If MAG scored AAA here on GS....

Guess what? SW is doomed!!:lol:

Seriously, just look at the thread about MAG, almost 90% of SW user said this game gonna flop because of the demo

Yeah, I know the demo was *meh but I still think Zipper still can improve the game, hope it'll get much better when it's released

So, here I am hyping MAG scored AAA here on GS because its gonna be fun if it's true:lol:

And hey, dont forget it's 256 players + PS3 exclusive + awesome boxart (just kidding)!!

Guess what? SW is doomed!!:lol:

Seriously, just look at the thread about MAG, almost 90% of SW user said this game gonna flop because of the demo

Yeah, I know the demo was *meh but I still think Zipper still can improve the game, hope it'll get much better when it's released

So, here I am hyping MAG scored AAA here on GS because its gonna be fun if it's true:lol:

And hey, dont forget it's 256 players + PS3 exclusive + awesome boxart (just kidding)!!

ihsanqueen

Hmm, sound like AAA to me

I doubt it will. But the official hype is at A now :P

Well, I think I'd just continue on with my daily life.siLVURcross

This.

we all will have lots of opinions after the demo begins

No

Demo?

dude that was the Beta.

Hmm, sound like AAA to meBPoole96

[QUOTE="Skittles_McGee"]If it scored that high, I'd be expecting Star Ocean 4 to score a 10.AgentA-Mi6

MP only = fail

if it scores that high BFBC2 will get a 10

Don't worry. It's a 6.5 game... tops.

Seriously it is horrible. Horrible graphics, horrible sound, stiff controls, boring shooting mechanics. 256 players is a gimmick. BFBC 2 is miles ahead of it.

Demo?

dude that was the Beta.

LegatoSkyheart

Sorry, dont really understand the difference between demo and beta

[QUOTE="LegatoSkyheart"]

Demo?

dude that was the Beta.

ihsanqueen

Sorry, dont really understand the difference between demo and beta

Guess what? SW is doomed!!:lol:

Seriously, just look at the thread about MAG, almost 90% of SW user said this game gonna flop because of the demo

Yeah, I know the demo was *meh but I still think Zipper still can improve the game, hope it'll get much better when it's released

So, here I am hyping MAG scored AAA here on GS because its gonna be fun if it's true:lol:

And hey, dont forget it's 256 players + PS3 exclusive + awesome boxart (just kidding)!!

ihsanqueen

[QUOTE="BPoole96"]Hmm, sound like AAA to meAgentA-Mi6

lol it will probably get a 7-8.0. Anything higher than that seems unreasonable unless the Beta is nothing like the actual game (which wouldn't even make sense)

Now I want it to do so just to see the chaos.

Demo?

dude that was the Beta.

LegatoSkyheart

there will be a demo in janurary

MAG won't even get AA. That game sucks.

It won't.comeonthehoops

But I wouldn't expect anything less than AAE. And that would be great.

it really wouldn't be suprisinq with the way qamespot hands out AAAEs to the PS3.(not that some aren't deservinq)

Graphically I don't think it was that bad. It looks better than cod4 for example.

The controls were comfortable and gameplay was fun, but there was something missing. It felt like 9vs9 and not 128vs128... they just split the game up. Not what I hoped.

it really wouldn't be suprisinq with the way qamespot hands out AAAEs to the PS3.(not that some aren't deservinq)

manny280

Graphically I don't think it was that bad. It looks better than cod4 for example.

The controls were comfortable and gameplay was fun, but there was something missing. It felt like 9vs9 and not 128vs128... they just split the game up. Not what I hoped.

Ultimaspooges

Don't worry. It's a 6.5 game... tops.

Seriously it is horrible. Horrible graphics, horrible sound, stiff controls, boring shooting mechanics. 256 players is a gimmick. BFBC 2 is miles ahead of it.

Wasdie

:o wow, I've never heard such strong negative comments about a game from a mod before.

[QUOTE="Wasdie"]

Don't worry. It's a 6.5 game... tops.

