Uncharted 2 - the actual Halo killer?

[QUOTE="DeadMagazines"]You're fooling yourself if you think Uncharted will have 1 million users daily 2 years from now, much less have support from ND in 2 years..at least more than minimum support. But go ahead and think so. SuperiorSoldier

Okay. Uncharted 2 has to now sell 2.5 million units in its first month in or its a failure.

after playing the beta i can safely say uncharted series >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> halo series.TheCoreGamer_

hm... you constantly bash the 360. i doubt you even played halo long enough to have an honest opinion on it

Why would you call any game "The Halo Killer"?

Just why?

Last time I checked Bub & Bob are the real Halo killers.

[QUOTE="DeadMagazines"]You're fooling yourself if you think Uncharted will have 1 million users daily 2 years from now, much less have support from ND in 2 years..at least more than minimum support. But go ahead and think so. SuperiorSoldier

So 10,6 million people were completely wrong about the quality when they bought halo 3?

[QUOTE="DeadMagazines"]You're fooling yourself if you think Uncharted will have 1 million users daily 2 years from now, much less have support from ND in 2 years..at least more than minimum support. But go ahead and think so. SuperiorSoldier

Lets see it sell 2.5 million in 2 weeks :wink:Wii_Gamer_277

What's your opinion? The second game in the Uncharted series appears to be an epic adventure that is unexcelled this year. The critics have praised it to heaven. Not only does it have the finest graphics on consoles, it also has first-class controls and original gameplay. Consequently, it has received enormous hype. Perhaps the most hyped game since Killzone 2? Discuss. SuperiorSoldier

I couldn't stop laughing when you said UC2 has "original gameplay".

[QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"]What's your opinion? The second game in the Uncharted series appears to be an epic adventure that is unexcelled this year. The critics have praised it to heaven. Not only does it have the finest graphics on consoles, it also has first-class controls and original gameplay. Consequently, it has received enormous hype. Perhaps the most hyped game since Killzone 2? Discuss. 93soccer

[QUOTE="Wii_Gamer_277"]Lets see it sell 2.5 million in 2 weeks :wink:SuperiorSoldier

quality?

i guess you forgot that halo is a 'AAA' franchise

kinda difficult to discern quality when both are highly rated and its pretty much just opinion anyway

[QUOTE="93soccer"][QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"]What's your opinion? The second game in the Uncharted series appears to be an epic adventure that is unexcelled this year. The critics have praised it to heaven. Not only does it have the finest graphics on consoles, it also has first-class controls and original gameplay. Consequently, it has received enormous hype. Perhaps the most hyped game since Killzone 2? Discuss. SuperiorSoldier

Halo 3 is a 9.5 and AAAE as well then, so according to your way of judgement, they are of an equal quality

[QUOTE="Wii_Gamer_277"]Lets see it sell 2.5 million in 2 weeks :wink:SuperiorSoldier

[QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"][QUOTE="DeadMagazines"]You're fooling yourself if you think Uncharted will have 1 million users daily 2 years from now, much less have support from ND in 2 years..at least more than minimum support. But go ahead and think so. DoomZaW

So 10,6 million people were completely wrong about the quality when they bought halo 3?

[QUOTE="93soccer"][QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"]What's your opinion? The second game in the Uncharted series appears to be an epic adventure that is unexcelled this year. The critics have praised it to heaven. Not only does it have the finest graphics on consoles, it also has first-class controls and original gameplay. Consequently, it has received enormous hype. Perhaps the most hyped game since Killzone 2? Discuss. SuperiorSoldier

The PS3 is a very odd system for me. Out of all the games I've really enjoyed on the PS3, Killzone 2 and Uncharted didn't do much for me. they were great in terms of graphics, but both games are guilty of borrowing far too much from other games in their genres.

The thought the Uncharted 2 online demo was nothing special at all. Fun for sure, but nothing close to a 9.5 so I'm guessing the SP is where the game really shines, that or I just don't have what it takes to enjoy this type of game.

I just think games like inFamous and LBP are far better games, but they don't seem to get nearly as much attention. But the only games to get a 10 this gen i thought were overrated as well. There are plenty of 8 and 9 games I've had way more fun with than GTA4 or MGS4.

Still unsure what makes a game a "halo killer" anyhow. Sales? Reviews? Fanbase size? Online play activity?

I don't think anything will pass Halo in sales on the 360. If you count overall, then CoD4 sold more and was played more.

[QUOTE="DoomZaW"]

[QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"] You ultimately fail at posting. I'm talking about quality here, kid. Is sales the only thing Halo has? So that's why you only talk about it.GreyFoXX4

So 10,6 million people were completely wrong about the quality when they bought halo 3?

