The Greatest Comback In VideoGame History. Overall Quality Library PS3 vs 360.

Good Day System Wars!

• I have compiled every AA+ game on Metacritic for the 360 and the PS3 that is NOT on the other system, doesn't matter if it's multiplat or exclusive, this is the fairest way to compare the 360 to the PS3 in terms of Quality Games.
• This took me well over an hour to do, so please do not brush off my work if you find a small mistake, these threads are editable :P I've been as neutral fair and unbiased as possible but the results speak for themselves.
• The PS3 has more exclusives, more variety, more award winning games and what I consider to be very crucial a much more up to date library.
• This thread isn't meant to sway your already defined preference, it was only made with the System Wars Metagame in mind. So be reasonable!
• Keep it clean.

Xbox 360

Total: 30

2005 Titles: 5

2006 Titles: 7

2007 Titles: 6

2008 Titles: 6

2009 Titles: 5

2010 Titles: 2

Exclusives: 21

Average Score: 82.6

1. Gears of War 94 – 2006
2. Halo 3 94 – 2007
3. Gears of War 2 93 – 2008
4. Forza Motorsport 3 92 – 2009
5. Mass Effect 91 – 2007
6. Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter 90 – 2006
7. Forza Motorsport 2 90 – 2007
8. Fable II 89 – 2008
9. Left 4 Dead 89 – 2008
10. Left 4 Dead 2 89 – 2009
11. Project Gotham Racing 3 88 – 2005
12. Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Conviction 85 – 2010
13. Project Gotham Racing 4 85 – 2007
14. Dead or Alive 85 – 2005
15. Dead Rising 85 – 2006
16. Viva Pinata 84 – 2006
17. Halo 3 ODST 83 – 2009
18. Crackdown 83 – 2007
19. Alan Wake 83 – 2010
20. Halo Wars 82 – 2009
21. Viva Pinata TIP 82 - 2008
22. Stoked Big Air Edition 81 - 2009
23. Rockstar Table Tennis 81 - 2006
24. Condemned 81 – 2005
25. Saints Row 81 – 2006
26. Perfect Dark Zero 81 – 2005
27. Ace Combat 6 80 – 2007
28. Moto GP'06 80 – 2006
29. Naruto 80 – 2008
30. NBA 2k6 80 - 2005

Sony Playstation 3

Total: 26

2005 Titles: 0

2006 Titles: 1

2007 Titles: 5

2008 Titles: 8

2009 Titles: 7

2010 Titles: 5

Exclusives: 24

Average Score: 87.6

1. Uncharted 2: Among Thieves 96 – 2009
2. LittleBigPlanet 95 – 2008
3. Metal Gear Solid: Guns of the Patriots 94 – 2008
4. God of War III 92 – 2010
5. MLB 10: The Show 91 – 2010
6. God of War Collection 91 – 2009
7. Killzone 2 91 – 2009
8. Demon's Souls 89 – 2009
9. Racthet & Clank Future: Tools of Destruction 89 – 2007
10. Uncharted: Drake's Fortune 88 – 2007
11. Ninja Gaiden Sigma 88 – 2007
12. Heavy Rain 87 – 2010
13. MLB 09: The Show 90 - 2009
14. Wipeout HD 87 – 2008
15. Resistance 2 87 – 2008
16. Ratchet & Clank Future: A Crack in Time 87 – 2009
17. Valkyria Chronicles 86 – 2008
18. Resistance: Fall of Man 86 – 2006
19. MLB 08: The Show 85 – 2008
20. Infamous 85 – 2009
21. Motorstorm 84 – 2007
22. Warhawk 84 – 2007
23. Modnation Racers 82 – 2010
24. Motorstorm: Pacific Rift 82 – 2008
25. Hot Shots Golf: Out of Bounds 81 – 2008
26. Yakuza 3 80 – 2010

Overall library? 360 wins.SaltyMeatballs

Yeah everyone to their own, thats why i dont see threads like this outside SW.

This isn't metacritic, 360 has more high scoring exclusives here on gamespotJcgamez

Overall library? 360 wins.SaltyMeatballs

Sony has always been the comeback kid. PS1, PS2, and PS3. They have always managed to get out of the first troubled years of their consoles and turn them into things every gamer needs.

Comparing metacritic scores...

[QUOTE="SaltyMeatballs"]Overall library? 360 wins.Gamtrix

Ya, it was probably the biggest comeback in gaming.

