Original Halo trilogy (MS) vs Uncharted trilogy (sony). which is better?

Mafia trilogy would've made more sense, but then both franchise descriptions would be the same.

Well besides the obvious bias, is this even a question? Halo is way more popular and is a cult classic at this point.

Gaming great vs gaming mediocre?

Of course Halo wins. Only a fanboy would vote differently.

Uncharted is great, but easily Halo. Halo CE is one of my favourite games of all time, and Halo 3 was also a masterpiece.

Halo is a game.

Designed for children who've never played Quake, but still fits under the criteria.

I've played Quack and never liked it, pretty much the same for Halo, what now?

Still a game. on other hand uncharted is not.

Quake is masterpiece. talking about original one. its a game that invent free mouse look.

3 good games vs 1.

Halo wins this and this isn’t close.

The legendary Halos by light-years of course.

UnFarted doesn't even belong in the same sentence with Halo. Sheeeesh, WTH is the matter with you? lol :P

Uncharted hands down.

not even a contest hah

tho i enjoyed playing this polls loser the nathan drake collection a few month ago...

Halo's, story has more lore in Master Chief's little pinky than UnFarted and the rest of Phony's movie games could ever hope to have.

True story, just sayin. lol :P

Both are terribly boring by modern standards.

Let sleeping dogs lie, let people have their memories unadulterated by remasters.

@girlusocrazy:

Your very minority Opinion has been noted. Thank's for playin. :P

Eew mouse, get good and learn to play with a controller. Quake was average back in the day, and still is today.

Uncharted has far better characters and dialogue.

Halo has far better gameplay

But you like exhumed a poor mans Quake.

Pretty sure you guys know where I stand on this one.

Uncharted 2>any Halo

@ghosts4ever: You need to up your game little moo moo.

Only good Halo game was the first.

While I do enjoy the Uncharted games Halo definitely gets my vote.

They are both WILDLY overrated... Halo is slightly better, because you get to play the game more than watch it.

@girlusocrazy:

Agreed but there's always an exception to the rule. :P

no how about the fact is bungie is not doing it any more. compare to 343 vs naughty dog because thats the future of the franchise. does it matter if it was better to gen ago. stop moving backwards and more forward.

funny xbox fans live in the past when there games was good.

so tell me this

naughty dog vs 343 studios because that is the future of these games.

naughty dog is 100 time better as a developer over 343.

should be halo 343 vs uncharted naughty dog.

xbox fans stop hiding behind the 360 its over. 343 is your future not bungie.

funny how no xbox one games or series x game ever get compared to sony first party games.

Halo but, Uncharted 2 is the best out of all six games.

(Fwiw, there is no Uncharted "trilogy".)

@gifford38:

343i, hasn't done too bad considering they took over the King of gaming...

Halo 4 = 9/10

Halo 5 = 8/10

Halo: Infinite, will = 11/10. Bank!! lol :P

Halo 1-3 were legendary but 4 and 5 just didn't live up to the originals where uncharted 1-4 have got better but I can't say better than Halo 1-3.

Uncharted. OG Halo is the best fps to me, but I couldn't care less for two and three

ok now go check out the fans of halo and what they say about it?

because if you guys go off of user scores for the last of us 2 then this is the same thing.

No doubt Bungie Halos, were indeed better but as I said, 343 put out a good product just not as good as the old Bungie, the Creator of the series. Give'em a break, at least until Halo: Infinite, launches and scored by both pro's and players.

I do think from the looks of it they did do a good job with halo. im not a fps fan unless in vr so i never got into halo. but I doo see they done a good job. I'm just saying don't act like halo the only achievement here.

naughty dog has created some great achievements to.

xbox fans got to realize naughty dog makes great game as well. uncharted might be considered a movie game but to blend in story with gameplay naughty dog is king.

just because uncharted is not on xbox doesn't mean you guys can realize something good here.

uncharted is tps action gameplay at its finest while halo is fps at its finest. uncharted is not just cover and shoot. there are many ways to take out the enemy.

plus naughty dog animations and character models are one of the best in the industry and hats there achievement.

and halo is fps action and one of the best online games back in the day is there achievement.

Unfortunately Halo because Uncharted 3 shat the bed.

Uncharted series is awesome, but I love me some old school Halo franchise. It sad that 343 f-it up so badly that lemmings now think that shi&T is gold.

@gifford38:

Geezzz, I made it so easy for you to say, yeah we'll just wait and see with Halo: Infinite but Nooooooo lol. Oh well, hey, I think cows just need to realize ND and Uncharted series sucks canal water and doesn't come close to 343's Halos. :o

There ya go, opinions, we all got'em. :P

@girlusocrazy: Wait, we’re comparing Halo to Uncharted and you’re telling us Halo is the game that rests on set-pieces and action sequences?

Is this what irony is?

I bet you never even played uncharted or last of us.

I bet you never played a Halo.

Your turn. lol :P

Uncharted is a bad joke ND has been pulling on gamers.

Uncharted has good banter between characters while Halo has a better gameplay. I enjoyed both games for what they are. The first 3 uncharted games were great but nothing will ever top my first time playing halo or staying up so night playing halo 3 campaign with 3 friends. Halo really defined the genre on consoles.

Really weird trolling. Guess the mods didn't bother opening the thread lol.

I liked Uncharted 2 but the fun I had with the Halo series just doesn't compare.

Definitely Halo. I really liked Uncharted for the time, but less and less as time went on. I really don't like stories in games. I want my games to have zero story. I only care about gameplay, and I want all cutscenes skippable. Some things that really bothered me about Uncharted were things like the forced stealth segments, the cutscenes, the platforming which is automatic, the Teen rating which made it less violent, the puzzles which were too easy, stuff like that. I played all the originals on PS3, and I had an unopened copy of Nathan Drake Collection sitting on my shelf for years, but I recently sold it because I knew I'd never play it. I also have the Halo Master Chief Collection and I will never sell that, those are timeless classics. The gameplay still holds up today, no BS cutscenes, no forced story for me to be bothered with, I can just turn it on and play.

Halo 3 on Heroic was incredible, and co-op was amazing.