[QUOTE="93soccer"][QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"]What's your opinion? The second game in the Uncharted series appears to be an epic adventure that is unexcelled this year. The critics have praised it to heaven. Not only does it have the finest graphics on consoles, it also has first-class controls and original gameplay. Consequently, it has received enormous hype. Perhaps the most hyped game since Killzone 2? Discuss. SuperiorSoldier

Halo 3 = 9.5 AAAE

you just owned yourself ;)

I'm being 100% honest here. I own a PS3 but i LOVE Halo. Its multiplayer was just soo much fun for me, I was very close to buying a 360. But i got a PS3, and until the Uncharted beta i still thought Halo was the best multiplayer game. But in all honesty Uncharted has one of the most fun multiplayers of any game (IMO). It could still have split screen online, but you got to live with what you have :/

[QUOTE="GreyFoXX4"][QUOTE="DoomZaW"]

So 10,6 million people were completely wrong about the quality when they bought halo 3?

DeadMagazines

Because they did not have the massive marketing Halo 3 did.

[QUOTE="DoomZaW"]

[QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"] You ultimately fail at posting. I'm talking about quality here, kid. Is sales the only thing Halo has? So that's why you only talk about it.GreyFoXX4

So 10,6 million people were completely wrong about the quality when they bought halo 3?

[QUOTE="Wii_Gamer_277"][QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"] OK, you feel owned? This thread is about quality, and obviously, since you know Uncharted beats Halo in that department, you're beginning to talk about sales. Silly, helpless people. :lol:SuperiorSoldier

We all know Uncharted 2 scored AAAE just because of the ridiculous hype it got. GameSpot didn't want Sony so be mad, so they overscored it. Otherwise, they would have given it a 7, 8.0 at most. But with the hype, no wonder...

[QUOTE="DoomZaW"]

[QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"] You ultimately fail at posting. I'm talking about quality here, kid. Is sales the only thing Halo has? So that's why you only talk about it.GreyFoXX4

So 10,6 million people were completely wrong about the quality when they bought halo 3?

for all you know, they could be playing the campaign

The only way this game would even be considered a Halo Killer is if it sell 2.5 milliion copies in 2 weeks, which is so highly unlikely its laughable :lol:

So 10,6 million people were completely wrong about the quality when they bought halo 3?

[QUOTE="DoomZaW"]

[QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"] You ultimately fail at posting. I'm talking about quality here, kid. Is sales the only thing Halo has? So that's why you only talk about it.GreyFoXX4

So 10,6 million people were completely wrong about the quality when they bought halo 3?

Roughly a million people are playing halo 3 every day, no game on the ps3 whether exclusive or not is experiencing that amount of prestige. KZ2 was even claimed to be the definite halo 3 killer, and despite that, it sold on an average scale, and the community is absolutely nothing compared to halo 3

No, nothing is just going to come and kill Halo. Other games have been rated higher than Halo games, and yet Halo is still being played.

Not sure why people think a game is going to kill Halo.....

[QUOTE="93soccer"][QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"]What's your opinion? The second game in the Uncharted series appears to be an epic adventure that is unexcelled this year. The critics have praised it to heaven. Not only does it have the finest graphics on consoles, it also has first-class controls and original gameplay. Consequently, it has received enormous hype. Perhaps the most hyped game since Killzone 2? Discuss. SuperiorSoldier

http://www.gamespot.com/xbox360/action/halo3/index.html?tag=result;title;1

B-b-b-backfire!

Nothingwill "kill" Halo. The only reason Halo might be killed will beif its quality goesdown and then it will kill itself.

[QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"][QUOTE="Wii_Gamer_277"] Last time I checked both scored AAA :roll: so your claim of quality is mute.ThatGuyFromB4

We all know Uncharted 2 scored AAAE just because of the ridiculous hype it got. GameSpot didn't want Sony so be mad, so they overscored it. Otherwise, they would have given it a 7, 8.0 at most. But with the hype, no wonder...

[QUOTE="Wii_Gamer_277"][QUOTE="GreyFoXX4"] Why isn't there atleast 4-5 million playing it a day then?SuperiorSoldier

http://majornelson.com/archive/2009/10/06/live-activity-for-week-of-sept-28th.aspx

Can you jump off a cliff now?

[QUOTE="GreyFoXX4"][QUOTE="DoomZaW"]

So 10,6 million people were completely wrong about the quality when they bought halo 3?

DoomZaW

Roughly a million people are playing halo 3 every day, no game on the ps3 whether exclusive or not is experiencing that amount of prestige. KZ2 was even claimed to be the definite halo 3 killer, and despite that, it sold on an average scale, and the community is absolutely nothing compared to halo 3

[QUOTE="DeadMagazines"][QUOTE="GreyFoXX4"] Why isn't there atleast 4-5 million playing it a day then?TintedEyes

Because they did not have the massive marketing Halo 3 did.