:|

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"][QUOTE="SaltyMeatballs"]Overall library? 360 wins.ohthemanatee

I would like to know that too because going by gamespot 360 has 2 AAAs, 24 AAs and 40 As more than PS3. Sw is the only place i know where 1 is bigger than 2

[QUOTE="SaltyMeatballs"]Overall library? 360 wins.Gamtrix

This isn't metacritic, 360 has more high scoring exclusives here on gamespotJcgamez

oh hooray another pro-PS3 thread using metacritic :| you forgot Mass Effect 2, or are we counting games which haven't been released yet? in which case you forgot a whole bunch of games.

:|[QUOTE="ohthemanatee"][QUOTE="Gamtrix"] Everyone has their own personal preference, but according to the industry, in a robotic style unbiased analysis, the PS3 is leading in Quality games. PAL360

I would like to know that too because going by gamespot 360 has AAAs, 24 AAs and 40 As more than PS3. Sw is the only place i know where 1 is bigger than 2

I say 360 wins. But it's only a matter of preference.

I wouldn't count NGS or GOW collection for the PS3's List...

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"][QUOTE="SaltyMeatballs"]Overall library? 360 wins.ohthemanatee

I wouldn't count NGS or GOW collection for the PS3's List...

zarshack

I say 360 wins. But it's only a matter of preference.

Alex3796

Sure ppl are free to prever on library over the other but it doesnt change the fact that 360´s lineup is superior in every way. It doesnt have 3 or 4 games more, it has 66 more A+ games than PS3 and im not even talking about the fact it´s the safest console to use for multiplats.

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

:|[QUOTE="ohthemanatee"] link?ohthemanatee

I would like to know that too because going by gamespot 360 has AAAs, 24 AAs and 40 As more than PS3. Sw is the only place i know where 1 is bigger than 2

System Wars rule #7: If you can find one thing that you think is better on your system of choice, make threads about it everyday.

Biggest offenders: Graphics king threads and the importance of not so important exclusives.

[QUOTE="Alex3796"]

I say 360 wins. But it's only a matter of preference.

PAL360

Sure ppl are free to prever on library over the other but it doesnt change the fact that 360´s lineup is superior in every way. It doesnt have 3 or 4 games more, it has 66 more A+ games than PS3 and im not even talking about the fact it´s the safest console to use for multiplats.

System Wars rule #7: If you can find one thing that you think is better on your system of choice, make threads about it everyday.

Biggest offenders: Graphics king threads and the importance of not so important exclusives.

heretrix

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

[QUOTE="Alex3796"]

I say 360 wins. But it's only a matter of preference.

Gamtrix

Sure ppl are free to prever on library over the other but it doesnt change the fact that 360´s lineup is superior in every way. It doesnt have 3 or 4 games more, it has 66 more A+ games than PS3 and im not even talking about the fact it´s the safest console to use for multiplats.

I allways thought that A (good) games were quality too. Anyway, 360 has 26 AAs more than PS3. My point still stands.

[QUOTE="ohthemanatee"]

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

:|

I would like to know that too because going by gamespot 360 has AAAs, 24 AAs and 40 As more than PS3. Sw is the only place i know where 1 is bigger than 2

Gamtrix

if you only play exclusives then you're the one missing out

Good Day System Wars!

• I have compiled every AA+ game on Metacritic for the 360 and the PS3 that is NOT on the other system, doesn't matter if it's multiplat or exclusive, this is the fairest way to compare the 360 to the PS3 in terms of Quality Games.
• This took me well over an hour to do, so please do not brush off my work if you find a small mistake, these threads are editable :P I've been as neutral fair and unbiased as possible but the results speak for themselves.
• The PS3 has more exclusives, more variety, more award winning games and what I consider to be very crucial a much more up to date library.
• This thread isn't meant to sway your already defined preference, it was only made with the System Wars Metagame in mind. So be reasonable!
• Keep it clean.