Seriously it is horrible. Horrible graphics, horrible sound, stiff controls, boring shooting mechanics. 256 players is a gimmick. BFBC 2 is miles ahead of it.

playharderfool

:o wow, I've never heard such strong negative comments about a game from a mod before.

Being a mod does not mean forsaking opinions.

I'm all for great games in the industry, so if this is good enough to warrant AAA status bring it on.

But I must say that even if it does achieve a AAA rating I will be staying away from this.

[QUOTE="Ultimaspooges"]

Graphically I don't think it was that bad. It looks better than cod4 for example.

The controls were comfortable and gameplay was fun, but there was something missing. It felt like 9vs9 and not 128vs128... they just split the game up. Not what I hoped.

Panther501

MAG WILL NOT SCORE AAA! sorry to say but this game was the reason I decided to buy another ps3 but I played in the beta And Gamestop exclusive beta and I wasn't impressed. My guess it will score around a 7 from what I played it was pretty etertaining seems like a solid shooter but in no way is it groundbreaking just bc of the 256 player concept zipper has going on. Regardless its a day one for me! the gun customization is something i really like in fps and I think all FPS's should implement that kind of thing it adds so much replay value plus its eye candy. gold guns in cod4 added about an extra day worth of replay value for me

[QUOTE="playharderfool"]

[QUOTE="Wasdie"]

Don't worry. It's a 6.5 game... tops.

Seriously it is horrible. Horrible graphics, horrible sound, stiff controls, boring shooting mechanics. 256 players is a gimmick. BFBC 2 is miles ahead of it.

789shadow

:o wow, I've never heard such strong negative comments about a game from a mod before.

Being a mod does not mean forsaking opinions.

lol he said 256 players is a gimmick...most ambitious "gimmick" i've seen anyone attemp for online games this gen

I wont say any more except opinions can be telling.

[QUOTE="Wasdie"]

Don't worry. It's a 6.5 game... tops.

Seriously it is horrible. Horrible graphics, horrible sound, stiff controls, boring shooting mechanics. 256 players is a gimmick. BFBC 2 is miles ahead of it.

playharderfool

:o wow, I've never heard such strong negative comments about a game from a mod before.

[QUOTE="playharderfool"]

[QUOTE="Wasdie"]

Don't worry. It's a 6.5 game... tops.

Seriously it is horrible. Horrible graphics, horrible sound, stiff controls, boring shooting mechanics. 256 players is a gimmick. BFBC 2 is miles ahead of it.

789shadow

:o wow, I've never heard such strong negative comments about a game from a mod before.

Being a mod does not mean forsaking opinions.

MAG will be a 8.0

[QUOTE="playharderfool"]

[QUOTE="Wasdie"]

Don't worry. It's a 6.5 game... tops.

Seriously it is horrible. Horrible graphics, horrible sound, stiff controls, boring shooting mechanics. 256 players is a gimmick. BFBC 2 is miles ahead of it.

CannedWorms

:o wow, I've never heard such strong negative comments about a game from a mod before.

But do you think 256 players is a "gimmick" tho?

I'm pretty sure I've been modded for trolling saying alot less than that.

I think cross game chat for xbl is a gimmick but I don't put that opinion on blast because I know some other people think that's a novel feature. If people are allowed to spam the tag word "gimmick"on everything they choose not to find impressive then this place will be over run with unrealistic projections that don't acknoledge truly notable acheivements of games and consoles.

There is no way MAG will scores AAA. It will be AA at best, my guess would be A (7.5).Tykain

lol, I swear I just had a flash back, or maybe deyavuz

I'm sure I've seen a post just like this somewhere else before...all you have to do is take out the word MAG and replace it with Demon's Souls

I don't know what MAG will score but I think it's pretty cool of them to "try" something this ambitious.

GS (and any other site that scores MAG highly) would lose their remaining shreds of credibility.

I know this is all prefaced by the beta caveat, but the MAG beta was truly horrible. The graphics were terrible, the sound was terrible, the game was poorly designed/balanced, and only a handful of players owned mics (let alone used them). The game needs another 4-6 months in the oven (at least) yet it's just gone gold, so I can't imagine it scoring higher than a 7 (and that's being optimistic).