarina of Time is the best one for me.

This game is flawless.

I have to go for the original Pikmin personally, but there are so many good options here

-Super Metroid being a design masterpiece

-Metroid Prime being a masterpiece in immersion and video game story telling.

-Yoshi's Island being one of the best platformers of all time

-Donkey Kong Country Tropical Freeze being the best platformer of all time

-Super Mario 3D world being the best 3d platformer of all time

They are still some of the best developers in the industry

My brain hurts from reading this.

Ocarina of Time >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Half Life 2.

Half Life 2 is too girly.

Probably Super Mario Bros:The Lost Levels since it was the only challenging mario platformer. I wish they would increase the difficulty of modern Mario games.

Paper Mario. I used to know the game by heart

Pokemon Gold/Silver was my favorite

@SNIPER4321 said:

Contra 3

Easily best and only product from nintendo i enjoyed, dunno why..

The TC is talking about games made by Nintendo. Not just any SNES game. But I agree that Contra 3 was good. It was always fun trying to beat Contra games without dying on hard mode. Once you memorize the attack patterns it became easy. Same with Mike Tyson's Punch Out and Super Punch Out. Once you memorize the attack patterns you can beat them without getting hit once. I'd like to see a Contra 5 to bring back that Nostalgia..

There's too much nostalgia in this thread. It's either Super Mario Galaxy or Super Mario Galaxy 2. Super Mario 3D World was a step back, but even so, it's better than any of the shit found on the PC.

Probably SMG 2... I think.

There are sooooo many good ones that it's hard to decide.

I always enjoy these types of threads cause 95% of the time you can tell a person's age simply by the games they list. There are always exceptions but most of the time that's the case. I'll go super mario 3. Yea I'm in my early 30's