Xbox 360

Total: 26

2005 Titles: 4

2006 Titles: 6

2007 Titles: 6

2008 Titles: 4

2009 Titles: 4

2010 Titles: 2

Exclusives: 19

1. Gears of War 94 – 2006
2. Halo 3 94 – 2007
3. Gears of War 2 93 – 2008
4. Forza Motorsport 3 92 – 2009
5. Mass Effect 91 – 2007
6. Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter 90 – 2006
7. Forza Motorsport 2 90 – 2007
8. Fable II 89 – 2008
9. Left 4 Dead 89 – 2008
10. Left 4 Dead 2 89 – 2009
11. Project Gotham Racing 3 88 – 2005
12. Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Conviction 85 – 2010
13. Project Gotham Racing 4 85 – 2007
14. Dead or Alive 85 – 2005
15. Dead Rising 85 – 2006
16. Viva Pinata 84 – 2006
17. Halo 3 ODST 83 – 2009
18. Crackdown 83 – 2007
19. Alan Wake 83 – 2010
20. Halo Wars 82 – 2009
21. Condemned 81 – 2005
22. Saints Row 81 – 2006
23. Perfect Dark Zero 81 – 2005
24. Ace Combat 6 80 – 2007
25. Moto GP'06 80 – 2006
26. Naruto 80 – 2008

Sony Playstation 3

Total: 26

2005 Titles: 0

2006 Titles: 1

2007 Titles: 5

2008 Titles: 8

2009 Titles: 7

2010 Titles: 5

Exclusives: 24

1. Uncharted 2: Among Thieves 96 – 2009
2. LittleBigPlanet 95 – 2008
3. Metal Gear Solid: Guns of the Patriots 94 – 2008
4. God of War III 92 – 2010
5. MLB 10: The Show 91 – 2010
6. God of War Collection 91 – 2009
7. Killzone 2 91 – 2009
8. Demon's Souls 89 – 2009
9. Racthet & Clank Future: Tools of Destruction 89 – 2007
10. Uncharted: Drake's Fortune 88 – 2007
11. Ninja Gaiden Sigma 88 – 2007
12. Heavy Rain 87 – 2010
13. MLB 09: The Show 90 - 2009
14. Wipeout HD 87 – 2008
15. Resistance 2 87 – 2008
16. Ratchet & Clank Future: A Crack in Time 87 – 2009
17. Valkyria Chronicles 86 – 2008
18. Resistance: Fall of Man 86 – 2006
19. MLB 08: The Show 85 – 2008
20. Infamous 85 – 2009
21. Motorstorm 84 – 2007
22. Warhawk 84 – 2007
23. Modnation Racers 82 – 2010
24. Motorstorm: Pacific Rift 82 – 2008
25. Hot Shots Golf: Out of Bounds 81 – 2008
26. Yakuza 3 80 – 2010

Gamtrix

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"]

Good Day System Wars!

• I have compiled every AA+ game on Metacritic for the 360 and the PS3 that is NOT on the other system, doesn't matter if it's multiplat or exclusive, this is the fairest way to compare the 360 to the PS3 in terms of Quality Games.
• This took me well over an hour to do, so please do not brush off my work if you find a small mistake, these threads are editable :P I've been as neutral fair and unbiased as possible but the results speak for themselves.
• The PS3 has more exclusives, more variety, more award winning games and what I consider to be very crucial a much more up to date library.
• This thread isn't meant to sway your already defined preference, it was only made with the System Wars Metagame in mind. So be reasonable!
• Keep it clean.

Xbox 360

Total: 26

2005 Titles: 4

2006 Titles: 6

2007 Titles: 6

2008 Titles: 4

2009 Titles: 4

2010 Titles: 2

Exclusives: 19

1. Gears of War 94 – 2006
2. Halo 3 94 – 2007
3. Gears of War 2 93 – 2008
4. Forza Motorsport 3 92 – 2009
5. Mass Effect 91 – 2007
6. Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter 90 – 2006
7. Forza Motorsport 2 90 – 2007
8. Fable II 89 – 2008
9. Left 4 Dead 89 – 2008
10. Left 4 Dead 2 89 – 2009
11. Project Gotham Racing 3 88 – 2005
12. Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Conviction 85 – 2010
13. Project Gotham Racing 4 85 – 2007
14. Dead or Alive 85 – 2005
15. Dead Rising 85 – 2006
16. Viva Pinata 84 – 2006
17. Halo 3 ODST 83 – 2009
18. Crackdown 83 – 2007
19. Alan Wake 83 – 2010
20. Halo Wars 82 – 2009
21. Condemned 81 – 2005
22. Saints Row 81 – 2006
23. Perfect Dark Zero 81 – 2005
24. Ace Combat 6 80 – 2007
25. Moto GP'06 80 – 2006
26. Naruto 80 – 2008

Sony Playstation 3

Total: 26

2005 Titles: 0

2006 Titles: 1

2007 Titles: 5

2008 Titles: 8

2009 Titles: 7

2010 Titles: 5

Exclusives: 24

1. Uncharted 2: Among Thieves 96 – 2009
2. LittleBigPlanet 95 – 2008
3. Metal Gear Solid: Guns of the Patriots 94 – 2008
4. God of War III 92 – 2010
5. MLB 10: The Show 91 – 2010
6. God of War Collection 91 – 2009
7. Killzone 2 91 – 2009
8. Demon's Souls 89 – 2009
9. Racthet & Clank Future: Tools of Destruction 89 – 2007
10. Uncharted: Drake's Fortune 88 – 2007
11. Ninja Gaiden Sigma 88 – 2007
12. Heavy Rain 87 – 2010
13. MLB 09: The Show 90 - 2009
14. Wipeout HD 87 – 2008
15. Resistance 2 87 – 2008
16. Ratchet & Clank Future: A Crack in Time 87 – 2009
17. Valkyria Chronicles 86 – 2008
18. Resistance: Fall of Man 86 – 2006
19. MLB 08: The Show 85 – 2008
20. Infamous 85 – 2009
21. Motorstorm 84 – 2007
22. Warhawk 84 – 2007
23. Modnation Racers 82 – 2010
24. Motorstorm: Pacific Rift 82 – 2008
25. Hot Shots Golf: Out of Bounds 81 – 2008
26. Yakuza 3 80 – 2010

chaplainDMK

so his sig is a lie?

[QUOTE="chaplainDMK"]

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"]

Good Day System Wars!

• I have compiled every AA+ game on Metacritic for the 360 and the PS3 that is NOT on the other system, doesn't matter if it's multiplat or exclusive, this is the fairest way to compare the 360 to the PS3 in terms of Quality Games.
• This took me well over an hour to do, so please do not brush off my work if you find a small mistake, these threads are editable :P I've been as neutral fair and unbiased as possible but the results speak for themselves.
• The PS3 has more exclusives, more variety, more award winning games and what I consider to be very crucial a much more up to date library.
• This thread isn't meant to sway your already defined preference, it was only made with the System Wars Metagame in mind. So be reasonable!
• Keep it clean.

Xbox 360

Total: 26

2005 Titles: 4

2006 Titles: 6

2007 Titles: 6

2008 Titles: 4

2009 Titles: 4

2010 Titles: 2

Exclusives: 19

1. Gears of War 94 – 2006
2. Halo 3 94 – 2007
3. Gears of War 2 93 – 2008
4. Forza Motorsport 3 92 – 2009
5. Mass Effect 91 – 2007
6. Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter 90 – 2006
7. Forza Motorsport 2 90 – 2007
8. Fable II 89 – 2008
9. Left 4 Dead 89 – 2008
10. Left 4 Dead 2 89 – 2009
11. Project Gotham Racing 3 88 – 2005
12. Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Conviction 85 – 2010
13. Project Gotham Racing 4 85 – 2007
14. Dead or Alive 85 – 2005
15. Dead Rising 85 – 2006
16. Viva Pinata 84 – 2006
17. Halo 3 ODST 83 – 2009
18. Crackdown 83 – 2007
19. Alan Wake 83 – 2010
20. Halo Wars 82 – 2009
21. Condemned 81 – 2005
22. Saints Row 81 – 2006
23. Perfect Dark Zero 81 – 2005
24. Ace Combat 6 80 – 2007
25. Moto GP'06 80 – 2006
26. Naruto 80 – 2008

Sony Playstation 3

Total: 26

2005 Titles: 0

2006 Titles: 1

2007 Titles: 5

2008 Titles: 8

2009 Titles: 7

2010 Titles: 5

Exclusives: 24

1. Uncharted 2: Among Thieves 96 – 2009
2. LittleBigPlanet 95 – 2008
3. Metal Gear Solid: Guns of the Patriots 94 – 2008
4. God of War III 92 – 2010
5. MLB 10: The Show 91 – 2010
6. God of War Collection 91 – 2009
7. Killzone 2 91 – 2009
8. Demon's Souls 89 – 2009
9. Racthet & Clank Future: Tools of Destruction 89 – 2007
10. Uncharted: Drake's Fortune 88 – 2007
11. Ninja Gaiden Sigma 88 – 2007
12. Heavy Rain 87 – 2010
13. MLB 09: The Show 90 - 2009
14. Wipeout HD 87 – 2008
15. Resistance 2 87 – 2008
16. Ratchet & Clank Future: A Crack in Time 87 – 2009
17. Valkyria Chronicles 86 – 2008
18. Resistance: Fall of Man 86 – 2006
19. MLB 08: The Show 85 – 2008
20. Infamous 85 – 2009
21. Motorstorm 84 – 2007
22. Warhawk 84 – 2007
23. Modnation Racers 82 – 2010
24. Motorstorm: Pacific Rift 82 – 2008
25. Hot Shots Golf: Out of Bounds 81 – 2008
26. Yakuza 3 80 – 2010

ohthemanatee

so his sig is a lie?

And all his threads and posts are anti Xbox, hail Playstation.

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"][QUOTE="ohthemanatee"]and according to metacritic the 360 has more AA+ games as well

ohthemanatee

if you only play exclusives then you're the one missing out

And no my sig isn't a lie, I don't own a 360 but I have a 360 in my house, I proved it to Clone, ask him if you don't believe me, I'm not getting into that again. Get on topic please.

[QUOTE="ohthemanatee"]

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"] You must not have read the OP, these are all the retail games on the 360 and on the PS3 NOT on the other console. If it has more games you must be counting DLC packs, Arcade titles etc. Gamtrix

if you only play exclusives then you're the one missing out

then you must have missed some, because the 360 list is bigger

And no my sig isn't a lie, I don't own a 360 but I have a 360 in my house, I proved it to Clone, ask him if you don't believe me, I'm not getting into that again. Get on topic please.

Gamtrix

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"][QUOTE="PAL360"]

Sure ppl are free to prever on library over the other but it doesnt change the fact that 360´s lineup is superior in every way. It doesnt have 3 or 4 games more, it has 66 more A+ games than PS3 and im not even talking about the fact it´s the safest console to use for multiplats.

PAL360

I allways thought that A (good) games were quality too. Anyway, 360 has 26 AAs more than PS3. My point still stands.

And no my sig isn't a lie, I don't own a 360 but I have a 360 in my house, I proved it to Clone, ask him if you don't believe me, I'm not getting into that again. Get on topic please.

Gamtrix

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"]

[QUOTE="ohthemanatee"]

if you only play exclusives then you're the one missing out

ohthemanatee

then you must have missed some, because the 360 list is bigger

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"]

And no my sig isn't a lie, I don't own a 360 but I have a 360 in my house, I proved it to Clone, ask him if you don't believe me, I'm not getting into that again. Get on topic please.

chaplainDMK

Great thread. It shows just how big a comeback ps3 has come since its start. I dont think any console out there has pulled such a comeback yet.

Are people seriously saying Metacrtitic is a poor tool if your gonna use review scores?

Lets see;

Gamespot only: 1 dudes opinion

Metacritic: The average of all of them... so one idiot cant bring em all down, and one idiot cant say its a masterpiece when everyone loves it.

Its the most accurate judge of games IF you are gonna rely on review scores. FACT.

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"] Excuse me PAL360 but this thread is about Quality lineup. AA+, don't start changnign the guidelines and including A games just to suit your needs. And AA+ the PS3 has clearly the more impressive lineup, more exclusives, more variety, more award winning games, more up to date library. Gamtrix

I allways thought that A (good) games were quality too. Anyway, 360 has 26 AAs more than PS3. My point still stands.

360

PS3

2 AAAs + 24 AAs = 26 AA+, right?

Can't we just agree that both are great systems and stop making five "360 vs. PS3" threads a day?

Can't we just agree that both are great systems and stop making five "360 vs. PS3" threads a day?

brickdoctor

[QUOTE="Gamtrix"][QUOTE="PAL360"]

I allways thought that A (good) games were quality too. Anyway, 360 has 26 AAs more than PS3. My point still stands.

PAL360

360

PS3

2 AAAs + 24 AAs = 26 AA+, right?

Can't we just agree that both are great systems and stop making five "360 vs. PS3" threads a day?

brickdoctor

If you have a gaming PC, PS3 wins. If you don't have a gaming PC, 360 wins

[QUOTE="brickdoctor"]

Can't we just agree that both are great systems and stop making five "360 vs. PS3" threads a day?

Gamtrix

If you have a gaming PC, PS3 wins. If you don't have a gaming PC, 360 wins

iBear-